Title:           A Night to Remember (Pinkie x Anon) *LONG* By PastafromSpace
Author:          PonyPronGuru
Pastebin link:   http://pastebin.com/hbEVtUMm
First Edit:      Saturday 21st of February 2015 08:18:16 PM CDT
Last Edit:       Last edit on: Friday 27th of March 2015 02:21:21 PM CDT

>You slowly push open Pinkie's bedroom door
>It makes a slight creak and you hesitate for a bit
>She doesn't respond, so you push it open just enough to sneak in
>You tiptoe over to a bed
>There's a rustling in the corner, but when you turn to look you see nothing
>You take a deep breath and grab the covers
>it_begins.png
>You yank the covers aside
>There's no Pinkie, just a pile of basketballs
>Wut
>Someting pounces down on you from behind
>you fall onto the bed on your back, Pinkie on top of you
>Heeey  Nonny~! What were you up to?"
>You have no idea what to say
>"You know, you don't have to sneak in Nonny..."
>She leans in real close, whisperring in your ear
>"You could have just asked~"
>She quickly pulls a cupcake out of her nightstand drawer and stuffs it in your mouth
>She giggles watching you trying to choke it down
>"Teehee, how do you like special 'Night-time Party Cupcake' recipe?"
>Wait, special night-time party cupcak-
>....
>In almost an instant, you drift off to sleep against your will
 
>You wake up in Pinkie's bed, still night time
>You can't remember much, but...
>Wait, did you really do it last night? Did you really rape Pinkie
>...if you did, why are YOUR arms tied to the bedposts?
>And why are your pants still down?
>Pinkie climbs up onto the bed over you
>"Ready for the REAL party, Nonny~?"
 
"Hey Pinkie... what's going on?"
>"You tell me, you were the one planning something funny last night~"
>You try to budge, but she's got you tied down pretty good
>Don't worry Nonny, I won't stray too far from your little plan."
>And with that, she crawls down so her face is at your crotch
>She somehow manages to unbutton and unzip your pants with her mouth
>She notices how surprised you are
>"Yeah... I practiced."
>She pulls your pants down with her front hooves
>Well this is awkward....
>You don't even have a boner
>"Come on Nonny... just relax and have fun, like I do."
>She presses her soft muzzle against your crotch
>Yeah... yeah, that's working for you
>Before the dong finishes expanding, she opens her mouth and takes your half-erect member into her mouth
>Once you're fully hard she starts brushing her tongue against your dick
>She presses her hooves down on your waist and starts bobbing her head up and down
>With each movement you feel her soft fur brushing you on the outside, and the warm wet tongue rubbing you inside her mouth
>You feel yourself reaching you limit already
>You dick is throbbing in her mouth, about to release
>When she abruptly pulls out
>Damn....
>She lingers her face over your crotch, her hot breath actually feels good against you
>"Silly Nonny... the party can't end just yet."
>She crawls up to meet your face with hers
>Your dick brushes through her soft fur, down her torso and between her back legs
>"Time to have some REAL fun~"
 
>She presses her soft pussy down on you
>The sound of you gasping at the sudden move gets a giggle out of her
>Her hips start slowly grinding against you
>Her bristly fur scrubs you and you feel her get more and more damp
>Both yours and her breath gets heavier
>The pressure of her pressing down on you, the warmth pf her pussy against you
>It makes you wish you could be inside her at this moment
>Maybe.....
>You start to press your hips up against hers, trying to slide inside her
>She catches on pretty quick
>"Nonny, what are you trying to pull there?"
"Umm... n-nothing."
>She smiles lewdly down at you
>"Admit it... you want to be inside, don't you"
>Well, she caught you. Nothing to hide now
"Y-yeah..."
>"Well, maybe I'll let you just this once..."
>She leans in real close, her face almost against yours
>"...maybe in you beg for it."
 
>She really knows how to get under your skin
>You never expected to be on this end of the situation... not that you're complaining
>You try to think of a way to 'beg for it' that won't release too much spaghetti
"Pinkie... please..."
>She boops your noose with her hoof
>"Please whaaat~?""
"P-lease.... let me fuck you."
>.....
>She bursts into laughter
>So much for minimal spaghetti
>"HAHAHA! S-sorry Nonny, it's just.. you sounded so silly!"
>She wipes a tear from her eye and manages to regain her composure, save for the occasional giggle
>You'd think that would have killed your boner, but...
>Damn, you actually want it more than ever
>"Don't worry, I always keep my promises~"
>She lifts her back legs up enough for your dick to stand up
>With her hoof she holds you in place as she slowly slides down...
>And down...
>And down.....
>You're all the way inside her
>She holds her body still for a moment, though her pussy twitches and squeezes down on you
>You feel your whole body tingle as the warmth of her insides wraps around your dick
>She starts bouncing her ass up and down
>Her soft, squishy plot presses against your hips with each bounce
>Her body is warm and her bristly fur almost tickles to the touch
>Her voice slipping out in the form of an occasional quiet moan
>You start thrusting against her
>She gasps at the first push, and she presses her hooves down on your chest
 
>"H-hey... did I give you permission to move?"
>She stops moving her ass, but her body is shaking
>She leans down and kisses you, forcing her tongue into your mouth
>The two of you tongue wrestle in your mouth for a moment before she pulls away
>"You know how it works, if you want it you gotta beg!"
>This girl.... really, REALLY knows how to get to you
"Pinkie, please... I want to fuck you harder. I want to be your sex slave."
>A little off-scrpt there aren't you?
>Reel it in before she starts laughing again
 
>To your surprise, she doesn't find it funny... she finds it hot.
>Another kiss, her tongue once again forcing its way into your mouth
>Her ass is bouncing on you harder than before
>You feel like your hips are going to be crushed, in a good way
>You push yourself into her with each thrust
>Her breath gets heavier, and you can feel it against your face... smells like cupcakes
>Her hoof reaches out, looking for your hand
>Once she finds it, you grasp her hoof firmly
>"N-nonny..."
>She breaks the kiss, but doesn't pull too far away from your face
>You can better hear her moans, and you notice she calls out your name more than you thought
>She begins to tighten up a lot more, and you feel it in your whole body
>Along with the pleasure surging through your whole body, you can feel your cock squeezed harder
>It slides in and out with ease as she gets wetter and wetter
>"N-Nonny!"
>That was more than a moan, she was practically screaming
>She might be close... you and her both
>"Umff... y-yes..."
>She reaches her other hoof for your hand and you grasp it tightly
>One last squeeze, one last thrust, one last push
>"NONNY!"
>She screams out your name as you release your load deep inside her
>Her body twitches for a minute, unable to move or speak
>Se plops down on top of you
 
>She slowly unties each hand, and once you're free you embrace her
>She puts her hooves around you as best as she can
>The two of you lay together for almost an hour
"So Pinkie... you okay?"
>"...yeah, I think so."
>She giggles, and you can't help but smile
>She nuzzles your neck, then pulls away
>"Nonny, you should probably head back home. It'd be weird to be caught like this"
"Yeah, you're probably right."
>"Especially for you, trying to sneak into my room~"
>Another boop on the nose
>You get up and head out the door
 
>As you walkout the front door of Sugarcube Corner, she calls back to you
>"Hey Nonny! Wait up!"
>You turn around just in time for her to tackle you
>she throws her hooves around you and kisses your cheek
>She whispers in your ear
>"Leave your door unlocked in case I want to have some more fun~"
>You stand there in silence as she heads inside, waves to you, blows you a kiss, and shuts the door
>You're drained for the night
>You probably shouldn't leave your doors unlocked like she said
 
>.....
>You'll do it anyways
 
>You wake up the next morning in your own home
>Pinkie is cuddling up next to you
>She came back but not for sex... at least none that you can remember
>Does she sell those cupcakes at the shop? Does she use them on customers?
>... eh, whatever. It was fun anyways
>You get out bed trying not to wake her
>You grab some clothes from your closet
>Just a t-shirt and jeans, nothing special going on today
>"Where you going, Nonny?"
>She sits up in the bed, yawning and rubbing her eyes
"Just gonna take a shower. You can see yourself out whenever you-"
>"I'll join you!"
>She hops out of bed and bounces over to your side
"Pinkie, I appreciate it, but I don't think-"
>"Come on Nonny, it'll be fun!"
>She turns around to face you, a serious look on her face
>"Or do you want me to tell everypony about what you tried to do to me last night?"
>She slams her hoof on the ground
>Is she trying to blackmail you?
>It'd work much better if she could stop giggling
>You give in
"Alright Pinkie, come on."
>You head to the bathroom, her bouncing behind you
 
>The two of you walk into the bathroom, and she closes the door behind her
>And locks it
>You put your fresh clothes on top of the sink and turn on the shower
>You turn your back to Pinkie as you start undressing
>She gasps when you take your shirt off
>You look back and see her eagerly awaiting to see you naked
>Not surprising since you're the only human in this pony world, and the only one who wears clothing on a daily basis
>They all insist on you going naked, saying it's perfectly normal
>...but none more so than little Pink Ponk here
>You slowly undo your pants and drop them to the ground
>She giggles and tries to cover her face, blushing bright red
>Maybe this is your chance to get her back for 'raping' you last night
>You turn around suddenly as you pull your boxers down
>Your dick is only inches from her face
"Well Pinkie, are you ready?"
>You were going to grab her and pull her into the shower
>But she's already pushing you in
>The water was still cold, but Pinkie blocks your only way out
>You start to shiver
>"You look cold Nonny, maybe I should warm you up~"
>She embraces you with her hooves
>Despite the water being cold, her wet fur is as warm as her body
>She backs you up against the wall of the shower
>"Hey Nonny..."
>She says it in the most seductive voice she can
>The water has heated up so you can't expect a cold shower to scare off your boner
>She leans her face real close to your crotch, close enough for you to feel her breath
>....
>"GOTCHA!"
>Tickling out of fucking nowhere
 
>You struggle trying to keep still, but let's face it, if there were an Olympic tickling team she'd be captain
>As you would expect from all your struggling, you slip and fall down
>"NONNY! A-are you okay?"
>You don't respond, you just struggle trying to pick yourself up
>Your silence seems to worry her
>She puts a hoof on your shoulder
>"No no no, don't move, just relax!"
>She starts to panic
>"Should I get you anything? Should I call Twilight? Maybe she knows what to-"
>You put a finger to her lips to calm her down
>.... and to keep her from bringing Twilight
>Her eyes begin to water
>You prop yourself up on your elbows
"Listen Pinkie, don't worry about it. I'm okay"
>"I'm sorry Nonny... I didn't mean to-"
"I know, it's okay."
>She wipes her eyes, her bubbly smile and giggle are back
"Come on, help me up. I still have to actually wash myself."
>In case you forgot, showers are for cleaning yourself, not for horsey tickle attacks
>She puts a hoof on your chest and gently pushes down
>"No no, don't worry about it. I'll clean you."
>What
>She grabs the bottle of body wash in her mouth
>She squirts out a glob into her front hooves, throws the bottle aside, and starts rubbing you down
 
>She scrubs your whole body, the soap foaming up in her hooves
>She's extra gentle while washing your face
>She scrubs down your chest. down your stomach, down your legs
>Her hooves feel soft, almost soothing against your body
>You close your eyes and relax....
>"Hey Nonny, are you sure you're okay after that fall?"
"Yeah, why?"
>"It looks a little swollen right here."
>You open your eyes to see her pointing right at your erect penis
>....seriously, how did you not see that coming
>"Hey Nonny~ You wanna do it again don't you~"
>She giggles as she says that
"To be honest, I don't think I can really move right now."
>You meant it as a joke, but then again you are pretty sore
>"Interesting~"
>She presses your dick gently between her front hooves
>The soap has been all washed off
>She begins stroking you slowly
>You lean back and relax, just enjoying the moment
>Except for the whole 'in pain' thing
>As your breathing gets heavier, she strokes you faster
"....Pinkie..."
>A quiet moan slips out of you, and she giggles
>"You're so cute sometimes, Nonny."
>You can't help but chuckle yourself
>She leans down, bringing her face closer to your crotch
>Gimme a heads up before hand, okay?"
>She gives you a wink (with her eye)
>You know exactly what that means
 
>She opens her mouth and takes your head in
>Her warm tongue gently strokes back and forth
>You can feel every little bump of her tongue
>You reach out and stroke her mane, and she giggles again
>She takes you deeper into her mouth, about half way
>With every stroke of her tongue you feel yourself twitch
>It's not long before you realize you're at your limit
>... oh yeah, give her a heads up
"Pinkie.... I think I'm about to cum."
>As soon as you say that she pulls you out of her mouth
>....
>Pinkie pls
"Wh-why?"
>She smiles
>"No reason, I just love playing with you"
>She lets out a deep, heavy breath on your dick, and you feel the warmth through your whole body
>You lose control
>"It's so much fun teasing you Non-mmPh"
>You wait for the perfect moment to push her back down on your dick
>All you did was push down
>But she starts bobbing her head up and down completely on her own
>The more she gets into it, the sloppier she gets
>An occasional slurping sound slips out, and she even has to gasp for breath
>You pull your hand away from her head and lean back, enjoying the moment
>She lets out a quiet groan and pulls out again
>She looks up at you with a seductive look in her eyes
>A combined look of lewdness and desire... how you imagined you looked when she made you beg
>You put your hand back on her head and push her down
>Once again, she gets into it, taking you all the way to the base in her mouth
>You put the other hand on her head
>She lets out a moan, not of disappointment, but in pleasure
>You tense up and clench your fists
>She seems to enjoy the slight pull of her mane
>As you approach the big moment, you call out her name
"Pinkie... I'm almost there..."
>You almost expect her to pull out again...
>But no
>Instead she presses her face against your body, stroking your cock with her tongue
>She moans out loudly as you tug on her mane, and release your load down her throat
 
>She holds her face against your crotch until you're done releasing
>Then she very slowly pulls out
>When she pulls out, she leaves her mouth open
>Her mouth full of your cum, she hadn't swallowed any of it
>She wanted you to see
>It starts to drip out, but she wipes it up with her hoof
>She closes her mouth and swallows a few times, then licks the excess off her hoof
>Not a single drop wasted
>She finishes cleaning you, and you shampoo her whole body
>Save for a few giggles from her, the two of you do so in silence
>She got really ticklish when you started scrubbing her
You dry off, turn off the shower, and you get dressed
>"Hey Nonny, I gotta be at Sugarcube Corner for work in a bit... care to walk me there?"
"Of course, Pinkie."
>You ruffle her already puffy mane, and she smiles bigger than you've ever seen
 
>You reach your destination, and wave goodbye
>"I have some shopping to do later on."
"Let me guess, you want me to join you?"
>She nods excitedly
>"Meet me here later this afternoon!"
"Gotcha, see  you later."
>You wave goodbye as she heads inside
>.....
>You should have asked her if she sells those 'special cupcakes'.
>You'll get around to it
 
>Later that afternoon
>You walk into Sugarcube Corner
>Pinkie is behind the counter
>"Oh, hey! I was just finishing up, gimme just a minute."
>You patiently wait
>You notice a box of cupcakes on the counter
>They each have different color frosting, and are arranged to resemble a rainbow
>Of course
>Two of the blues seem darker than the rest. It reminds you of....
>They're her 'special night-time' cupcakes
>Someone's having fun tonight
>She walks back in and notices you eyeballnig the cupcakes
>She closes the box and ties it shut with a big red ribbon
"So you really do sell those special night-time cupcakes?"
>She blushes and turns away
>"Sorry Nonny, those aren't for you."
>She walks up to you
>"...but I'd gladly make a batch just for you~"
>She gives you a wink
>No idea how to respond there....
>"Come on Nonny, we gotta get going before all the shops close!"
>She grabs your arm and drags you out the door
 
>She drags you all over the marketplace
>You run from shop to shop, getting all sorts of groceries
>Ever since you introduced Equestria to spaghetti there have been more and more pasta stands
>...speaking of which, you're running low
>You try to stop, but Pinkie pulls you away
>"Come on Nonny, the lettuce shop is about to close!"
"Maybe if you hadn't spent an hour arguing with the tomato lady we'd have more tim-"
>You stumble over yourself, struggling to keep up
>You make it there in time and she buys her lettuce
>After haggling down the shopkeeper to half price
>It's time consuming but damn she's good
 
>After a long afternoon of running around the two of you finally stop to relax
>The two of you find a bench to sit down and rest
>You take her saddlebags off her back and set them on the floor
>You sit on the bench, and she hops up on it, resting her head on your lap
>You can feel her shivering
>Well it is getting late...
"You okay Pinkie?"
>"Yeah, I was just in such a hurry I forgot to grab my sweater."
>You sigh deeply.... you're too nice of a guy
>You take your jacket off and cover her up
>"T-thanks Nonny..."
>She pulls the jacket over her head
"You okay?"
>No response
>After a moment she pokes her head out
>"It smells like you... I like it."
>You pet her soft mane, and she relaxes her head back on your leg
>"Hey Nonny... you trust me, right?"
>You wonder what she means by that
"Yeah, I guess. Why?"
>She looks around, then smiles up at you
>The slides a hoof down your pants
 
"Pinkie, what are you doing?!"
>"Don't worry Nonny, no one's looking, I checked."
"Yeah, but what if someone does-"
>"You trust me.... right?"
>You sigh and nod your head
>Then don't worry, it'll be fine."
>It's not much, but you relax a little, enough to enjoy the situation
>You let out a deep breath as she starts rubbing up and down
>Your lap, and half her body, covered by your jacket, so you're not in plain view
>Then again, the bench is out in the middle of the marketplace
>Most of the shops are closed, there's only a few lingering ponies and shop owners, but still
>Her hoof is gently pressed against you as she strokes you in your pants
>She giggles, realizing how nervous you are
>She gives you a lewd smile, and tucks her head under the jacket
"W-whoah, Pinkie, what are you-"
>You get your answer when you feel her tongue against your head
>Your boner was peeking out the top of your pants giving her easy access
>Imagine how much trouble you'd be in if you were caught
>You'd probably be punished harder seeing as how you're not one of them
>.... the thought kind of makes it hotter
>You put your hand where you're sure her head is, and you whisper out her name
"...Pinkie..."
>.....
>Wait a sec. This isn't good
>You start shaking her head
"Pinkie, Pinkie."
>She thinks you're trying to push her head down
"Pinkie stop. Someone's coming!"
>She lunges her head out from under the jacket and giggles... if only you could be so carefree as her
>"Hey Pinkie, hey Anon. What're y'all doin out here this time of day?"
 
"H-hey Applejack, w-what are you up to?"
>Stuttering is the universal sign of totally not suspicious, right?
>"Oh nuthin, just finished closin' up shop for today. How about you two?"
>Gotta think of something
>It doesn't help that her hoof is still stroking you under the jacket
"U-umm..."
>"Oh nothing AJ, just giving Nonny some head"
>Did- did she really just say that?
>Applebutt just stares at you blankly, and quite frankly you can't do more than return the stare
>.....
>She bursts into an uncontrollable, snorty laugh
>You an AJ join her
>"Okay, well I gotta get back to the farm, y'all take care now."
>And with that, she trots off
 
>The two of you sit in silence for a while
>You finally decide to speak up
"That was a close call, Pinkie."
>"Yeah, but you gotta admit, it was pretty fun!"
>Can't argue there
>"Besides, I told you you could trust me right?"
"Yeah, you're right. Still... you need to be punished."
>"What?"
>You pull the jacket over to cover her butt without revealing your lap
>"Nonny, what are you do-"
>You reach over and give her flank a squeeze
 
>"H-hey Nonny! What are you-"
>You put a finger to her lips to keep her quiet
"Wouldn't want someone to hear us, now would we?"
>She nods her head 'no', unable to speak
>Her face is blushing bright red
>You slide your hand down that round, soft ass of hers and between her legs
>You press your index and middle fingers against her without inserting them
>"Mmh... Nonny.."
>The hoof in your pants begins to tremble, and her body starts to fidget
>One by one, the last few shops close down, and lights go out
>You continue to rub your fingers against her
>Once the last light goes dark, she whispers something
>"I-I.. think that's the last one"
>You smile down to her
"You know what that means?"
>"I-It's just you and me now, Nonny-YY!"
>She makes a sudden squeal as you push your fingers inside her
>She doesn't say anything after, she just shudders
>You curl up your fingers and rub her insides
>She quivers more and more at your touch, whatever you're doing you're doing right
>She undoes your pants to let your cock out
>Her other hoof starts stroking you, both moving faster than before
>You'd push her into a blowjob, but she just got her hooves moving at a steady rhythm
>Let's not ruin this feeling
>You feel her tighten around your fingers
>"Nonny... please..."
"What is it?"
>She pulls away from your hands, climbs down from the bench and lays in the grass on her back
>Her arms are stretched out for you, she wants you on top of her
>Without giving a second though you pounce on top of her
 
>As soon as you get yourself comfortable, you find your way inside her
>With one quick thrust, you push your whole dick inside her
>She gasps loudly, slurring out your name
>Shaking and trembling the whole time she does so
>You push yourself in and out of her, your pelvis pushing against hers
>The feel of her fur against your skin is soft and incredibly warm
>Her pussy is wet enough for you to easily slide in and out, but tight enough to cling to you with each pull
>Between your heavy breathing and her gasping and moaning, it's a miracle all of Ponyville doesn't hear you
>Not to mention all the lewd noises from between her legs
>You can feel her squeezing down, her warm insides clenching down on your cock
>It's as if she's sucking you back in every time you pull out>"Nonny... Nonny... NONNY!!!"
>She starts thrusting her hips against you as she screams out your name
>You run your fingers through her coat, from her legs up to her hooves
>...for some reason, you feel the need to hold her down
>Her face changes when you start to hold her down... the same look when you forced her head down in the shower
>She actually likes this
>A lot.
>You slam your hips against her harder and faster
>Her hot pussy twitches with each thrust
>You're getting there.... just a little more...
"P-Pinkie!"
>"NONNY!!!!"
>Just as you start to release inside her, your body suddenly jerks out
>You blow the rest of your load all over little Pinkie Pie's chest
 
>You lay down in the grass next to her
>She makes no effort to wipe your seed from her chest
>The two of you lay in silence, save for some heavy breathing, staring upp at the stars
>.....
 
>Of course this moment can't last very long
>You see a light approaching
"Shit. Pinkie, do you see where we can hide?"
>"No, but I got a plan."
>She grabs the jacket from the bench and puts it on
>At least she's covered the evidence... which is the most you can do now
>As the light gets closer, it calls out to you
>"....Pinkie Pie? Anonymous?"
>Only one pony still calls you by your full name
"Hello Twilight."
>She shines that horn light of her right in your eyes
>....bitch.
>"What are you two doing out so late?"
>"Oh nothing, Nonny took me out shopping a while ago, and we stopped to relax, and we kinda fell asleep."
>She adds a little giggle at the end. Nice touch.
"Yeah, what she said."
>She gives you a look
>Purple Smart doesn't believe you.... but she believes Pinkie
>"Okay, well be careful. You should head home soon Pinkie..."
>She shoots a sharp glare at you
"... You too Anonymous."
>With that, she turns her back and trots away
>....bitch.
 
>You walk Pinkie back to Sugarcube Corner
"Keep the jacket for now. I'll be fine."
>"Thanks, Nonny."
>She leans in and kisses your cheek, and slowly closes the door
>You should probably head home too
 
>It's been a few days since that night at the marketplace
>You and her haven't really had sex since then
>Maybe pony is no longer for sexual...
>Nah, you'll get around to it
 
>You're sitting at home watching some stupid crap on t.v.
>You'd change it but you can't find the remote
>Who the hell put the channel on 'Discovery Family' anyways?
>The phone rings, and you're more than happy to get up
"Hello, this is Anonym-"
>"Nonny! What are you doing?"
>Oh, it's Pinkie
>They really need to get caller I.D. out here
"Not really, I was just-"
>"Come down to Sugercube Corner!"
>She hangs up
>You know, it'd be nice of her to ASK if you had plans today
>....not that you did, but still
>You turn of the t.v. and head out
 
>You get to Sugarcube Corner
>Pinkie pokes her head out from the kitchen
>"In here!"
>You walk through into the kitchen and say hi to-
>Holy shit this kitchen is a mess
>"Great! You're just in time!"
"In time for what?"
 
>"Our picnic, silly!"
>wat
"You didn't say anything about a picnic today"
>"Well then it wouldn't be a surprise, now would it?"
"Well, uhh..."
>She's got you... kinda
>"I mean, if you're busy it's okay... I get it."
>She seems a little disappointed
>And to be honest, you have absolutely nothing going on
"Nah, I got nothing. Just surprised is all."
>"Then... that means..."
>She turns around, smiling bigger than usual, and starts hopping up and down
>"The surprise picnic was a success!!!"
>She hands you the picnic basket, which is much heavier than you expected
>"Come on, let's go!"
"Wait, you mean right now? As in, right now right?"
>"Yeah let's go!"
>She runs out the door, and you slowly follow behind
>Just as you step outside she runs back in
>"Forgot something!"
>Just as quick as she went in, she comes back out
>Carrying that cupcake box with the red ribbon
>The box with the 'special night-time party' cupcakes
>.... this will be a fun picnic
 
>She walks you all the way across Ponyville
>The two of you pass by... oh god.
>"Hey there Twilight! What are you up to today?"
>"Oh nothing. Just doing some... research. How about you?"
>"Nonny and I are headed out on a picnic!"
>"A picnic, huh? Well I'd love to join you, but..."
>She glares over at you
>"I have a lot of work to do"
>Her gaze could blow a hole in a brick wall
>She slowly turns around and walks away
>"Okay, bye Twilight!!!"
>Pinkie continues waving long after Twilight is gone
>You don't even offer her a tip of the fedora
"Pinkie... maybe we should get going before it gets late."
>"Omigosh you're right!"
>She grabs your arm and drags you along
 
>The journey goes on for longer than you thought you could handle
>You end up on the outskirts of town in a small field on the edge of a forest
>"Here's the spot! You like~?"
"It IS pretty nice out here."
>She smiles proudly
>You put the basket down and she puts the box of cupcakes
>You almost ask if a whole dozen is too much for just the two of you
>But then you remember.... you're here with Pinkie
>You lay out the blanket and sit down, and she sits next to you
 
>The two of you share a decent, although over-sized lunch
>As much as you miss meat, she makes a delicious veggie sandwich
>You burst into laughter when she takes out the sealed pitcher of pink lemonade
>She joins you in the laughter
>The laughing slowly dies down, mostly because you're both out of breath
 
>You both finish eating and pack up
"Hey Pinkie, the sun's going down, maybe we should head back soon."
>"What!"
>She's a little disappointed
>"But we haven't even had any cupcakes yet!"
"Don't worry, we can eat them when we get back."
>"Aww, but that's no fun."
>She unties the red ribbon and opens the box
>"Come on~ just one?"
>You give her a smile and a pat on the head
"Alright, just one. Only for you Pinkie."
>She happily presents the box to you
>Wait a sec....
>You recognize that ribbon
"Aren't these the one's with the 'special' cupcakes you made few nights ago?"
>"Don't worry Nonny, I made these fresh earlier today."
>That's not what troubles you
>What troubles you is that they all look the same
>"What's the matter Nonny? Do they look bad?"
"No no, its not that. It's just... you sure there aren't any special cupcakes in here?"
>She giggles, trying to hide her blushing face
>"Relax Nonny, they're normal cupcakes!"
>She grabs one and eats it in one bite... even the paper cup with it
>"See? Just fine!"
>...okay, you're convinced
>You're about to take a bite as she falls over onto the blanket
>You laugh it off, assuming she's joking
>No response
>You poke her belly
>No response....
>You slide a finger between her legs
>No response.....
>She's completely unconscious
 
>She just accidentally ate one of her own rape cupcakes
>At least, she's acting like it
>You roll her over onto her back
>Her legs spread open on their own
"Hey Pinkie... if you really are unconscious, then you can't really fight back..."
>You lean over her and whisper in her ear
"...no matter what I do."
>No response
>You honestly had no idea what you were going to do, you just wanted a reaction
>Maybe... you've never done this before, but you'll have to figure it out eventually
>You lower your face between her legs, your nerves almost getting the better of you
>You pull yourself together
>Then you slowly drag your tongue along her pussy
>..... still no response
>She is REALLY unconscious
>If you wanted to, you could totally rape her right here and now....
 
>You look around
>It's getting dark, and there's no one around
>You pull your pants down and take them off
>You lay down on top of her and press yourself against her
>She feels damp, but that's probably just your saliva
>You run your fingers through her coat, up her chest and down
>A cold breeze blows through
>You cling to her but it doesn't help much
>So you take your shirt off and press your whole body down on her
>You can feel her warm body directly against you, a soothing relief from the cold
>Her bristly coat brushing against your body
>The breeze dies down, but you don't want to leave the warmth of her body
>Speaking of warmth, the whole time your dick is rubbing against her pussy
>You dont' want to hold back anymore
>You spread her legs wider, and push until you're inside
 
>As you first penetrate her, her legs twitch and she takes a sudden sharp breath
>... but she doesn't wake, so you keep pushing
>Her body gives up a lot of resistance, but you make it all the way inside
>You hold still for a moment
>It's less wet and much more tight, natural given the situation
>Almost too hard to even move
>You reach down and look for that right spot
>..... yup, that's her clit
>She may be unconscious, but she can still feel it
>Her pussy quivers the more you rub her clit
>It gets easier to pull out as she gets wetter
>Once you're able to slide in and out, you rest your hands on her shoulders and start thrusting
>As you push in, her body slides on the grass
>The harder you thrust, the more she slides
>...that's gonna burn when she wakes up
>Even in her sleep, she starts breathing heavier, and her insides twitch and tighten as you push
>As it gets easier for you to slide in and out, you start doing it harder
>Maybe a little too hard
>"N...Nonny?"
>Damn, she's waking up. Gotta think fast....
>The cupcakes
>You reach for the box and grab a cupcake out
>"Nonny... what are you mmH-"
>You hold the cupcake in her mouth, trying not to choke her
>"MMh..."
>She doesn't bite it, she just licks all the frosting off
>Her head turns away when all the frosting is gone
>Then she closes her eyes and drifts back into unconsciousness
>So it's in the frosting....
>Either way, now you know you have 10 more cupcakes worth of time with her
 
>You roll her over onto her stomach, she's surprisingly light
>You also help turn her head to the side so she can still breathe
>She quietly snores every once in a while
>She's so cute you can't tell if you should be raping her or pinching her cheeks and snuggling her
>You can do both, right?
>You grab her from behind and hug her tightly, burying your face in her mane
>Then you adjust yourself to shove your cock into her
>Something about fucking her from behind feels so much better
>Maybe it's the feel of your hips slamming against her soft fluffy rump
>Or maybe it's the deliciously sweet smell of her hair
>Or maybe it makes the rape feel more real
>Cause the drugged, unconscious body isn't enough apparently
>You thrust harder, making a loud slapping sound that echoes through the field
>Her breath gets heavier, the occasional snore mixed in with loud pants and gasps
>You grab her mane and start pulling, not that she feels it, it just makes things more fun
>You're sure she'd enjoy it anyways
>....what else would she enjoy?
>You spread her flank and gaze at her butthole
>You've never really seen it before because her ass is so round and perky and perfect in every way
>You gently press your pinky finger (lel) against her little hole
>It gives up quite a bit of resistance, but you eventually force your finger in her
>As it penetrates her backside, she lets out a sudden gasp
>Even without her consciousness, her body responds
>The deeper you push your finger, the tighter her pussy gets
>You can feel your own finger inside her against your dick
>You wiggle your finger in her asshole, and it makes her pussy twitch violently
>Oh God
>The moment sneaks up on you
>With a sudden, hard thrust, you push yourself to release your load deep inside her
 
>You roll over onto the ground next to her
>The sky is dark, only illuminated by the moon
>You really should be getting home, but you're exhausted
>There's no way you could carry yourself, let alone a pony
>You pull the blanket over yourselves
>The little mare next to you lets out a quiet groan, she's waking up
>She puts a hoof around you and nuzzles your neck
>You put an arm around her and close your eyes
>You shouldn't be sleeping out like this, but you'll be fine, right?
>.....
 
>You wake up the next morning next to her in the field
>You're in the same position you were last night, cuddling with Pinkie
>You don't want to wake her, so you just lay there
>Not that that it's all that bad
>"mmm... Nonny, is that you? Where are we?"
"Still here at the picnic site?"
>"Really?"
>She rubs her eyes
>"I have to get to Sugarcube Corner for work!"
>She tries to get up, but her legs give out
"Here, maybe I should walk you there."
 
>You pack up the blanket, grab the basket, then cradle her in your arms and walk home
>"Geez Nonny, what did you do last night, I could barely walk!"
"Sorry, I may have gotten a little carried away-"
>She kisses your cheek
>"Hey Nonny?"
"Yeah Pinkie?"
>"You should play with my butt more often~"
 
>You say nothing until you get her back to Sugarcube Corner
>"See you later Nonny! Feel free to stop by!"
>She waves energetically as you turn around and head home
>After a night outside in the grass, you could really use a shower
>....and an actual bed
 
>One week after the picnic
>You decided to take Pinkie out to dinner as a thanks
>You're all dressed up in your... semi-fancy suit
>You know, the one you wear when funposting online?
>Anyways....
>She said she'd meet you here at 8
>It's already 8:30 by the time she comes running up to you
>"Sorry I'm late Nonny!"
"No worries Pinkie, what took you so long?"
>"I couldn't decide what to wear. I wanted to look extra fancy like you!"
>.... all she did was put a ribbon in her hair
>You point it out
"And you decided to go with... that?"
>"Yeah and the best part...."
>She pulls it out of her hair and eats it
>"It's made of taffy!"
>.....
"Yeah, extra fancy."
>"Speaking of fancy..."
>She points behind you, towards that marshmallow dress maker
"Oh hey...."
>What was her name again?
>"Hi Rarity! You on a date too?"
>Oh yeah, that's it. Rarity
>"Hello Pinkie, Anon. I'd like you to meet this wonderful colt, Prince Pearl Necklace."
>You know for SURE he's not really a prince
>And given this is the fifth week in a row you've seen Rarity with a different guy makes you pretty sure she's a prostitute
"Nice to meet you man."
>You reach out for a brofist/hoof, since thy can't exactly shake
>He just stares at you like you've offended him or something
>Dick
>Pinkie throws her front legs around Rarity for a hug
>When that's over, Rarity reaches out to hug you
>... she's hugging you rather tightly for some reason
 
>You finally get her to pull away
>"I must say you look rather dapper today, Anon."
"Yeah, you too... Rarity."
>You hesitate before saying her name, gotta assure yourself you're right
>"Although I must say, that tie of yours does look crooked."
>She uses her magic to straighten it for you
"Thanks."
>"Hmm... and I do think you could use a different color
>Wat
>She turns your tie from red to blue
"Umm, thanks Rarit-"
>"No no, that simply won't do
>She changes it to a piano-key necktie
"Uhh.... thanks, I guess-"
>"No, too tacky."
>Rainbow tie
"Rarity, please-"
>"No, that doesn't suit you either."
>Bedazzled neon yellow tie
>"Oh heavns, no!"
>At least you agree on something
>She turns it back to normal
>"There we go. Perfect"
>You let out a sigh of relief as she says that
>"Now about your outfit-"
>OH GOD NO
"I-I'd love to, but we have a reservation and we're running late as it is! Come on Pinkie!"
>You grab her and run in
>You know, the kind of thing she usually does
 
>The two of you share a decent meal at a small local restaurant
>Kind of like Italian, if ponies had an Italy
>Well decent for what you paid
>She ordered lasagna, because, "It's like pasta cake!"
>She ate her whole meal and about half of yours (you weren't all that hungry tbh)
>And she still had room for desert
>You pay your bill and all that what-not
>"I'm gonna run the the bathroom really quick, meet you outside!"
>As long as you don't take half an hour
 
>Waiting out front
>That dude Rarity was with walks out
>... more like marches out with his nose in the air. Dick.
>Rarity slowly comes out a minute later, a strange combination of sad and murderously angry
"Hey Rarity, you okay?"
>You know if you have to ask that, it's not okay
>The glare she gives you tells you that you just opened pandora's box
>She realizes she's scowling at you and apologizes
>"I'm sorry Anon, it's not your fault..."
>She sits down on the floor, and you take a seat next to her
"Didn't go so well?"
>She sighs
>"Oh Anon... why is it that every man with class has to be so stuck up?"
>She leans over on your shoulder and starts sobbing
>Come on say something to.... I dont' know, comfort her?
"Listen Rarity..."
>She looks up at you, tears trickling down her cheeks
"... a guy who treats a lady like you so rudely.... I wouldn't call him classy. I'd call him..."
>You hesitate. It feels embarrassing to say this in front of her for some reason
>"... A what, Anon?"
"... I'd call him a dick."
 
>Awkward silence....
>Then she giggles and wipes her eyes
>"If I may be so crude for a moment... he was a bit of a dick."
>The two of you share a laugh
>"Oh Anon... why can't more guys be great like you."
>She leans on your shoulder
>"Pinkie's lucky to have you."
"Yeah, I'm honestly pretty lucky to have her too."
>She probably has NO idea what you mean by that
>"Thanks for talking with me Anon. Tell you what, come by the boutique tomorrow and I'll have something for you..."
>She leans in real close and whispers in your ear
>"... something I think you'll like a whole lot."
>She slowly licks your neck, from your shoulders all the way to just below your ear
>..... yes. She just fucking did that. That shit just happened.
>You feel a little guilty for actually getting aroused
>"Sorry for taking so long Nonny!"
>Pinkie hops out, apparently hadn't seen a thing
>"Hey Rarity, where's that guy of yours?"
>Rarity looks at over at you and smiles
>"He was a total dick."
>Her and Pinkie laugh
>You sit there in awkward silence
 
>Rarity heads home on her own, and you walk Pinkie back to her place
>Then you head home by yourself
>Tomorrow.....
>Should you go?
>.... probably should. Don't wanna be a dick.
 
>Tomorrow became today
>Morning became afternoon
>'Time for normality' became 'time for not sure what this marshmallow mare is up to'
>You cautiously head over to the boutique
 
>You open the door, and a little bell goes off
>"Just a minute!"
>Yup, that's Rarity. This should be interesting
>She comes down and almost jumps when she sees you
>"O-oh, hello darling, wasn't expecting you to come so early"
>*That's what she said*
>"Come with me."
>She grabs your hand and leads you to another room
"Where are you taking me?"
>"To my bedroom"
>.....
>WHAT COULD POSSIBLY GO WRONG?
>You follow into her room and....
 
>Draped on a surprisingly well-made human mannequin is a brand new suit
>"You like it? I hoof stitched it myself."
>She says that rather proudly
"To be honest, it actually does look pretty nice."
>She bumps you towards it
>"Go on, try it on.
"Uhh... sure. Can I, you know, have a little privacy first?"
>Don't want to get raped by ANOTHER pony
>"Oh yes, of course darling."
>She steps outside
>"Just call me when you're done."
>You wait until she's gone, then you undress and put on the suit
>... it's surprisingly well-made, fitting, and comfortable
>It may be your new favorite
>Maybe she's not so bad after all....
"Hey Rarity, I'm ready!"
>You're looking at yourself in the mirror, you don't see her come in
>"Well, what do you think~?"
>You turn around to thank her
"It's really nice, thank you so much for-"
>Holy shit what is she wearing?
>Since when did ponies have lingerie?
 
"Uhh... that looks... nice."
>You say that as you look around for an excuse to see yourself out
>You don't even realize how close she's gotten to you
>"That's very sweet of you darling..."
>You back away as she creeps closer
>"... perhaps you'd like to see it up close~"
>You trip on something and fall back
>.... onto the bed.
>You try to get up, but she took that as an 'invitation'
>She straddles your hips with her back legs, her front hooves pressed down on either side of your shoulders
>"You look so tense sweetie, you need to loosen up a little."
>She rips open your shirt, buttons popping off and flying across the room
>So much for the new suit
>She pushes your shirt open and caresses your bare chest with her soft hooves
>You're trying to push away as she brings her face closer to yours, but doing so gently so as to not make an obvious 'fuck you' out of it
>She's inches away from a kiss when you hear that door bell tingle
>"Just a minute!"
>She gets up and boops you on the nose
>"Don't go anywhere now."
>You look away as she undresses
>Seeing her naked is an everyday thing, but watching her actually takes clothes OFF just feels more... lewd for some reason
>She heads out the bedroom and closes the door behind her
>....
>You give it a minute before attempting to sneak out
 
>You don't even bother changing into your old clothes
>Hate to have her walking in on you naked
>You carefully look down the hall to make sure no one is coming before dashing through
>Just around the corner is the front room, and your exit
>You turn the corner and head for the door without stopping to listen
>You probably should have....
>As you walk into the room, Pinkie and Rarity both turn towards you
>Awkward silence.
 
>Is there a way out of this without committing sudoku?
>....No. No there is not.
>Pinkie just looks at you, the same big smile she always has
>"You okay there Nonny?"
>She acting completely normal.... that may or may not be a good sign
>Gotta clear this situation up before she gets any ideas
"Listen Pinkie... I can explain-"
>"No Anon, let me explain."
>She lets out a deep sigh
>You see... the thing is, Pinkie, I-"
>"You were making Nonny a brand-new suit all by yourself. He told me about it last night."
>She pulls a box out of her saddlebag
>"So I made a cake as a thank you for your generosity!"
>She looks over at you
>"Cause I'm sure Nonny would have forgotten to thank you properly."
>"Why, thank you darling. Just go set them in the kitchen, we'll be there in a minute."
>She hops away, and Rarity whispers to you
>"Listen, Anon... I'm sorry about earlier. It wasn't appropriate of me, I just-"
"I get it."
>"So should we-"
"-Pretend it never happened? Yes."
>You try not to sound rude, but when shit gets this real it's hard to control your tone
>The two of you follow Pinkie together back to the kitchen
>The cake is unpacked on the table and already cut
>3 plates, 3 slices, 3 forks
>...it's actually looks delicious. No surprise from Pinkie
>You take a bite
>It's good... really good... in fact, it tastes kind of like.... uh oh.
"H-hey Rarity, can I get a glass of water?"
>Gotta wash out this rape cake
>"Sure thing."
>She gets up to get you some water
>You look over at her plate, she's only taken one bite
>Maybe she'll be okay
>As she passes you the glass, Pinkie plops her head on the table
 
>Rarity is naturally a lot more surprised than you are
>"Pinkie? Anon, is she okay? Maybe we should call Twi-"
"She's fine."
>Why does everyone want to call Twilight!?!
>"Are you sure?"
"Yeah. It's hard to explain but... well, you see... the frosting is..."
>"Ah, sugar crash. I always warned Pinkie it would happen one day."
>Yeah. Sugar crash. Let's go with that.
>"Come on, let's take her to my bed."
"Yeah, alright."
>She takes Pinkie's saddlebags, and you pick up her unconscious body
 
>You get to her room, and gently lay her on the bed
>Rarity plops Pinkie's bags on the bed next to her, breathing heavily
"Were they heavy?"
>No... not really... I'm just a little..."
>She never finishes that thought, so you let it go (if anyone makes a Frozen joke I will end you)
>A long box with a ribbon falls out of the bag, with a little tag that says "For: Rarity <3"
"Hey Rarity, I think this is for you."
>Rarity is kneeling down beside Pinkie, gently petting her mane
>"You know Anon, I get what you see in her.... She really is cute."
>She moves her hoof down and caresses her face.... very sensually
"Yeah, she is. Are you feeling okay?"
>She speaks through heavy pants
>Of... of course... whatever do you... you mean... darling?"
"It's just, I don't know, you seem exhausted."
>"Oh no, darling... in fact... I'm full of energy... more than ever."
>.... what?
>She holds Pinkie's face up, and slowly and passionately kisses her on the lips
>.... What?
>Rarity straddles Pinkie like she did you earlier and lays down on top of her
>.... WHAT?
"Rarity, what are you doing?"
>"Oh I'm sorry Anon... how rude of me..."
>She get off and lays down next to Pinkie, presenting herself to you
>"Did you want to join in?"
 
>Say somethng. Anything
"U-uh.. umm... I, uhh- *clears throat* well..."
>Yeah, that's a thing.
>"Oh come on Anon..."
>She grabs Pinkie's body and pulls it on top of herself, their chests pressing tgether
>"It'll be fun... I'm sure Pinkie would agree."
>Distraction, distraction, gotta find a distraction...
"The present! Don't you wan to open your present Rarity?"
>You pick up the box and hand it to her
>"Forget it Anon, don't you know it's rude to keep a lady waiting?"
>She swats the box out of your hand and when it hits the floor it pops open
>...and out rolls a strap-on horse dildo
>She gives you a lewd smile
>Oh, Anon... I had no idea you had THIs in store..."
>No no no this is not what you had in mind at all
>With her magic, Rarity lifts up the dildo and puts it on herself
>She presses the tip of 'her' dick against Pinkie's pink
>You've been in the spot, godd luck trying to push it inside her-
>It slides in almost instantly. Wow.
>It must be the aphrodesiac, or whatever she added to the new recipe, but her pussy is already wet and eager
>You watch as Pinkie bounces up and down as Rarity bucks her hips against her
>You slowly undo and drop your pants
>This is what she wanted.. it's what she hoped for, right
>Besides, you'd be lying to say you didn't have a boner
>You swallow your nerves and approach the two mares
>Rarity smiles at you, as if to say 'gotcha'
>She stops bucking so you could get yourself situated
>You spread Pinkie's round flank
>You press your dick against her tiny asshole and....
>You push slowly
 
>Her ponut gives up a lot of resistance
>Rarity sits still, panting heavily, letting you have a chance to make it in
>Your head just starts to penetrate when her back legs start shaking
>With a sudden hard push, you force the rest of you cock inside her tight anus
>"AAHH!!"
>She woke up
>"Glad to see you finally awake, darling~"
>"R-r-rarit-ty? N-Nonn-ny?"
>Her whole body is quivering
>Rarity starts moving, not bothering to start off gently
>That's your queue to start slowly pushing in and out
>Not that it's easy, her insides are clinging to you tightly
>"R-rarrity, p-please... n-not so rough."
>"Oh, come now sweetie, that look on your face is clear enough."
>With each push of 'her' dick, you feel it against yourself
>With every thrust from you, she clenches down harder
>"N-non...ny...p-please st-stop..."
>She looks back at you with an expression that means 'don't actually stop'
>So you try to thrust faster
>Of course, she squeezes down even tighter
>"Ahh... n-no m... mmhh... no more... please..."
>She's good at this whole begging for mercy thing
>Rarity starts thrusting harder
>"R-rrarity... oww... p-please.."
>"Oh admit it darling, you're loving it."
>You grab a handful of Pinkie's mane and start pulling
>Rarity throws her hooves around Pinkie and pulls her down to kiss her
>"MMh... mmf..."
"P-Pinkie..."
>You quietly moan out her name
>You slam against her ass, Rarity slams against her pussy
>Rarity breaks the kiss, and Pinkie's head flies back, tongue still out
>Pinkie screams in pleasure as you pull her mane just a little harder
>"AAHH! Y-YESS!"
>As she screams she clenches down with her anus
>Just as you are at your limit...
>"AAAHH! N-N-NONNNYYY!!!"
>Your warm fluids pour into her warmer insides
 
>.....
>As you calm down, you slowly pull out and sit next to the Rari-Pinkie sandwich
>Rarity slowly pulls 'her' dick out of Pinkie's slippery pussy and lays down on your other side
>The three of you lay together, you being in the middle
>"...h-hey Nonny.... thanks.."
"Th-thank you... Pinkie.."
>Pinkie cuddles up into your right shoulder, Rarity into your left
>You put your arm around Pinkie and hold her
>.... ah fuck it, cuddle Rarity too
>Rarity magically pulls the blanket over the three of you
>She has enough pillows for all of you to drift to sleep in her bed
 
>A couple days after the little 'incident' with Rarity
>Twilight calls over all her friends to the library for an important meeting
>... of course, you weren't invited, but Pinkie told you about it
>She tries to bring you along,but you try to talk her out of it
"Pinkie, I think she didn't invite me for a reason-"
>"Nonsense, we can't have a gathering without you, Nonny. You're like the 7th Element of Harmony!"
"Oh yeah? And what friendship element am I?
>"The element of benefits!"
>... it took you a minute to get it
>As she walks out the door she bumps you with her butt
>"Cause friends are always better with benefits~"
>She winks at you
>You give her a slap on the butt as you leave together for the library
 
>You stop her just outside the front door of the library
>lol she lives in a tree like a hobo
"Hey Pinkie, can I ask you something?"
>"Hmm? What is it?"
"Let's keep the whole '7th Element' thing between us."
>"What do you mean? Everypony knows that we're together."
>You always cringe at that word
"Yeah, but do they know EVERYTHING?"
>She has to think for a second
>".... Oh right! 'That' stuff"
>She giggles as she says it
>"Maybe we should keep the '7th Element' a secret"
>"What's all this about a 7th Element of Harmony?"
>Shit. Someone overheard you
>"Hey Applejack! Nonny here is the Element of 'Benefits', if you know what I mean."
"She's only joking, I swear."
>Applejack just gives you a blank start
>"Uh huh.... anyways I'm headin' in. See y'all inside."
>She goes in the library as if nothing happened
>Either she knows what is going on and is trying not to make things awkward
>Or she really has no idea what 'friends with benefits' means
>That's probably it.... probably.
>You look over at Pinkie
>She giggles and kisses your cheek
>... okay, you forgive her for now
>You head in together and find everyone already there
 
>Fluttershy greets you almost instantly
>"Oh hello Anon, nice to see you today."
"Yeah, you too Flutters."
>You call her 'Flutters' because she has never really been shy around you
>Dash gives you a wave, you wave back
>You share a brief, awkward moment of eye contact with Rarity
>What ever did happen after that day.....
 
>Flashback no jutsu
>You are in bed with Rarity and Pinkie
>Rarity seems to be ashamed of what happened
>They both seem to have come down from the drugged cake, but Pinkie's still asleep
>"Listen, darling. I truly am sorry for how I acted. I have no idea what came over me..."
"Don't worry about it Rarity, I get it. Just glad it's all out of your system now."
>"Y-yeah.. i-it's all out now..."
>She turns away from you
>Pretty sure you saw her blush.... ah, it was probably nothing
>She crawls out of bed
>"You and Pinkie stay as long as you like, see yourselves out whenever."
>She heads out of the room, and you call out to her
"Hey Rarity... you don't mind if I take the rest of the cake, do you?"
>Hate to have another little mishap while she's home alone
>"Not at all, go ahead."
>She comes back to your side and whispers in your ear
>"Don't tell Pinkie, but something in the frosting takes funny."
>She leaves the room, and you grab Pinkie to carry her home
 
>Back to the treehouse
>When the book pony sees you she shoots you a glare
>You reflect it back to her, your eyes saying 'Do it, make a scene I dare you.'
>She's apparently smarter than that
>Her little dragon slave turns down the lights and turns on a projector, and she starts some kind of presentation
>Remember you weren't given an invitation, so you have no idea what's going on
>You just zone out thinking about why Twatlot Sparkle is so hard on you
 
>.....
>.......
>..............
 
>"Anonymous! Are you paying attention?"
>Huh?
>Oh yeah, she was doing a thing
>"Honestly, did you hear a single thing I just said?"
"Yeah."
>"Really, then what did I say?"
"Words."
>She whacks you on the head with a ruler
>Totally worth it
>She continues on with her lecture on.... whatever is going on today
>Rainbow Dash taps your shoulder from behind and reaches out for a hoof/fist bump
 
>Well, apparently here's the plan:
>There's some huge shopping mall opening up in Canterlot, everyone's going
>Going shopping at the mall with a bunch of girls... great.
>Twilight organized some kind of schedule routine for 'maximum shopping efficiency'
>Rainbow Dash is already planning a mutiny
>And you're definitely in
 
>After a fairly short train ride and an even shorter walk you end up at the mall in Canterlot
>... to be honest, you're a little excited
>Twilight speaks up
>"Okay girls... and Anonymous... the first thing on the schedule is-"
>"See ya!"
>"Rainbow Dash! Get back here!"
>Applejack: "I'll go get her!"
>Twilight: "Wait Applejack, that's the wrong way!"
>Pinkie whispers to you:"That's out cue."
>Twi: ""Hey you too!"
>You and Pinkie split up in opposite directions
>You've already agree to meet up somewhere
>You kinda feel bad for ruining Twilight's plan
>.... no you don't
 
>You wait in front of the bathrooms like Pinkie told you
>You eagerly look around trying to find her
>"In here!"
>Pinkie pops out of the mare's bathroom, carrying a big pink bag
"Oh, hey. What's in the bag?"
>She looks around cautiously
>"Okay, the coast is clear."
"Clear? Clear for wha-"
>She bucks you into the mare's bathroom, following you in
"Pinkie, what are you-"
>"Shh!"
>She pushes you into the big handicapped stall at the end
>"Here, put this on. You'll blend in here better."
>You take a look inside.... it's a dress
>What.
>By blending in 'here', she apparently means the bathroom
"Pinkie, why do I-"
>"Shh! Someone's coming!"
>She's right, you do hear hoofsteps approaching
>Your best situation is to just put it on and sneak out
>You quickly strip and put on the dress
>It's meant for ponies, but somehow it fits your body well enough
>She even got you some thigh highs to cover your leg hair
>After a while the hoofsteps leave the bathroom
"Okay... now what?
>Pinkie locks the stall door and turns around
>"Now call me mistress~"
 
"Pinkie did you seriously buy these here just to dress me up and sneak me into the bathroom?"
>"Yup! Great idea wasn't it?"
>It' one of those shitty malls where the men's and women's rooms are on opposite sides of the fucking building
>And she asked you specifically to wait in front of the mare's bathrooms
>.... it's your own fault for not seeing this coming
"I appreciate the idea Pinkie, but... "
>You can't deny the awkwardness of the situation
>"Aww, come on Nonny, don't tell me you haven't even thought about it."
"About what?"
>"You know...."
>She puts the lid down on the toilet, puts her front hooves up and bends over
>"The thought of taking advantage of me in public~"
>She wiggles her rump as she says that
>Now that she mentions it, it's a pretty awesome idea
>But then again, the dress?
"Did I really have to wear this, though?"
>"It'll help you blend in everywhere."
>Everywhere.... meaning there's more to today than the bathroom
>"Now come on, Nonny..."
>She looks back at you, lust in her eyes
>"Are you really going to say no to this"
>She wiggles her butt again
>She's got a point you know... you'd be stupid for passing up this opportunity
 
>You lift up your dress and take out your dick
>.... and pray that those words are never written again
>You grab her from behind, slowly approaching her
>"Nonny, what;s taking so long, you feeling okay?"
>You know if you open your mouth you'll let it slip out how awkward this is for you
>So you just make a quick push inside
>She gasps quietly, trying to suppress her voice
"Still think something's wrong?"
>"N-nope."
>Go time
>You thrust slowly, still not sure if it's okay to go all out
>It's not the getting caught in public that bothers you, it's getting caught in a damn dress
>"Nonny, please... harder.."
>She makes more noise like this...
>So you slam your dick as hard as you can into her
>She gasps loudly at the original impact, but as you start to thrust more she keeps her voice down
>You try not to push all the way to keep down the sound of your hips slapping against her butt
>Her face is pressed against the bathroom wall, but she manages to whisper over to you
>"Nonny... the door... is locked, right?"
>You look back, and sure enough it is
"Don't worry, it's locked."
>She gently pushes you back, and she heads way
"Pinkie, what are you-"
>*CLICK*
>"Where's the fun if there's no chance of getting caught?~"
>She unlocked the door.
"Maybe that's not such a good idea PinKie..."
>"Maybe you should keep your voice down~"
>She slowly approaches you, backing you into the toilet
>You sit down on the lid, not realizing you walked right into her plan
>She pushes your dress up and climbs into your lap
 
>She feels just a little heavier in you lap than all the times you've carried her in your arms
>"You know Nonny... you do look kinda cute in that."
>... no stop it. Stop enjoying this so much
>She presses her pussy on the head of you dick, giving you a wink before sliding down
>She struggles a bit trying to go all the way down
"You okay there Pinkie?"
>"Y-yeah.. its just... been a while."
>It HAS been a while since she was on top... and conscious
>She gets the hang of it and starts bouncing up and down on your dick
>You put your hands around her to keep her from slipping off
>She giggles, your hands tickling her as they run through her fur
>.... and almost loses her balance
>You hold her tighter, burying your face in her chest fur
>"N-Nonny..."
>She bounces up and down faster
>You respond by pushing your hips against her
>Again, she almost falls off
>"S-sorry Nonny... I'm trying-"
"Don't worry, I have an idea."
>You've seen this all the time in hentai, no idea if this works
>But damned if you don't try....
"When I say 'go', wrap your legs around me."
>"O-okay..."
>You cling to her tightly and...
"Go!"
>You stand up from the toilet, grabbing her plot with both hands
>You hold her up and she clings to you, your dick still inside her
>You take a sec to get your balance before you start thrusting
>It's an awkward forward and back movement, but you get the hang of it
>She's gasping and panting, so you can tell it's working
>Until... shit. Door open. Hoofsteps
>You push Pinkie's face into your shoulder to suppress her moans and back up against the wall to not be seen
>You stop moving, but you can't really pull out without putting her down
>One of the ponies who just came in starts talking
>.... shit is that Flutters?
 
>Pinkie pulls her head away as surprised as you are
>"Glad to see you still had a good time, Twilight."
>"Yeah, somehow I knew they wouldn't follow along from the start."
>PurpleSmart is here too... oh the lecture in store if you're caught
>"I just... kinda wished Pinkie kept it just between us, without Anonymous."
>"What do you mean? Anon's a nice guy."
>"It's just... there's something wrong with him."
>Pinkie strokes your head, your hurt from that comment apparently visible
>"Don't you think there's something... I don't know, weird about how close he is with Pinkie? Especially since..."
>Twilight sighs
>"I saw Anonymous sneaking into Pinkie's house a couple weeks ago."
>Shit... how much does she REALLY know?
>"Really? How come?"
>"No idea... I just don't know if he can be trusted."
>.... the hell is that supposed to mean?
>There's an awkward silence in the room, before Twilight speaks up again
>"Oh well, let's forget it. Come on' there's still a few more shops we should check out."
>They both leave the bathroom
>Leaving you and Pinkie alone, alone and uncomfortable
 
>"Nonny... are you okay?
 
>Truth be told: Not really
>Not only is Twilight aware of that night, but she suspects you of doing something wrong
>And what worries you is that most people (and ponies) would say you did
>Yeah... you are definitely not okay
 
"Yeah, I'm fine. I had a feeling she never really liked me anyways."
>You can't really contain your disappointment with what you just heard
>For some reason you actually care what she thinks about you, and it's-
>"Mmmh... Nonny..."
>She interrupts your train of thought with a kiss
>She gently slips out her tongue, and yours meets hers
>As you pull away, you feel so much better
>Who cares what Purple bitch thinks, as long as you're here with Pinkie...
>You step forward, still carrying Pinkie and now pushing Pinkie against the wall
>And you resume thrusting your hips
 
>When you press her against the wall, you feel more stable
>Which means you can thrust harder and faster
>Pinkie clings to you tighter and buries her face in your shoulder again
>But it only does so much, and the occasional moan does slip out
>"Ahh... mmhn.. N-nonny...."
>She clenches down when she calls out your name
>Her insides are getting wetter and wetter, her mare juice slowly dripping onto the floor
>The loud slooshing sound of your dick slipping in and out echoes through the empty bathroom
>Her legs start to quiver and she pulls her head away
>"Mmh.. Nonny... stop..."
>You know that's your signal to be more rough with her
>You fuck her with more vigor, almost pulling her body away from the wall and slamming it backwith each thrust
>"N-no, I'm serious Nonny, p-please stop."
>Shit. You dun goofed Anon
>You pull out and away from the wall, but you don't put her down
"Is everything okay Pinkie?"
>"Y-yeah... it's just.... umm..."
>For the first time, she actually looks nervous during sex... it's really cute
>"T-thee thing is... I k-kinda... have to pee."
>She tries to hide her face as she says it
>You try not to have a heart attack from excess cuteness
>"So... c-can you put me down?"
>You could, or....
"How about plan-B?"
>"W-what's that?"
>You smile lewdly at her
>She has no idea what you're up to
>....huh it's usually the other way around
>Without putting her down, you turn her body so she's facing the toilet, then you kick up the lid and the seat with your foot
>You slide your hands to just below her butt, and pull her legs apart
>Her legs are spread the toilet in front of her... good to go
"Alright Pinkie, go ahead."
 
>"Waitwaitwaitwaitwait-"
"Wait for what?"
>She must have said 'wait' at least a dozen times
>"I-I can't Nonny! It's just... i-it's embarrassing"
>She's hiding her face with her front hooves
>God this is cute. Too cute for you to give up now
"Don't worry Pinkie, it's no big deal."
>You push your dick inside her, and she gasps loudly
>"N-Nonny, please! I-I can't h-hhold it if y-you do-"
>You start thrusting, and her voice just cuts out
>Her back legs start trembling, she covers her face...
>And she lets out her stream
>"Ahh! D-don't look, Nonny!"
>You stop moving, letting her urinate in peace
>... well you know, as peaceful as she can with your dick inside her
>Inside her pussy as it twitches and quivers with nervousness
>You don't have a particular thing for piss, but just seeing her so embarrassed makes you...
>Damn.
>The sound, and her stream, die down slowly
>"Ahh... ahh... N-Nonny..."
>You lean forward and kiss her neck, hoping to calm her down
>It seems to work
>She uncovers her face
>"Nonny... I need to clean up.."
"Don't worry, we're almost done here"
>"O-okie d-dokie.."
>For the most part, she's calmed down
>Her pussy is clenching tighter, and you haven't even started moving again yet-
>Wait a sec
>Was she turned on being humiliated like that?
>... Was that real embarrassment or an act?
>You tell yourself it was real and keep going
 
>You turn her body around so she faces you again, and start thrusting
>Her body bounces up and down in your arms
>It gets heavy but not too much for you
>... cause you totally lift, don't you?
>"Mmh.. Nonny, please"
>She tries to gasp something out
>"Please... slam me... against the wall."
>You quickly stumble over against the wall, pressing her body against it
>Her legs tighten their hold on you
>You thrust harder and harder, your breathing getting heavier
>She cries out with every push of your cock
>Between yours and her moans of pleasure, the squishing of her juices, and the sound of your hips slapping against her, the bathroom echoes
with sounds of ecstasy and love
>"MMh... N-Nonny... I... I l-love..."
>She can't even finish her statement
>But you got the message
>You press your lips against hers, forcing your tongue through her teeth
>"MMH! MRRh!"
>She seems to react when you do that
>When you violate her mouth with your tongue
>It makes her moans muffled, yet still louder
>You don't have much more left in you...
>Her pussy is hotter than ever, squeezing and twitching with each thrust
>Every time you pull out, it sucks you back in
>There so much of her mare juice that it's spilling out onto the floor
>She presses her face into your shoulder... she knows what's coming and knows she won't be able to control her voice
>So she lets out a muffled scream as you blow your load inside her
 
>You wait until you've finished, let out your whole load in her
>Then  you pull out and your seed spills out all over the floor...
>On the one hand you're not a damn janitor
>But on the other hand you gotta keep this secret
>So you and Pinkie grab handfuls of toilet paper and clean up
>Just the mess you made, cause you're still no damn janitor
 
"...you ready?"
>"Yeah..."
>Pinkie pokes her had out the door
>"All clear! Go!"
>You and her run out of the bathroom as fast as you can
>You head outside the mall
>You find a dark spot in the parking lot
>And you get redressed on your normal clothes
>Everything back to normal. Just one more thing...
"Hey Pinkie, can you-"
>"Secret. Got it."
>You head back inside
 
>The only part of Twilight's plan you all agreed on was when and where to meet up before leaving
>You and Pinkie hang by the front doors
>There's a little lounge area with benches and tables
>The two of you are not there very long when everyone else shoes up in a big group
>You wave to them
"Hey guys, how's it-"
>"ANON! WE'RE YOU RUNNING ACROSS THE MALL IN A DRESS A MINUTE AGO?"
>....god damn it Rainbow Dash.
>She's laughs her ass off and everyone else joins, even Pinkie
>... hell, you let out a chuckle yourself
>After the little moment, the whole group leaves together
 
>On the train home
"Hey Flutters, how was your day?"
>She averts her gaze for some reason....
>"umm... yeah.. it was, nice."
"You uhh, get anything nice?"
>"...yeah, sure.... s-sorry, I gotta go."
>She gets up and walks away
>.....
>What was that about?
>Did it have something to do with what Twilight told her earlier?
>Speak of the devil...
>You look back and see a cold, diamond-cutting gaze from across the train car
>.... you feel like you can't really trust Twilight either...
 
>"Hey Anon, want to hear a joke?"
>Damn it Dash
>You're trying to enjoy your hay burger
>... well, as much as you CAN enjoy a burger made with fucking hay
"Not really-"
>"Okay! Here it goes: What do you call a guy running around in a dress?"
"I don't know, a guy trying to eat lunch in peace-"
>"YOU CALL HIM ANON!"
>She falls over onto the floor, unable to control her laughter
"Yeah, sure, that was funny when you first brought it up... a month ago."
>You will never live that down
>And neither will she...
 
>The next afternoon.
>You agreed to accompany Pinkie shopping again
>Mostly to keep her on schedule: 20 minute time limit on haggling shopkeeps
>Don't want to be out all night again
>.... okay you kinda do
>"Ready to go Nonny?"
>You take a quick look around... no Dash in sight
"Yeah, let's go."
>The two of you head off to the market together
 
>The 20 minute arguing limit seems to work
>The sun has just started to set by the time you're almost done
>Her saddlebags are almost empty, because she's making you carry everything
>You regret telling her about human backpacks
>You're about to head out when you make one last check
"You got everything you need?"
>"Ummm.... oh yeah! Apples! We're running low over at Sugarcube Corner!"
>The apple stand isn't too far away, but Pinkie still sprints over to it
>So you struggle to keep up...
 
>"Hey Applejack! Still got some apples left?"
>"Oh hey Pinkie, yer here earlier than usual."
>"Yeah, Nonny's making sure I stay on schedule today."
>"O-oh... he's with you?"
"Right... here..."
>You call out to her while trying to catch your breath
"Hey there... AJ... how's it going?"
>".... fine."
>She's short-spoken today... it's probably nothing
>Pinkie is eyeballing the different shelves and compartments of the apple stand
>"Hey what are these? They look new"
>"Oh those, Granny Smith thought we could increase cider sales if we sold it in bottles, so I-"
>"I'll take all of them."
>Pinkie pulls out a sack of bits as big as her head
>... where was she keeping that thing anyways?
>She spent all the her money on cider, you ended up buying her apples for her
>"Thanks for yer business as always Pinkie.... Anon..."
>She gives you a nod as she says you name, not even smiling
>"And thank you for the cider, Appleja-"
>"DID SOMEBODY SAY CIDER?"
>Rainbow Dash beams out of the sky and lands right in front of you guys, panting like a dog with her tongue out
 
"Dash, were you following us?"
>"Yeah I had a joke I thought you'd like to hear-"
"-Doubt it-"
>"-But I hear this about cider?"
>"Yeah, Pinkie here just bought it all."
>Dash looks so disappointed
>"Nonny and I were just about to head home, see you guys later-"
>"Wait a sec Pinkie, y'all are headin back, just the two of you?"
"Yeah, I'd hate to leave her walking alone. Plus, I'm kinda carrying all her groceries."
>"Uhh, umm.... maybe you should go with em, Rainbow."
>Oh please no
"I appreciate it, but I think we can-"
>"No! She's right! Gotta make sure the cider get's back safe."
>Dash and Pinkie are already heading back
>You look back at AJ, and she's giving you a cold stare
>You know, for a second she almost looks like....
>No way. Forget it
 
>You get to Sugarcube Corner and put away all the groceries
>"You know... this IS a lot of cider here... I doubt the two of you could really drink it all."
>Dash slowly caresses a bottle of cider as she says that
>"You're giving me a great idea Dashie... Midnight Cider Party!"
"Hey Pinkie, it's a great idea and all, but I should probably head home."
>"Aww, come on Nonny, don't be like that~"
>"Yeah Anon, it won't be a party without you!"
>She only says that for the cider... and for an opportunity to bring up the dress again
>You sigh, defeated
"All right, I'll stick around."
>"All right Anon!"
>She gives you a hoof bump
>"This totally makes up for you wearing a dress!"
>Of course....
>You pop open a bottle reading the label as you do
>[SWEET APPLE ACRES 100% FRESH ALCOHOLIC APPLE CIDER]
>.....
"Pinkie, you know this is alcoholic cider, right?"
>"Well duh, Nonny."
>She grabs 3 glasses and motions for you to pour
>"What kind of party would it be if it wasn't?"
>You pour 3 glasses... this will be interesting
 
>The three of you burn through the first bottle pretty fast
>And a second...
>And a third...
>The two of you sit around a table talking about random shit
>You talk Pinkie out of making cupcakes
>We've been down this road with Rarity and you still feel awkward around her
>Seriously, can you imagine having drugged sex with Dash?
>.... no, that doesn't mean imagine it now. Stop it.
 
>Speaking of Dash, she's already wasted
>Pinkie's noticeably drunk but still seems to control herself
>You feel a little tipsy yourself
>Apparently pony alcohol isn't as strong as you're used to
>"Hey Nonny, I'm gonna go grab another bottle, be right back."
"Pinks, are you sure that's such a..."
>Ah, she's already gone
>"Heeey Anon..."
"Yeah Dashie?"
>That was the alcohol calling her 'Dashie', I swear
>She leans closer to you in her seat
>"You wanna get with Pinkie don't you"
>You nearly puke up every drop of cider you had tonight
"W-what are you talking about? Why would-"
>"OH MY GOSH YOU DO!"
>She laughs so hard she falls out of her seat
>Pinkie comes back with not just one bottle but three, and sees Dash on the ground
>She whispers: "Watch this, Nonny~"
>She pounces on top of Rainbow Dash
>"H-ey Pinkie, guess what Anon sa-MmHpf!"
>Pinkie popped open a bottle and pushes it in Dash's mouth
>And gulp by gulp, Dash chugs the whole bottle
>You laugh at first, but it's actually quite impressive
>When the bottle is empty, Pinkie throws it aside, and the two of them burst into laughter
>Seeing Dash drink all that cider makes you need to pee real bad
"Be right back, headed to the bathroom."
>"Alright, take your time Nonny."
>"Yeah, we're fine without you, more cider for us"
>You're surprisingly more tolerant of Dash being... well, Dash
 
>You hear a lot of commotion out there
>Some voices, a crash...
>Oh well, ignore it
>You finish up and wash your hands
 
>You get back to the 'party room', but you don't see Dash or Pinkie
>Not to mention the table is overturned
>A pink hoof reaches up from behind the table
>"Down here, Nonny!"
>You walk over and see them both on the floor
>And Dash is on top of her
>... And they're making out
"Umm...."
>No idea what to say here
>"Sorry Anon, you snooze you lose."
>She pulls Pinkie back in for more rough kissing, but Pinkie pulls away
>"Come on Dashie, there's enough love to go around~"
>Pinkie grabs you and pulls you down on the floor with them
>Pinkie immediately presses her lips to yours, and Dash starts kissing your neck
>You put an arm around Pinkie and pull her closer
>You slip your tongue to her, and soon hers comes out to meet yours
>Dash gets a jealous look in her eyes
>Just when you think she's going for Pinkie, she grabs you turns you around, and forces her tongue in your mouth
>... well that was unexpected
>But not unwelcome
>"Tee hee, you like it, don't you Dashie~"
>"O-of course not... it j-just looked like fun."
>"Well Nonny sure seems to like it"
>Pinkie grabs her hoof and slides it down your pants
>As soon as Dash feels your boner, she stops
>A moment of awkward stillness
>Then she pounces on top of you
>She struggles trying to get your pants off until Pinkie steps in and helps her
>Your pants get pulled down, you dick out in the open for Dash and Pinkie
>.... aaand just as that happens there's a knock on the door
"Shit, whose that?"
>"Don't worry Nonny, I called her. Can't have a party with only 3 people!"
 
>You and Dash sit next to one another as Pinkie answers the door, neither of you making a move
>"So Anon... wanna, y-you know... do it or something?"
>Well that was blunt and awkward
>And yet... still genuine
"Umm... maybe we should wait for Pinkie to-"
>"Aww come on, we both know you got a hard-on..."
>Oh yeah, that thing
>"...so come on, let's do it!"
"O-okay then."
>There really is no arguing with this one
>She climbs on top of you and tries to push it in.... and keeps trying
"Dash... you need some help-"
>"No! I got this!"
>She eventually manages to get it in place
>Her body twitches so much just from your head penetrating you're almost afraid to go any further
>She slowly slides down your cock bit by bit, until she is sitting on your lap and you are all the way in
>You sit still, let her get the hang of it
>Once she's comfortable she starts bouncing up and down on your cock
>Probably the alcohol, but she was already wet from the start
>She's a little tighter than Pinkie
>And maybe a little more sensitive because her pussy twitches more often
>She seems ready, so you start thrusting up against her
>"AAAh! MMn!"
>Shit, she enjoys that way to much
>"C-come on Anon, i-is that all you g-got? D-Do it harder!"
>She's certainly not shy, so you thrust harder
>"AAH! YES! J-JUST LIKE THAT! Y-YES! ANON!"
>Jeez, she's louder than Pinkie
>You hear Pinkie's hoofsteps coming back, but you don't bother to stop
>"Oh my~ you two sure are having fun."
>.... that wasn't Pinkie
"H-hey Rarity..."
 
>Rarity stands over you with a bag, Pinkie giggling behind her
>You can see the end of that dildo sticking out of the bag... of course
>"Come, Pinkie. It would be rude to disturb them when they're having so much fun."
>Rarity pushes Pinkie across the room, grabbing a bottle of cider as she does
>You focus back on Dashie, who had not stopped bouncing on your dick the whole time
>You put your arms around her
>She starts moving her hips faster, slamming them against you with each movement
>You decide to help her out by thrusting your hips
>Her pussy is so wet it almost splashes when you thrust against her
>"A-a-anon!!!"
>She stutters out your name, her body shivering
>You flip her over onto her back so you are the dominant one
>She has no idea how to respond, both full of lust and nervousness
>You start thrusting into her, and she just lays there and takes it
>"Y-Yes! A-anon!"
>You even enjoy it more yourself this way
>With every push, she tightens on you more
>It's almost too much
"Rainbow Dash... I'm about to-"
>She grabs you tightly
>"Y-y-you betttter d-do it ins-side..."
>You give her a few more hard thrusts, and with one big slam of your hips against hers you release your load
>"AAhh! A-a-Annnon!!"
>She screams out your name as you fill her up
>You pull out as soon as you've finished releasing
>You hear a whisper from across the room
>You look up and see Pinkie being fucked by a now tipsy Rarity
>Pinkie whispers again
>"p-please... I want N-Nonny's dick... I-I need it...."
>....
>Upon hearing that, you grow back instantly
>Rarity looks back and sees you and your erect member
>She motions for you to come towards her... you and Dash
>"Both of you, come here~"
 
>Rarity and Pinkie are lying on a couch against the wall
>You slowly walk towards them, Dash waddling slowly behind
>Rarity pulls the dildo out, and Pinkie rolls over so her back is against Rarity's chest
>"I think she wants you in the other end this time, darling."
>That becomes apparent as Pinkie spreads her legs for you
>You lean over Pinkie, trying not to put extra pressure on Rarity
>You gently press you dick against Pinkie's pink
>That gentle push is enough for you to penetrate
>Yup, Rarity got her all ready for you
>As you push your rod all the way in, you feel something push in below
>Rarity must be in too
>She starts moving before you do
>Last time you were on the other end... and quite frankly you prefer it on this side
>You can feel every twitch of her pussy, and her hot wet mare juices make it easier for you to move
>Pinkie's shaking, but she's usually moaning and 'begging you to stop'
>You wonder if something's wrong....
>Until you see her face buried in Rainbow's crotch
>While you were busy getting yourself situated, Rainbow took the liberty to sit on Pinkie's face
>"What.. couldn't let you two have all the fun."
 
>You thrust in and out of Pinkie's pussy while Rarity penetrates her ass and Rainbow grinds on her face
>Pinkie doesn't give the slightest struggle... either she can't or she doesn't want to
>Although, she does let out the occasional muffled moan
>You try not to thrust too hard, you might accidentally push someone off the couch
>Of course that eventually slips out of your mind as you get more into the moment
>You see Rarity drinking cider straight out of a bottle
"Hey Rarity... pass me some of that."
>You take a big drink, feeling almost as drunk as Dash looked ten minutes ago
>Come on Anon, don't hog it all!"
>Dash grabs it out of your hand and starts chugging
>You hear her voice in your head: 'My name is Rainbow Dash and I'm an alcoholic.'
>"Don't worry darling, I hid another bottle under the couch."
>She whisper so Dash doesn't hear
>Dash pulls her face away for a brief moment
>"Hey Pinkie, thirsty?"
>As soon as Pinkie opens her mouth, Dash empties the bottle into her mouth
>She can't swallow it all, and some of it drips out along with....
>... is that you cum? Is that from when you came in Dash?
>You don't have time to think about it, because her face goes right between Dash's legs again
>"D-dash, just give me a sec- Mmh..."
>Maybe she should get a second to breathe....
>"C-come on Pinkie... I'm a-almost there..."
>"We can tell, darling, you're so vocal about it."
>As you thrust harder, even Rainbow's body isn't enough to muffle Pinkie's moans
>Dash seems to like that
>"P-pinkie... you're breath is so w-warm.. i-its.. I.. I... AAAAHHHHNN!!!"
>Rainbow arches her back and falls off the couch, her body twitching in ecstasy
>As soon as she's off, Pinkie's voice lets out
>"Nonny! H-harder... please!"
>"Well? You heard the lady Anon"
>Rarity starts moving herself faster, almost like she's trying to throw you off
>You struggle to keep up, but you manage to move with a faster pace
 
>With every thrust, Pinkie squeezes down on your cock
>And if it's not her, it's the pressure from Rarity's 'dick' in her behind
>You give it your all, not holding back
>Faster, harder, faster, harder....
>You're losing your breath, you did a lot more tonight than usual
>"Mhm... Nonny... Rarity..."
>Rarity actually seems flattered that she called out her name
>"I-I'm almost... just a little more..."
>Pinkie is shaking, on the verge of climax
>You feel it as her insides twitch at every movement and her legs quiver
>Rarity starts thrusting harder so you do the same, exerting more energy than you knew you had
>You're almost there too...
>"Ahh... AAH.... N-NONNY!!"
>That scream and the convulsing of her pussy that accompanied it were the final straw
>You pulled out and blew your load all over Pinkie
>... a little got on Rarity's face
>'As long as it's not in her hair she won't kill you' you figure
>You plop into the empty seat on the couch
>"H-hey Nonny, can you grab a towel from the kitchen? We kinda need to clean ourselves up."
"Yeah sure."
 
>You grab a towel from under the sink
>You notice a plate of cupcakes on the counter with a sticky not that says 'For The Party!'
>Each one is labeled with a different name, even one for you (she's a big pony)
>...great, now she's got specialized rape-cakes
>There's even ones for Applejack, Twilight, and Flutters
>Did she invite them? Why wouldn't they show?
>Forget it, you're missing the big picture here: SPECIALIZED RAPE CAKES
>Good thing she forgot them, there was enough cider that you didn't even need them
 
>You head back to the party room and help Pinkie clean up
>Rarity refuses, insisting that semen helps with smooth skin
>.... you have no idea how to argue against that
>Once everyone and the room are all clean (save for semen face over there), you all agree that everyone is too drunk to head home
>You all head upstairs, everyone leaning on everyone for support
>Sleepover at Pinkie's house
 
>The next morning
>You woke up, before everyone, in bed with Pinkie
>You think you can quietly sneak across the room to go to the bathroom
>....
>One step down form the bed and you already tripped. Loudly.
>"MMhh.. Anon? Is that you?"
>Welp, Dash is awake
>"You okay darling?"
>And so is Rarity
>Pinkie still out like a light
>"Well now that you're awake Anon, what's for breakfast?"
"Whatever you make, Dash."
>She rolls her eyes
>"Hear that Rarity? Anon volunteered to make us pancakes!"
"The hell? No I didn-"
>"Did somebody say cake?"
>Pinkie pops up like a spring, now wide awake
>"Yeah, Anon's making pancakes for us all."
>"Really? How nice of you Nonny!"
>You can't really say 'no' now
>You'll wipe that smug grin off Dash's face later
>You head down to the kitchen, and Pinkie joins you
>"A pancake is just a cake for breakfast. And if there's anything I know, it's cake."
 
>You get to the kitchen and find an... uninvited guest
>"Hey Twi! Nice of you to stop by.... Twi?"
>Twilight's there, not responding
>You walk over and see her leaning on the counter.... asleep
>Her cupcake is missing from the 'rape cake' box
>Shit.... shit.... SHIT!
"Uhh, Pinkie.. I think she ate her cupcake."
 
>You both try not to panic
"Don't worry, listen. We'll just take her home, tuck her into bed, and she won't remember a thing."
>"But Nonny, everyone upstairs is waiting. You gotta take her yourself so I can get these pancakes done."
"Whoa whoa whoa,  why can't I do the pancakes and you take her?"
>".... no offense Nonny, but I've seen you in the kitchen."
>She got you there
"But... what if she wakes up? After all that stuff she said at the mall..."
>"Relax Nonny, I'm sure she didn't mean any of that"
>She's pushing you out the door as she says this
>"Now you've got time just in case, I made her cakes extra strong. But that doesn't mean it'll last forever, so hurry!"
>She slams the door behind you
>... so they were specialized
>You don't have time to ponder
>You need to get her home, and fast
 
>If you walk too fast you might shake her awake
>If you walk too slow the drugs will wear off
>It's a lose lose situation here
>You resort to some awkward not-so-fast power walk you see old people do on treadmills at the gym
>You get an occasional awkward stare and a 'is she okay?'
>Your excuse is 'walking a drunk friend home from a party'.
>For a minute you think that such a rumor could hurt her reputation
>..... so you stick to it
>You're almost at the library when these three little girls show up
>One of them is definitely Rarity's sister, one of them you're pretty sure is Applejack's
>The third one... you really have no idea
>"Heya Anon, watcha doin'?"
>Little Applehorse speaks up
"Oh nothing. just walking Twilight home. She blacked out at a party last night?"
>"Is she gonna be okay?"
"Yeah, I'm sure she's fine."
>"Do you know when she'll wake up? Cause she was supposed to tutor us in-"
"Look, she's exhausted, I really should get her to bed."
>Nosy little kids
>Twilight makes a quiet groan
>Shit, she's waking up
>"Is she-"
"I'll let her you know you stopped by, so come back later okay, bye!"
>You go in and slam the door in their faces
>You go up to her bedroom and gently place her on the bed
>Only cause you don't want her to wake up, you're not going soft or anything
>As you pull the covers over her one of her legs slides off the mattress
>You were going to leave it until you realize how her crotch is pretty much on full display
>....... no. Don't even think about it
>You prop her leg back up, tuck her in, and head for the door
 
>"Sup Anon."
>Just as you let out a sigh of relief, Spike startles you from behind
>"If you're looking for Twilight, I think she's out right now."
"Actually I just brought her home."
>He looks up and sees her in bed
>"What happened?"
"....Long story."
>"Got it."
>He doesn't know what happened, but he knows that it's best he doesn't
>As you head out, you turn back
"Hey Spike... what's up with Twilight lately?"
>"So I'm guessing you noticed it?"
>Noticed? Noticed what?
"I know what I'M talking about, what are YOU talking about?"
>He looks back at her, then to you
>"Well I was supposed to keep it a secret, but I'm sure it's over now.... but when you first arrived...."
>He's down to a whisper
>"... she kinda had a thing for you."
>.... it all makes sense now.... wait a sec no it doesn't
>"She would always talk about you non-stop, how you were such an interesting creature. She would follow you around all the time. Claimed it was 'research'."
>Well that's not weird
>"But then one day a couple months ago, she just... stopped. She would get really angry whenever someone mentioned you."
"How long ago was all this?"
>"A couple months. Around the time you and Pinkie started going out."
"Huh.... "
>You pause, not sure how to take all this
>"But just between you and me, I think she still wants you."
"What?"
>"Yeah, she still keeps following you around sometimes."
>......
"Has she mentioned anything? Like, between me and Pinkie?"
>You HAVE to know how much she knows
>"Not really."
>You don't believe him
>"Don't worry Anon, we all pretty much assumed the two of you are getting it on."
>He nudges your side
>"Now that's an accomplishment if you ask me-"
>You hear Twilight grumble from upstairs
"Shit I gotta get going.
>"Right, see ya later"
>You fist bump and head out the door
>As you leave you turn back
"Hey Spike-"
>He nods to you
>"Got it. You were never here."
>You nod back and run to Sugarcube Corner
>.....
>The thought of what Twilight might know haunts you
 
>The walk back to Sugarcube Corner feels a lot longer than usual
>Maybe because you're not in a hurry this time
>Maybe because you had a long night and you're still exhausted
>Or maybe it's because Twilight might, just might, have enough to blackmail you
>How do they punish people here?
>Prison? Banishment? Execution?
>What ever it is, she has you by the ass
>.... or maybe not
>And it's the 'maybe' that's killing you
 
>You finally get back to Sugarcube Corner
>"Hey Nonny! You were gone a while, I was starting to get worried."
>......
>"...Nonny?"
"Oh, sorry. My mind was somewhere else."
>"Oh it's okay. I have no idea where my mind is half of the time."
>That gets a smile out of you, she always knows how to cheer you up
>"Come on, you haven't eaten all morning, you must be starving!"
 
>She leads you back to the kitchen
>Everyone is still there, and to your relief still conscious
"Please tell me there are still some pancakes left?"
>"Don't worry darling, we set some aside for you, they're on the-"
>"I ate them."
>God damn it Dash
 
>That shit eating (and pancake eating) grin of hers
>"What? You were gone a long time, I didn't want them to get cold."
>Bullshit, she did it on purpose
>She's trying not to laugh
"Really Dash, after everything I did for you last night?
>She abruptly goes silent. Checkmate
>"J-just for the record, that only happened because I was drunk!"
"So you DIDN'T enjoy it?"
>"W-well, I mean, yeah, but like, you know, uhh"
>She keeps stuttering, might as well show some mercy
"Relax Dashie, my lips are sealed."
>You ruffle her mane
>"Y-yeah, you better, or else."
>She stomps her hoof and storms out
>Before she leaves she turns back
>Holy crap she's blushing
>"B-but... you know, if... like, you know..."
"Use your words, Dashie."
>"IFYOUWANTEDTODOITAGAINCOUNTMEIN"
>She blurts out as fast as she can and rushes out
>"I should probably get going to. Thanks for everything"
>Rarity gets up and heads out
>"By the way, about what Rainbow Dash said before leaving.... if there's anything she and I agree on, it's that."
>She gives you a wink
>Surrounded by three horny mares who want you
>And your pony girlfriend actually encourages it
>Never before have you felt so awesome
>.....*grumble*
>Well, awesome and hungry
>Pinkie giggles
>"Let me get started on those pancakes."
 
>She makes herself some pancakes along with yours
>"I made sure to save room so I could eat with you."
"Pinkie, you didn't have to do that."
>"Don't worry Nonny, I wanted to-"
"No no, I mean you physically didn't have to. I always thought your stomach was bottomless."
>"N-Nonny!"
>She puffs her cheeks and wrinkles her snout, trying to be angry... and trying not to giggle
>You boop her on the nose
>LAUGHTER BOMB: TRIGGERED
>She throws her arms around you
>"Nonny! You big silly head!"
>She nuzzles your neck and you bury your face in her soft, cotton candy mane
>You don't want to be a creep, but you can't help how sweet she smells
>After this morning at the library, you really needed this....
>"Nonny... are you sniffing my mane?"
>Shit. She got you
>You start stuttering trying to control the damage
"Uhh, umm, w-well.. the pancakes! I think the pancakes are burning!"
>"Omigosh! You're right!"
>You wipe sweat from your forehead as she flips a nearly blackened pancake
>Good save
 
>After a bit you each have a good sized stack of pancakes in front of you
>You agreed to eat the burnt one
>The two of you eat in silence, sharing an occasional awkward glance
>When you both finish, Pinkie finally speaks up
>"Nonny, Is everything okay?"
"What do you mean?"
>"You've been acting strange since you got back from Twilight's."
"Don't worry Pinkie, I'm fine."
>..... that look she gives you says she doesn't believe you
>But she lets it go
 
>You help her clean up the kitchen
>"Thanks again Nonny you didn't have to help with all this."
"Well, I had nothing better to do anyways."
>She giggles
>At least the awkwardness from earlier is gone
"Hey Pinkie, I should probably head home soon."
>"Oh, that's okay. My shift starts soon anyways."
>The two of you hug, she gives you a quick kiss on the cheek and walks you to the door
>"By the way, come by here later tonight, I've got something super fun planned!"
"It's not anything... weird, is it?"
>"N-no! It's just-"
>You laugh, and she joins in
>Then again, you had to be sure, in case SOMEONE was watching
>"Don't worry Nonny, it's just a party! I've been planning for weeks! It'll be huge!"
>Another party.... why not
"Sure I'll be there."
>She excitedly hugs you, and you part ways
 
>You head home quickly, making sure you're not being followed
>You really should have told Pinkie the truth
>'Hey Pinkie, it turns out your best friend wanted my dick when you stole me from her'
>'Oh yeah, and now she maybe stalking us, maybe even knows about the rape cupcakes'
>Nah, it's best you keep it a secret
 
>You spend the rest of the day at home
>All the windows locked, all the curtains closed
>You've become a regular Dale Gribble
>Later at night, you get a call
>You're weary about answering it... but you do
"Hello-"
>"Nonny! The party's started! Get over here!"
>*click*
>She hangs up as soon as she's done
>To be honest, you were kinda looking forward to this party
>You head out and, for the first time since you came here, you feel that you NEED to lock your door
 
>It's hard to watch out for your stalker this time of night
>But you try not to think about it
>You don't want Pinkie to notice you worrying
 
>You can hear the music from a block away
>As you approach Sugarcube Corner you see Pinkie waiting for you out front
>"You're late Nonny!"
"I got here as fast as I could-"
>"And you missed a whole ten minutes of partying!"
"Ten minutes isn't that much-"
>She practically kicks the door open, grabs you and drags you in
>Holy shit.
>She's done big parties before, but she's really outdone herself this time
>Strobe lights, fog machines, a huge banquet table with all kinds of snacks
>There's some hipster DJ in giant sunglasses, and you wonder how she sees anything in this room with those on
>"Come on Nonny, I need your help for a second."
>Pinkie leads you back into the kitchen, which was blocked off to keep the party goers out
>"This is the one room where partying is not allowed... at least not anymore."
"Anymore? What happened."
>"A little while before you showed up, the kitchen caught fire and almost burned down the whole shop."
"Jeez, what kind of party were you having?"
>"It was just a regular party, I swear!"
>She pulls two trays of cupcakes out of the oven
>"See, there wasn't enough room in the kitchen for a confetti cannon, so I thought I could just put it in the oven with the cake."
"Are... are you serious?"
>"I know, good idea right? Well, apparently confetti is super flammable, but I mean, who could have guessed that?"
"Everyone."
>"Jeez Nonny, you sound just like the fire marshal."
>You laugh, and she can't help but giggle
>The two of you each grab a big plate of assorted snacks and head out
 
>You're bringing the snacks to the banquet table when Pinkie call out
>"hey Fluttershy, I didn't think you'd be making it tonight!"
>"Oh, hi Pinkie! ....hi Anon...."
>She says your name in a whisper, you could barely hear it over the music
"Hey Fluttershy."
>You haven't called her 'Flutters' since she started actually being shy around you
>Since the day at the mall... since Twilight got to her
>"I've got some more snacks going in the kitchen, I'll meet up with you two later!"
>Pinkie hops away, leaving the two of you in awkward silence
 
>The two of you stand next to each other by the snack table
>Neither of you want to be rude and be the one to walk away
>So you just bask in the awkwardness
>"umm.... h-hey Anon..."
"Yeah Fluttershy?"
>"how come... y-you know... you're not out on the dance floor?"
"Oh, umm... I don't know. Guess I'm just not in the mood. Besides, you look like you could use company."
>"y-you really don't have to, you know."
>Was that a passive aggressive 'get away from me'?
>.... nah she wouldn't.... would she?
"Well, I think I'll stick around anyways."
>You smile at her... and for a second she looked like she was about to smile back until she turned away
>The silence comes back, but it doesn't feel as awkward
>"hey.. Anon..."
"Yeah?"
>"despite what Twilight said... I don't think you're... I mean, I think you can be trusted."
>Part of you is feeling feels, those feely feels that feel feely
>Another part of you is screaming 'HEY TWILIGHT FUCK YOU AND YOUR CENTIPEDE-FILLED VAGINA'
"Thanks Fluttershy, that really means-"
>"please... call me Flutters."
"Thanks, Flutters."
>It feels good to call her that again
>"so Anon, how come Twilight thinks you can't be trusted?"
"Eh, she's probably been reading too many mystery novels lately, she probably doesn't trust her own shadow."
>"yeah, I know how that feels."
>The two of you share a laugh. Well, you laugh, she quietly giggles to herself
>You may have finally won Flutters back
 
>You spend God knows how long just chilling by the snack table just hanging out
>Rarity came by, and you managed to keep her from mentioning anything about... anything
>Flutters is finally warming up to you until....
"Damn..."
>"you okay Anon?"
>This fruit punch goes right through you
"Be right back Flutters, I gotta... gotta go."
>It feels weird mentioning going to the bathroom in front of her
 
>You do your business, I'll spare you the details
>You're washing your hands when you hear a knock at the door
"Occupied."
>More knocking. Harder
"Just a minute!"
>The doorknob jiggles
"Alright, just a minute!"
>You dry your hands, very slowly out of spite
>You open the door, but you are immediately pushed back inside
"What are you doing-"
>"Shh!"
>The pony slams the door shut
"... Pinkie? Is that you?"
>"Shh! Someone might hear you!"
>Well whose fault is that?
>She pushes you across the bathroom, towards the bathtub/shower
>You climb into the tub, if you didn't you would have tripped in anyways
>Then she joins you in, and pulls the curtain closed
"I'd ask what you're trying to pull, but I think I know what's going on here."
>"You've seemed a bit down lately, and I just wanted to make sure this party would be perfect to cheer you up!"
>She gives you a wink
>"Especially if we had our own little private party~"
>She starts to undo your pants
>Is she really doing this here? Right here in the bathroom, when there's a party going on outside?
>Good thing she locked the door or you might get caught
>.... she DID lock the door, right?
>You hear a knock, a creak, and the slam of a door
>Shit, someone just came in
>.... and Pinkie's just pulled your pants down
 
>The hoofsteps approach, the toilet being right across from the shower... and facing it
>You better pray that the curtain isn't even slightly see-through
>Despite the nervousness of the situation, it's also a little exciting, and your body can't help but rise to the occasion
>Pinkie leans her face closer to your erect penis and starts nuzzling the head with her nose
>You gasp as she gives you a sudden lick.... probably loud enough for the other pony to hear
>The look on her face screams 'oh shit', and you're sure yours does too
>'o-oh, I'm sorry, I thought no one was in here. i'll come back later."
>The pony tiptoes out and gently closes the door
>Good thing that was Flutters out there, anyone else would have probably caught you
>After a moment, you each let out a sigh of relief
>"Jeez Nonny, I warned you about keeping quiet"
>She's not very good at whispering
"Well maybe if you wanted to do this you could have locked the door."
>"But where's the fun in that?"
>As much as you hate to admit, this is a little fun
>"Now come on, don't you want to have some more fun~?"
>You don't say a word, and she takes that as a yes
>She licks you again, pausing a moment to make sure you can control your voice
>Once she's sure you're in control, she pushes you further into her mouth
>You run your fingers through her mane and push her head down
>She starts bobbing her head up and down
>With every movement her wet tongue brushes your dick
>You naturally feel yourself getting winded, but you know if you DO breathe heavier....
>It's almost unbearable trying to hold your breath in
 
>She moves her head very slowly, as if carefully trying not to make any accidental noise
>Which means that with every bob of her head, her tongue strokes you dick very slowly
>You could feel every bump of her tongue
>Her mouth gets more slippery as her saliva builds up
>She makes an occasional slurping noise, but it's mostly masked by the loud music from outside
>At least, to those on the outside. Inside, every little sound seems to echo
>Her mouth is warm on the inside, and every brush of her tongue sends a rush through your whole body
>You almost lose yourself in the moment when another pony comes in
>You panic when you hear the door open, and your body tenses up
>And by that I mean you pushed Pinkie's head down until it presses against your body
>Not even a single cough or gag from her, now that's talent
>You try to ignore as this other pony does their business
>Which isn't hard to ignore, Pinkie can't stop moving her tongue
>Don't forget, she enjoys this kind of thing
>She even tries to move, so you have hold her head down harder
>.... which only makes her struggle more
>The other pony finishes, washer their hooves and exits
>When you hear the door close you let go
>As soon as you do Pinkie pulls her head back, coughing and gasping for air
"Hey Pinkie, I'm sorry. I didn't mean to do that so-"
>"Fuck me."
>wat
>"Please Nonny... I need it."
>She turns around and puts her ass i the air, presenting her pink pony pussy to you
>How could you say no to this
 
>You grab a hold of her flank and push yourself in
>She apparently got wet already, most likely after almost getting caught
>Despite the easy entrance, she still gasps at your penetration
>You consider covering her mouth, but part of you is convinced that would only make her start moaning
>So you take your chances and let her gasp echo throughout the room
 
>You're moving slower than usual so as to not make any accidental noise
>The way Pinkie moves in synch with you she doesn't seem to mind
>You nervously push in and out of her tight slit
>You're both worried and admittedly excited by the notion of getting caught here
>Unlike the usual slam of your hips against her backside, it's more of a gentle press and pull
>Your cock moves slowly in and out of her, allowing your body to savor every second of each push
>Every little twitch of her body sends a tingle through yours
>She starts moaning, so you go back on your previous choice and cover her mouth
>As was bound to happen, you hear a knock on the door
>You make one last thrust, pushing yourself all the way inside her
>She opens her mouth, and you have a mild panic attack that she's about to make some noise
>.... instead, she pulls your index finger into her mouth with her tongue and starts sucking
>You shouldn't be enjoying this as much as you are now
>Her pussy squeezes as she sucks on the tip of your finger, seemingly involuntary
>The other pony does their business and steps out
>When the door closes, you pull your finger out
>She leans forward for your finger again
>"Nonny... it actually helps"
>You comply and put your finger back in her mouth
>And once you're sure the coast is clear, you start slowly thrusting again
 
>You get into a rhythm
>Anytime someone enters the bathroom, you push in and she sucks your finger harder
>With each intruder, you find yourself more nervous and yet more excited
>Every time that door opens, her legs start to shake
>She licks your finger as if she were genuinely sucking you off
>She starts moving her hips faster than you, and you can hear that quiet slushing sound from her movements
>You try to hold her back so you have more control
 
>Once again another pony enters the bathroom
>As usual, you plunge all the way into Pinkie's insides and hold still
>But she doesn't stop moving
>Pinkie pls
>The other pony does their business
>You hold her back to keep her from speeding up, but you can't stop her entirely
>And you can't tell her to stop because the other pony will hear you no matter how quietly you whisper
>The pony finishes and turns on the sink
>Pinkie's still moving back and forth against you, sliding your dick in and out of her warm insides
>Hopefully the sink will mask any noise
>The sink shuts off
>And what should follow is the clack of the door.... but all you hear is silence
>Pinkie come on we're in the danger zone here
>You hear hoofsteps, but they're coming closer
>No Pinkie stop
>You panic in your mind, but you have no way of stopping her
>And yet... you can't help but enjoy the situation
>She continues to bounce her soft ass against you
>Her body starts to tremble
>You feel your dick throbbing inside her
>No. Not now.
>The silhouette of the other pony shows through the shower curtain
>Damn it Pinkie we are at DEFCON-1 here
>Pinkie slides herself all the way down on you, and finally stops moving
>Just as you release your load inside her
>You start to shake, filled with both pleasure and panic
>Pinkie does a good job of keeping her voice down, though she's sucking your finger pretty hard
>And in what should have been the best moment of the night, the curtain starts to glow with magic
 
>*KNOCK KNOCK KNOCK*
>"Just a second!"
>As soon as you finish saying your prayers, the magic dissipates, and the pony leaves
>It takes you a second to register that voice, and figure out who it was
>Congratulations. You just fucked Pinkie in a shower and came inside her... right in front of Twilight Sparkle
>Twilight leaves, the other pony enters
>The door closes and locks
>You look over at Pinkie, and of course she's fallen asleep
>As she usually does after she cums
>As much as she scared the shit out of you a minute ago, seeing her cute sleeping face almost makes up for it
>Besides, it was pretty fun
>The bathroom is awkwardly silent
>What is that other pony doing?
>*YANK*
>"You know Fluttershy is wondering where you ran off to."
>The shower curtain was suddenly jerked open
"O-oh... hey Rarity."
>Thank God it's only her. Not that this situation is less awkward, but yeah
>You notice her staring at your crotch
>... oh yeah, still out
>She giggles as you fumble trying to get your pants back up
>"Hold on dearie, let me help."
"What, you want some too?"
>You try to be funny but you may have just come off as a creep
>.... Nope, she laughs. Funny it is
>"Hate to disappoint, but a lady like myself doesn't take sloppy seconds."
>She called you sloppy... that does hurt a little
>She pulls your pants back up magically
>"Although given some one-on-one time, I could show you a thing or two~"
>She gives you a wink
>.... You're honestly curious what she could teach you
>"Well that's about it, just told Fluttershy I'd find you for her."
"You're not gonna tell her about..."
>You look over at Pinkie
>"Don't worry darling, I'll cover for you."
>She turns to leave
>"Speaking of cover, you may need a plan of action. You don't want the two of you to be seen leaving together now."
>And with that she exits
>She's right, being seen leaving the bathroom together is bound to start rumors... and they'll probably be right
>You close the curtain to give you time to think
 
>A few ponies come and go, you remain undetected
>You need a way to sneak her and yourself out of here, and soon
>....an idea comes to you
>You quickly get out of the shower and lock the door
>You carry Pinkie to the door, and lean her against it
>*KNOCK KNOCK KNOCK*
"Occupied."
>"mmmhhmm..."
>Pinkie gives a quiet grumble... that actually helps your plan
>You flush the toilet to complete your lie, and open the door
 
>You walk out, Pinkie's hoof around your shoulders as you hold her up
>"Pinkie? Is that you?"
>It's Twilight's other little henchman, Applejack
>"Anon, did you do somethin to her?"
"It's nothing Applejack, Pinkie just got a little too drunk."
>Yup, that's your cover. It's plausible right?
>"...Uh huh, is that so?"
>You had to be caughrt by HER. Pretty much any other pony would have believed you, but no, not Applejack
>She stands at attentoin like a soldier and stares you down
"It's true, I swear."
>"mmhmrrmm..."
>Pinkie mumbles again
>Applejack eases a little, she might be fallnig for it
"I'm taking her upstairs, let her get some rest."
>"Maybe I'll come with you."
"Don't you have to go to the-"
>"I'll hold it."
>Damn she's stubborn
 
>Applejack escorts you up to Pinkie's bedroom, the only other room the party hasn't taken over beside the kitchen
>You lay Pinkie in her bed and pulls the covers over her, then sit by her side
>Glancing back, you see Applejack fidgeting in the doorway
"Applejack, just go. We're good here."
>"... alright fine. But I'll be back in a jiffy, so no funny business."
 
>Applejack leaves the room
>You stay seated next to Pinkie and watch her sleep like the creep that you are
>She quietly snores, and from time to time mumbles something you can't understand
>You bring your hand to her face and gently brush her cheek
>She nuzzels her face into you palm and softly mumbles something
>She does it again, louder
"You awake Pinkie?"
>"..mmhm... appuls..."
"What?"
>"...hi Applejack."
>You look back and see Applejack, peeking in the doorway
>How long has she been there?
>Pinkie slowly gets up, rubbing her eyes and yawning
>"Hey Pinkie, how you feelin'?"
>"Oh, fine. Just a little partied out."
>She looks over at you as if to make sure that's your cover story
>You give her a nod that says 'close enough'
>"And Anon... he didn't try anything... you know, funny, right?"
>Pinkie giggles like she just thought of something funny
>You brace yourself, expectig some sexual joke from Pinkie and a hoof around your neck from Applejack
>"Oh, don't worry about it, Applejack. He wasn't doing anything."
>Thank God she didn't-
>"We finished up a while ago."
>Applejack is up in your face before you even realize what Pinkie just said
>"Now just what the hay is that supposed to mean, Anon!?"
"......"
>You feel like Applejack's glare pierces your soul, leaving you with no idea what to say
>Meanwhile, Pinkie s on the bed lauhgng her head off
>"Don't worry Applejack, I was only joking!"
>Applejack slowly backs away, not breaking her gaze
>"....If you say so..."
>"Come on Nonny, we missed out on a whole bunch of partying while I was out. Time to catch up!"
>She grabs you and pulls you out of the room, oblivious to the awkwardness that just happened
>Applejack slowly follows behind the two of you
 
>Thee three of you rejoin Fluttershy at the snack table
>No surprise she's been there the whole time
>At least Rarity is there to join you
>"there you are Anon, I was wondering where you've been. is everything okay?"
"Yeah, we're fine. Pinkie just had a little too much to drink, so I decided to check on her. You know how she gets."
>Rarity: "I'm sure you do."
>Damnit Rarity, you've been spending to much time with Pinkie
 
>The five of you hang out all night
>Flutters seems as friendly with you than she was before Twilight got to her
>Rarity winks at you anytime someone asks Pinkie  if she feels alright
>Hell, even Applejack is starting to lighten up
>As for Pinkie....well she ate half of the snacks on the table, so it's safe to say she's fine
 
>Night becomes early morning, the part dies down, ponies start leaving
>"it's pretty late, we should probably start heading home."
>The five of you all get together
>Pinkie offers to walk you all home
 
>It's a mostly quiet walk home, even with Pinkie around, until Rarity breaks the silence
>"Well it was a fun night darling, but Fluttershy and I are headed this way."
>The exact opposite direction of your house
"Alright, well see you later."
>"Take care now."
>"goodbye Anon."
>"See you all later!!!"
>As Pinkie waves goodbye to the others like she's having a seizure, you turn to Applejack
"Which way are you headed."
>She points
>Fuck
>"How bout you?"
"... same."
 
>Eventually the three of you get to your place
>Her farm is further up the road thank God
"Well Applejack, I guess I'll see you later or something-"
>"What exactly is going on with you two?"
>That was hardly a question, more like a threat
 
79.
"W-what do you mean-"
>"You heard me!"
>She gets in your face again
>"What the hay is going on with you and Pinkie?!"
 
>Her voice gets gentle, almost calm
>"Sometimes, it seems like you and Twilight are the only ones who make a lick of sense around here, and she..."
>Applejack started avoiding eye contact after mentioning Twilight
>"She's been out of it lately too, but I trust her. And if what she says is true than... I just don't know."
>There's not much you can do here, but you try to inprovise a lie
"Well you see, the thing is-
>"Nonny and I have been experimenting."
>......
>Really? Fucking really? One of her jokes NOW?
"Pinkie, now isn't the time for a joke-"
>"It's no joke Nonny, you know that."
>......
>No. She isn't. She can't.
 
>You stand as Pinkie tells every detail
>Every. Last. Detail.
>You really don't kvow how to feel about this... shame? Embarassment?
>Applejack drifts in an out between shock and confusion
>Even Pinkie is unnaturally timid
 
>She finishes her stories
>"Is... is that true Anon?"
"Yeah."
>"And... with Rarity?"
"Yeah."
>"And Rainbow Dash?"
"Yeah."
>"What about tonight? At the party?"
>Pinkie didn't tell that part, she must not remember
>You hesitate.... fuck
"Uh huh..."
>You can't read her face, but if you had to guess, that's confusion
>At least she's not angry... not yet you think
>She silently heads to the farm, leaving you and Pinkie
>"... sorry Nonny."
"It's okay."
>"It's just that she kept asking, and not just tonight, like a lot-"
"It's fine I get it-"
>"I had to, she was worried and I couldn't just-"
"Pinkie!"
>You didnt mean to sound so angry and loud
>She's startled, but you gently stroke her mane to keep her calm
"It's okay Pinkie. You're right, it's better she knows."
>She sighs
"It's been a long night, you should head back soon-"
>"Nonny..."
>Awkward silence, she fidgets and darts her eyes back and forth
>"I... I'd like to spend the night with you."
>You've spent many nights together, but tonight... it just feels awkward
"Pinkie, I'm-"
>"Please Nonny."
>......
>You open the door and invite her in
 
>The two of you head straight to bed, no sex just cuddling
>With how tightly she holds you, it's more like suffocation
>"Nonny... again, I'm sorry I made tonight so awkward."
"Dont worry about it, it wasn't that bad."
>So you say, disregarding all the spaghetti on your porch five minutes ago
"I knew we'd be in a lot of trouble if we had gotten caught. And I guess that kind of made it more fun, but of course I didn't actually want it to happen."
>She's shaking and you feel a wet spot on your shoulder where she's burying her face, so you stroke her mane to relax her
>"Everyone's gonna find out Nonny-"
"Pinkie please."
>"And worst of all, I'm worried Twilight-"
"Pinkie!"
>You startled her into silence. Again, you may have scared her. You continue the comfort petting
"It's fine, don't worry. Nothing's gonna happen. They'll talk for a while, but they'll forget by the end of the week. Except maybe Dash, but that's just her."
>"But Nonny-"
"But nothing Pinkie. It's going to be fine, trust me."
>She wipes her eyes on your shoulder and stops shaking. You hold her almost as tightly as she is you
>As you drift off to sleep, you hear a quiet whisper in your ear
>"I love you Nonny..."
>You want to respond and you know exactly what you'd say....
>You'd make sure she knew the feeling was mutual
 
>If only you weren't so tired
>....hell you were too tired to ask about the 'Twilight' comment