File: 1567692003661.png (2.00 MB, 1920×1080, 2cool4school.png)
/mlp/:FiM S06E21 - Sounds of Silence Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)14:00:03 No.34264633
For the last few days, there has been a sentiment among some anons here, wishing that seasons 8 and 9 had never existed. A repeated comment these days was that Sounds of Silence was the only thing worth saving out of these last two seasons, and there was some joking about how it should simply replace a previous episode to make those seasons easier to forget.
Unfortunately, even though it's irrelevant to the plot, the School of Friendship appears for like two seconds in the opener, and again with the theme song, so the episode would have to be "fixed" before being moved to a previous season.
Well, here's an edited version of Sounds of Silence, 100% School-free, replacing both the opening shot and the intro with scenes without the School.

https://mega.nz/#!CjhFzCAA!Rxrd1MMUnqQavirhiRfIC4JEaCSKQ5m-U6VboUErDuQ

This edit isn't supposed to be "definitive" or anything, it's only the reminder that there are things worth saving in this show. Something as simple as watching this episode in the middle of season 6 during a rewatch would make it easier to stop at Shadow Play/the Movie/whatever, knowing that there isn't anything worthy later. And being able to stop without being reminded of the school will probably make the show more enjoyable to many people.
Maybe after this edit more people will have more ideas to make the show better, I think it was worth a shot.
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)14:01:08 No.34264639
File: 1567413670538.webm (3.00 MB, 240×272, soulless vs less soulless.webm)
Here's a preview of the first 2 minutes of the edit, compared to the tainted version. Keep in mind that these are the only changes in the video, everything after the logo stays the same.

For the record, the edit was done with TMPGEnc MPEG Smart Renderer, so only the parts that were different (and a couple of frames around the clip points) had to be reencoded. Everything else was simply copied, so the quality of this video is identical to the original most of the time. To help with the immersion, the episode number has been updated accordingly in the metadata using the same version of MKVToolNix that YayPonies used in 2016, and the mkv was edited to add the subtitles as optional tracks, like YayPonies used to do in season 6.

I had to use an old episode number for the edit, but when people talked about moving SoS to a different season, no one specified which episode should be removed. I ended up choosing this episode but, as I said, this isn't meant to be a definitive change, and anyone interested in this idea is absolutely free to use a different episode. Anyway, just for interest, here are my reasons to choose this episode:
Sounds of Silence specifically mentions Viva Las Pegasus, so the edit had to be placed after S06E20. For convenience, it would also be appropriate that the establishing shot of the removed episode had the Castle of Friendship. Finally, season 6 is usually considered worse than season 7, so having an extra good episode probably would make the season more enjoyable. ELTSD checks all the boxes, more so it's often considered a turning point since some people started disliking Starlight here. All in all, even though this was a sudden decision, I think I did the right thing.

That's pretty much it. Enjoy.
Fuck seasons 8 and 9. Fuck the School of Friendship.
Fuck Josh Haber, fuck Nicole Dubuc, and fuck Jim Miller.
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)14:23:37 No.34264694
>>34264633
Neat

Here's a mirror
https://iwiftp.romesilvanus.io/Pony/Episodes/%E2%81%84mlp%E2%81%84%20%E1%8D%A1FiM%20S06E21%20-%20Sounds%20of%20Silence/
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)14:30:22 No.34264716
>>34264633
Interesting project, anon. SoS is one of my favorite episodes from the later seasons. Giving it a download.
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)14:32:17 No.34264721
File: 1418011133457.jpg (72.00 KB, 600×542, 1548431721784.jpg)
>>34264633
>>34264639
NICE, thank you anon
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)14:32:33 No.34264723
>>34264694
Thanks Rome, I love ya.
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)14:49:16 No.34264778
i miss brony autism
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)14:54:26 No.34264796
>>34264633
You autism and dedication to improving the series is appreciated.
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)14:54:43 No.34264801
File: 1500454470837.png (116.00 KB, 1000×1000, 1267551.png)
>>34264633
>S06E21
good riddance too
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)14:55:29 No.34264804
Based Rainbow Nerd
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)14:56:32 No.34264810
Now remove the school and student shits from Best Gift Ever
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)14:58:45 No.34264819
Wait, how can you put it in S6 if Twilight mentions Rockhoof?
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)15:04:15 No.34264826
Nice. I like this kind of initiative!
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)15:07:01 No.34264832
season 8 was okay
season 9 was okay
the finale's when it became so bad
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)15:19:06 No.34264865
File: 1558992033668.png (783.00 KB, 1100×876, 1565769692742.png)
>>34264832
>Season 8 and 9 okay
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)15:20:11 No.34264866
>>34264633
>>34264639
>>34264694
Anon... I would give you a hug and contemplate a chaste kiss. And I'm not a faggot.
Sounds of Silence was the only jewel in the dumpsterfire
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)15:21:58 No.34264871
>>34264832
No, Anon. The Epilogue was so fucking dogshit it makes you wish there were 10 more shitty s9 episodes to slog through, or filing your back teeth for an hour. Again, aside from the episode written by OURGUY Confalone, it was awful. We really don't deserve him.
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)15:23:43 No.34264879
>>34264865
>Posts a character exclusive to those seasons
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)15:25:45 No.34264891
>>34264832
S9 had one good episode. One. And that was heavily inspired by the voice actors.
Most of the rest is bad or terrible with a few mediocre episodes sprinkled in.
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)15:27:35 No.34264898
>>34264832
The only episode I'd call okay was Frenemies, and that one was rendered completely pointless by the finale.
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)15:30:05 No.34264911
>>34264832
I respectfully disagree.
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)15:31:56 No.34264919
Holy shit this is based
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)15:34:55 No.34264924
File: 1567697695466.jpg (28.00 KB, 486×302, images.jpg)
>This thread's level of cope and seething
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)15:36:07 No.34264927
Remember: everything can be fixed with proper software, time and dedication. It's not a movie with real actors.
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)15:37:33 No.34264931
>>34264633
Anon, what if we liked Legion of Doom from S9? How do we skip the school and Cozybuse?
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)15:38:05 No.34264935
>>34264633
I would also save Break Up breakdown as one of the few good things in S8
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)15:39:08 No.34264940
>>34264832
Nah. Season 8 and 9 were garbage beside some Confalone and Vogel episodes
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)15:39:44 No.34264944
File: 1556759086138.jpg (52.00 KB, 380×333, 1559786295755.jpg)
>>34264924
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)15:41:16 No.34264950
File: 1567589024189.gif (1024.00 KB, 350×262, 45966586.gif)
>>34264944
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)15:41:50 No.34264953
>>34264633
This is autistic and that's an important episode for Starlight. Starlight didn't even actually get that many episodes in season 6.
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)17:26:19 No.34265295
>>34264898
Twilights Seven was great, the whole season was just up and down with extremes. Uprooted should have never existed but there was some good episodes in s8-s9 same as any other.

If anyone wants to take a more ambitious edit then try to remove the s9 numuzzles and return it to the original style.
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)17:28:51 No.34265308
>>34265295
I want to watch the CMC episode but the numuzzles turned me off so much I couldn't make it 3 minutes
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)17:29:22 No.34265310
File: 1509307481296.png (521.00 KB, 1274×1024, 4353324.png)
>>34264633
You're doing Celestia's work
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)17:30:30 No.34265317
>>34265308
autism.
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)17:31:19 No.34265318
>>34265317
>Semen sucking hasdrone
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)17:32:45 No.34265325
>>34265318
if you already watched s9 episodes that had the nu facerig then theres no reason you cant watch more than 3mins of another. you just have crippling autism
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)17:45:17 No.34265377
>>34265295
Sparkle's Seven felt like it aired 7 seasons too late and was just another filler episode.
Like 3 princesses, 5 EoH and teachers and a prince and captain of the royal guard have nothing better to do than play CTF in their castle.
Plus it had this weird part of fixing/retconning Spike's role in the Sparkle family.
The good things I can say about it are that it was still one of the better episodes this season, even if that doesn't say much in this case, and was written by the VAs, proving that everyone else is more qualified than the nu-writers.

Still, I thought it took away a spot for a potential significant episode, back when I still believed they'd use the last season to tie up all the loose ends, and ultimately did nothing of any relevance compared to Frenemies, which set up the villain redemption arc that, as I said, was rendered pointless by the finale.
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)18:11:38 No.34265477
>>34265377
they didnt spend enough time with the villains but i dont think anything is gained by losing Twilights 7. The sisters vacation episode was fine too, and Angelshy was just a retread lesson of when Starlight swapped the cutiemarks of the sisters but still enjoyable unlike when they used the recycled lesson

Theres way more episodes deserving to be gutted like when the Yaks are involved. I used to be ok with them when they were first introduced but ever since they shoved it down our throats just are an eyesore, actively damaging show the lessons because yaks exist like when pinkie got a yak instrument.
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)18:53:02 No.34265631
File: 1424639783402.gif (2.00 MB, 308×214, thumb.gif)
>>34264633
>>34264639
Excellent work, anon.
Very well done.
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)19:31:44 No.34265749
>>34264633
Well that's filled my autism quota for today
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)19:44:56 No.34265794
>>34264633
Can probably drop half of S6 and S7 while you're at it.
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)19:55:08 No.34265829
File: 1432335364842.gif (2.00 MB, 445×619, 1484278947349.gif)
>>34264633
>>34264639
Good shit. You've saved the kirin from the cancer of S8.
>>
Anonymous 09/05/19(Thu)21:00:54 No.34266153
File: 1566585620431.png (169.00 KB, 1000×1000, 1553700717551.png)
>>34264633
Mega based.
>>
Anonymous 09/06/19(Fri)03:32:02 No.34268216
File: 1418589292911.jpg (324.00 KB, 844×958, 1557586836538.jpg)
Bump.
>>
Anonymous 09/06/19(Fri)07:11:16 No.34268878
File: 1567753876796.jpg (154.00 KB, 625×833, 229685.jpg)
>accepting season 6 as canon
Guys, what if the School, and the students, and all the asinine episodes in seasons 8 and 9, and turning Discord into a psychopath, and the retarded finale, and everything was just part of an elaborate plan to make us like Glimmer, or at least hate her a bit less now that we know that there are so much worse things after her?
Because it's unironically working for me.
>>
Anonymous 09/06/19(Fri)07:34:33 No.34268922
File: 1567755273899.jpg (69.00 KB, 650×650, My-Little-Toy.jpg)
>>34268878
I think plan was to get rid of all adult fans. After all you normally don't buy their shit-tier toys while you damage their reputation by mere existing.
>>
Anonymous 09/06/19(Fri)07:47:14 No.34268943
>>34268922
>ugly as shit toy
>proportions, body and faces aren't anywhere near show accurate
>maker doesn't even know how horse articulations work
Do the old fat incompetent fucks managing Hasbro even realize the amount of money they are losing by not putting *any* pretense of care in their products ?
>>
Anonymous 09/06/19(Fri)08:10:08 No.34268981
File: 1567377470832.jpg (232.00 KB, 2048×1152, 2127562.jpg)
>>34268943
>"Anons don't understand anything in our business. We, Hasbro, know that we can make tons of money on low standards of children! There is no need to care in anything, because children will eat any poop that we puke out. What does phrase "All the best to the children" mean? Don't they know that children are worthless subhumans that deserve nothing? I thought we already demonstrated that it's not true in our finale of the show."
>>
Anonymous 09/06/19(Fri)08:33:11 No.34269033
>>34264633
Thanks for your effort anon, much appreciated.
>>
Anonymous 09/06/19(Fri)08:52:22 No.34269060
>>34264633
>>34264639
Whoa. This is pretty neat.
>>
Anonymous 09/06/19(Fri)09:19:07 No.34269121
>>34264639
Good effort on not wanting continuity issues with Viva Las Pegasus but how did you immediately disregard the massive continuity clash of Twilight talking about Rockhoof telling her about the Peaks of Peril and its legend?
He only really shows up in the season 7 finale
>>
Anonymous 09/06/19(Fri)11:32:59 No.34269330
File: 1425848882957.jpg (100.00 KB, 724×587, 227503.jpg)
>>34269121
Damn. How would you fix it?
I was bored and I made some terrible mockups.
https://streamable.com/eigzd
https://streamable.com/124et
>>
Anonymous 09/06/19(Fri)00:55:24 No.34269489
File: 1505228289493.jpg (36.00 KB, 693×583)
>The fact they gave twilight a different height as an alicorn to prevent simply editing the wings out.
Meghan knew everyone would hate it. She fucking knew.

I really hope the men who leaked the last episodes in English can leak the animation and flash files so episodes can be reanimated to correct that error. Won't fix the bad writing and characterization, but it's a start.
>>
Anonymous 09/06/19(Fri)14:41:36 No.34269793
>>34264633
So I noticed that they massively cut down on songs in the later seasons.

It got me wondering, what exactly drove them to lower the shows quality over 6,7,8,9?
>>
Anonymous 09/06/19(Fri)15:32:29 No.34269979
File: 1567783949980.png (72.00 KB, 602×737, jim saddle arabia twitter.png)
>>34269793
Good question, for the last few seasons it might have been due to resources being diverted towards G5.
Also the TV ratings went down heavily and I don't buy the streaming meme as an excuse.
One thing besides the decline of songs that pissed me off especially was not showing Saddle Arabia in Road to Friendship or any other episode simply because
>it would require effort.
>>
Anonymous 09/06/19(Fri)15:50:33 No.34270024
>>34269979
>it would require effort.
"No effort" is a Hasbro's slogan.
>>
Anonymous 09/06/19(Fri)17:26:23 No.34270333
>>34269979
and yet jim demands praise for all the hard work that he and his team have put into this show
>>
Anonymous 09/06/19(Fri)17:41:02 No.34270384
File: 1418685746974.png (14.00 KB, 450×450, 1567784469303.png)
>>34264633
based as fuck anon

>>34269330
yeah, that works pretty well. I was going to suggest finding another scene of alicorn twi talking next to the map, but that's pretty damn good as is
>>
Anonymous 09/06/19(Fri)18:13:03 No.34270536
>>34269979
>it wasn't in the script
>in the epilogue big mac was supposed to have 3 kids and rarity should've only had the grey hair and looked the exact the same otherwise
Wow Jim great moves!
>>
Anonymous 09/06/19(Fri)22:05:00 No.34271584
>>34269979
>One thing besides the decline of songs that pissed me off especially was not showing Saddle Arabia in Road to Friendship or any other episode simply because >it would require effort.
Are you going to tell me that it would have lived up to your expectations, especially with the Miller/Haber/Vogel/McCarthy quartet being in control?
>>
Anonymous 09/06/19(Fri)23:12:06 No.34271925
File: 1558902754783.png (1024.00 KB, 1920×1080, fetlockfeteedition.png)
I did something similar a while back with She's All Yak. In it, Twilight talks about the Fetlock Fete as a Ponyville tradition and immediately erases the name because it's problematic to the nonponies. What's interesting is that most of the dialogue still refers to the original name so if you erase the initial scenes and make a few cuts, it flows really smoothly. Only questionable scenes are Rarity saying "Or whatever Twilight is calling it." I also left in one reference of Twilight referring to it as the amenity ball but if you take Sandbar saying it's a whole night of dances, it fits without any real questions.

https://pastebin.com/JC6g5Q7x
>Removed Scenes
>Scene 1
Twilight Sparkle: You don't need to do that, Ocellus. This year, the event's at school and open to everycreature. We're calling our dance the Amity Ball.
Ocellus: Even better!
Yona: Yona not know Amity Ball dance.
>Scene 2
Spike: Hello, everycreature! I'm your DJ, Scales-n-Tail, spinning your favorite tunes all night long! So welcome to the Fetlock Fet— I mean, the Amity Ball!
>Scene 3
Twilight Sparkle: From now on, it's the annual Amity Ball Award for Friendship!
Applejack: No pony-ness required.
>>
Anonymous 09/06/19(Fri)23:30:32 No.34272022
>>34271925
But anon, editing SoS worked because it only had ponies and a cute and interesting new species in it.
Trying to fix a students episode seems rather pointless, it will always suck unless you cut like 95% off it.
>>
Anonymous 09/06/19(Fri)23:32:17 No.34272031
>>34264633
Twilight's Seven is it for me. Sounds of Silence still had Applejack and Fluttershy being total asshats to each other and nothing can fix that. Appreciate your efforts though.
>>
Anonymous 09/06/19(Fri)23:50:12 No.34272091
>>34272022
I still had hope for season 9 when I did it. It did have potential up until The Last Crusade and The Last Laugh completely shat the bed on two important endings and only got worse from there there. Let's pray that the hacker secretly has flash production files for every or most episodes and will release them down the line. We could fix the entire fucking show with them. Beyond that I would love to see someone edit out every single "everycreature" in season 8 and 9 and replace it with everyone.
>>
Anonymous 09/07/19(Sat)00:03:53 No.34272148
File: 1567814633581.png (745.00 KB, 1280×720, newspaper.png)
I'll just leave this here...
>>
Anonymous 09/07/19(Sat)00:04:57 No.34272154
>>34272148
Big deletion request on that shit.
>>
Anonymous 09/07/19(Sat)00:06:34 No.34272163
File: 1418168185419.jpg (225.00 KB, 682×600, 1365175197225.jpg)
>>34272154
>tfw derpibooru will commit suicide
>>
Anonymous 09/07/19(Sat)00:09:21 No.34272172
File: 1431897102971.jpg (318.00 KB, 1920×1080, 105739.jpg)
>>34272163
And nothing of value was lost
>>
Anonymous 09/07/19(Sat)00:51:46 No.34272375
>>34272148
Now we just need someone to edit the scene of Discord, Celestia, and Luna to be of them teleporting the trio into the rubble of Canterlot Castle with mops and brooms.
>>
Anonymous 09/07/19(Sat)00:56:54 No.34272398
File: 1404112557488.jpg (47.00 KB, 500×500, happyflutters.jpg)
>>34272148
Okay, now this is based
>>
Anonymous 09/07/19(Sat)01:00:55 No.34272412
>>34272148
I can provide a higher quality frame with the newspaper, but first I need an unedited, hi res frame.
Then someone with skills can replace it in the epilogue.
>>
Anonymous 09/07/19(Sat)03:32:27 No.34273092
File: 1567827147309.jpg (81.00 KB, 600×454, Modern_Problems_Require_Modern_S (...).jpg)
>>34264633
>>34264639
>>34269330
>>34270384
>>34271925
>>34272148
>>
Anonymous 09/07/19(Sat)09:31:25 No.34274204
>>34272148
Woah
>>
Anonymous 09/07/19(Sat)17:29:02 No.34275976
>>34272148
top kek, implement this
>>
Anonymous 09/07/19(Sat)22:40:19 No.34277562
>>34269979
Classic case of artists getting lazy?
>>
Anonymous 09/07/19(Sat)23:41:04 No.34277925
I wonder if Lauren and Larson read his tweets and if yes, how much they want to punch this fag in the face.
>>
Anonymous 09/08/19(Sun)03:58:31 No.34279239
>>34264633
Thanks, I appreciate the effort.
>>
Anonymous 09/08/19(Sun)05:43:51 No.34279727
>>34268922 Been screaming this for years anon, and people always get asshurt when I say it. Any pretense of otherwise should have been killed by Fame and Misfortune.
>>34268943 Let me tell you something anon: On the executive level, business is no longer about making money, it is about control.
>>
Anonymous 09/08/19(Sun)00:34:26 No.34280707
>>34268922
Someone willing to edit all of S4 and after to replace her alicorn model with her unicorn one?
>>
Anonymous 09/08/19(Sun)17:07:56 No.34281788
bump
>>
Anonymous 09/08/19(Sun)21:45:15 No.34283179
>>34264633
Nice!
>>
Anonymous 09/09/19(Mon)00:18:46 No.34284052
>>34265477
>i couldn't learn a friendship lesson because i was reminded of the existence of yaks
>>
Anonymous 09/09/19(Mon)05:56:53 No.34285133
>>34284052
Yep, you just described Yona's role in the show in one sentence.
>>
Anonymous 09/09/19(Mon)18:12:18 No.34286953
>Page 11
>>
Anonymous 09/09/19(Mon)22:08:19 No.34287965
>>34264633
>>34264639
Based as fuck