>Sweetie belle
>Looking after her alone while big sister rarity is away.
>Make sure she's well fed with healthy meals
>play games with her all day
>Give her snacks when she's been well behaved
>she wants for nothing when you're with her

>Lie on sofa reading a story to her
>she falls asleep resting her head on your chest
>softly stroke her hair out of her face
>run your hands down her back.
>gentle brush away her tail
>rub your fingers along her slit
>play with her soft inexperienced folds
>she's dry.
>bring your finger out and lick it
>tastes like vanilla
>delicately slide your fingers back into place
>you could never hope to get your dick inside such a tight hole
>you can only fingerfuck her as she sleeps
>with each breath she takes you slip your wet finger deeper inside her marehood
>she starts to squirm uncomfortably as you get your finger tip insider her soft unsullied pussy.
>you gently stroke her mane and whisper to her to relax
>you flex your finger up and down in time with her breathing
>you can feel her heart racing
>a pained frown is forming on her face in her sleep.
>she wakes up
>you finger still inside her
>she starts to panic trying to lift herself up off you
>you hold her down with one arm
>she's begging you to stop
>she's in so much pain
>you unceremoniously slide your finger farther inside her tight virgin hole
>She cries and screams in pain and hits you with her soft hooves
>Your finger breaks her hymen and she stops trying to fight you and just focuses on the pain trying to block it out your mind.
>Your finger now fully insider hilts, so you just leave it there insider her
>Sweetie belle looks at you through bloodshot tears
>you can see how betrayed and in how much pain she feels from her eyes alone
>"If you tell anyone about this, I will do this to your sister, then kill her
>She collapses on your chest sobbing in agony as you fuck her virginity away with your finger leaving her a bloody sweaty mess in the middle of rarity's shop.