>You are anonymous
>You have just finished your day at Sweet Apple Acres and are heading home for the day.
>You're tired, but not more than usual.
>You're nonchalantly crossing the field between the farm and Ponyville when you see something out of the corner of your eye.
>A yellow dot...
>Hmm?
>Oh. Its just Fluttershy.
>She glides towards you and stops once she's at ample distance.
>"Good Evening, Anon."
"Hey, Fluttershy. How are you?"
>"I'm doing alright. And yourself?"
"Tired. Been kicking down apples all day." you say with a yawn.
>"Oh, well, umm...if you're not too tired..."
>You're still staring up at her from the ground, you raise your eyebrows to display interest.
>"Well...the girls are out of town at a festival. I had a big pet sitting gig, but it got called off...so I was wondering if you wanted to come over tonight?"
>You look down and think about it, trying to hide the fact that you were just a little excited.
>"And if you can keep a secret?"
>You look up at her again.
"Sure!"
>She stammers a bit, "W-Well...I do get lonely at night."
 
>You snicker at her.
>She looks offended.
>"Anon?"
"Heh, you're joking, right?""
>......
"Oh."
>"Its okay, Anon. I'll just be-"
"Wait!"
>She stops, not looking back at you; obviously humiliated.
"I'm...sorry. Its just, I thought you were joking around."
>She lands and puts her wings down, turning back towards you.
>Her cheeks were flushed with embarrassment, you felt bad for laughing at her now.
>"No, Anon...I wasn't."
>You rub the back of your neck, looking away from the yellow Pegasus.
>The sun was setting, making the field in between Ponyville and the Cottage glow a vibrant orange.
>The evening wind pushed past both of you, as you sat in silence.
>You clear your throat.
"I have some things to finish up back at my place...I guess I cou-"
>"Really?" she says, a surprised look on her face.
>You can't help but grin at that. It was just too adorable.
"Mhm, yeah, I don't see why not."
>She flies up to you and hugs you.
>"Oh, anon! Thank you!"
>Your heart flutters.
>Okay anon, keep it together. She probably just sees you as a friend and simply wants company over.
>You hug her back, not ignoring her embrace.
>After a couple seconds you both let go, and you look into her eyes for a moment before hers dart away in shyness.
"Well, I'll be back in an hour or two, fluttershy."
>She nods, taking flight again.
>"Okay, anon. I'll just be tending to the animals before it gets too dark."
>With a nod and a smile, you turn around and head home.
 
---
 
>As you finished up your daily routine, you gather a couple of things and head to the cottage.
>You walk through Ponyville, the streelights now casting light over the buildings.
>A few ponies here and there, but most everyone is retired to their homes by now.
>The cool night air feels good in your lungs, and you're excited to spend some time with Fluttershy.
>You mumble to yourself as you walk.
"Out of all the people she wants 'me' to spend time with her?"
>You're staring at the ground as you walk, brow furrowed in deep thought.
"Could she..."
>No, no. She couldn't. She was just being friendly. That is her element, isn't it? Kindness? That's just her normal behavior. Its not like she has any special interest in you.
>You'd successfully killed any sort of excitement for yourself by over-thinking it.
"Fuck."
>You sigh in disappointment and pull out a flashlight from your backpack; ponyville's lights not being sufficient for the walk to the cottage.
>You point it at the ground so you can see where you're walking.
>.....
>Come on, anon. Maybe...Maybe there is something?
>You shake your head, as if trying to free yourself from that thought.
>You remember the times when you had hyped yourself up for something like this and been disappointed. Not again. Its just fluttershy being fluttershy, so stop thinking like that.
>Princess Luna's moon was reaching above the horizon now, lighting the home in the distance.
 
>You stop and look at the moonlit cottage.
>A night breeze rushes past you and you breathe in the fresh air, trying to calm yourself down.
"Okay, enough worrying. Lets just...do this."
>You try to force a smile and look at the situation in a positive light.
>As you continue to walk, you know that even if she doesn't return the feelings you may or may not have, you were making her happy by being there for her.
>In the end, that is enough of a reward for you.
 
>You're now nearing her cottage, light emanating from the windows.
>You walk the slanted path up to the front door way.
>You stop and stare at the door.
>Alone time...with...her.
>And theres the butterflies in your stomach.
>Calm down, anon.
>You lift your right hand and knock on the cottage door.
>After a couple of seconds, the door creaks open. There she is.
>"Hey, anon...please, come inside."
>You smile and click off your flashlight.
>After taking off your backpack and shoes at the door, you put your flashlight away.
>Your breath is heavy. Keep it together.
>She walks into the other room.
>"Is there anything I can get you to drink, anon? I got tea, water, lemonade..."
"Waters fine."
>You looked around, taking in the sights.
>She had a lot of 'animal' themed objects decorating the living room. Bird cages, dog beds, feeders and the like.
>Wouldn't expect any different from her.
>You take a deep breath and take a seat on one of her couches, your nerves still tense.
 
>Fluttershy hovers back into the living room, a tray with a pitcher of water and a small glass.
>The ice makes clinking noises as she approaches you.
>"Here you are, anon."
"Thanks, fluttershy. I really appreciate it."
>"Oh, its no problem at all."
>She sets it down on the table in front of the couch.
>You help yourself to a glass of water; you need it. All this worrying was making you thirsty.
>"Did you find your way here in the dark alright?"
>Keeping her distance, she lands on the other side of the couch and sits.
>You take a few sips of your water.
Yeah, my flashlight proved useful. How are the animals?
>You put your right leg and cross it under your left, and face towards her.
>"They're all tucked away for the night. It went smoothly, though. Angel didn't give me too much trouble."
>You smile and laugh.
"Yeah, Angel can be a nuisance sometimes."
>"That's what I like about him though. He's got a spunky personality."
>You continue to small talk with her without a hitch.
>The crickets chirp outside, the cool breeze coming in through the windows. Its a really calming atmosphere.
>Or it would be a calming atmosphere if...'she' wasn't sitting right next to you.
>Your heart was still pounding in your chest, but you successfully keep your cool as you both chat.
>You don't notice it, but you finish off the entire pitcher of water...damn.
>She notices and moves to get up.
>"I'll go get you some more water, Anon."
"No, that's okay. I should be good."
>She sets herself back down.
>You smile at her warmly.
 
>She smiles back at you.
>"Thank you for coming, Anon. It really does get lonely here once all the animals are asleep."
>You relax your body and lean back in the couch a bit, your nervousness subsiding partially.
"You know, you could have gone with Twilight and the others to the festival."
>She blinks a few times and replies, "Well, I thought I was going to be sitting for some animals, so when they called it off, I didn't have enough time to find somepony to watch 'my' animals...so, my hooves were tied."
>You had your responsibilities on Sweet Apple Acres, so it would have been impossible to watch them for her.
>"Anyway, so hows work going?" She asks, laying down and tucking her fore hooves under herself.
>You sigh and breathe in.
"Its a lot of hard work. The Apple family are just a wonderful bunch to work with though. Applejack is a lot of fun too."
>"Oh? Hows that?" She asks
"Well, apple bucking can get pretty boring. So we make it a competition to see who can get the most apples. She beats me every time though."
>You go on to talk about Applejack without even really thinking about it.
"And so she turns around and calls me-"
>"Anon?"
"Oh. Yes?"
>"Do you like Applejack?"
"Yeah, of course I do."
>"O-Oh...No, I mean...'like like.'"
".....Oh."
>Well that is bold of her to ask.
>You can feel your face burning up. Oh fuck, she's going to get the wrong idea.
>You stammer
"N-No! I would never think of Applejack like that...she's more like a sister to me than anything..."
 
>"Oh..." she says.
>Her furrowed brow from your sudden outburst didn't leave the impression that she was convinced...at all.
>Oh please, no.
>All power to reverse thrusters.
"Look, I really don't like her like that...don't get the wrong impression."
>"I didnt mean to pry-"
"You didn't. Its just...well, I really do like working with her, but that's as far as it goes. I can see where you got the idea, though."
>Her ears perk up.
>"So is there anypony that you do like?"
>Your heart jumps
>You wince at the sudden jerk from it
>Holy shit, anon calm down.
"Well...."
>Your face is burning again
>"Oh! So you do!" she says with a grin.
>I guess you're THAT easy to read.
>Again, she's being very bold. I guess that means she's comfortable around you at least.
>"Right?" she asks
>You snap back to attention.
"Haha, well, I'm a human and everyone around here is a pony so-"
>STOP
>"O-Oh...so you don't-"
"No, I didn't mean that...I do."
>She looks confused.
>God dammit, anon.
>You try to get this conversation back on track.
"Yes, you're right. I do."
>Her furrowed brow fades, dismissing your previous comment.
>"So? Who is the special pony?" she asks.
>Your hearts pounding now.
>"If...you don't want to tell me, I understand."
>Sweat is beading on your forehead, it feels really hot in here suddenly.
>Come on, spit it out anon.
>"Oh! I have an idea!" she interjects.
>You look at her
>"How about I ask twenty questions about her, and I try to guess who it is?"
>No going back now.
 
"Uhh, sure."
>She scoots a little bit closer to you on the couch before she starts.
>"So, does she live here in Ponyville?"
"Yes."
>"Does she talk a lot?"
"No."
>You're going all out truthful on this.
>"Does she read a lot?"
"Not that I know of."
>"Party a lot?"
"No."
>"Is she an Earth pony?"
"No."
>"Unicorn?"
"No."
>"So she's a Pegasus?!" she asks.
"Yep. And that counts as a question."
>"Oh...well is her coat blue?"
"Nope."
>"Orange?"
"No."
>"Red?"
"No."
>"Yellow?"
>You're quiet for a moment.
>You clear your throat.
"Yes."
>"Alright, so that's a yellow Pegasus who lives in ponyville..."
>Her speech slows down as she comes to the sudden realization.
>The gears are turning in her head.
>She quiet for a couple of moments.
>"A-Anon?"
"Mhm?"
>"Is the special somepony...."
>HERE IT COMES
>"Golden Glory? She seems like a really nice pony! I'm happy for you!"
>You resist the urge to slap your open palm against your forehead. Is she REALLY this dense?
>"She's one of the ponies who helped me and Rainbow Dash make the tornado for cloudsda-"
"Fluttershy."
>"Oh. Yes?"
"I don't like Golden Glory."
>Her eyes widen a little bit.
>"Oh. I could have sworn I was right."
>She starts thinking again.
>"Well.. I can't really think of any of the yellow pegasi who live in Ponyville off the top of my head. Maybe I just don't know her.
>This couldn't be going any worse. You've dropped hint after hint and she's not picking up on it.
>What if she's not picking up on it on purpose...?
 
"You know her."
>"Oh. I do?" she asks.
"Yep."
>In deep thought again, she sighs.
>"W-Well, then who is it? I give up."
>You raise an eyebrow. Okay, she isn't this dense. Somethings up.
>You breathe in deep and let out a sigh.
"You, Fluttershy."
>Silence.
>The silence drags for what seems to last forever, but she finally breaks it.
>"I...I figured...I just didn't think it would...or could be me." she says.
>You're both avoiding eye contact, you could cut the tension in the air with a knife.
"So...what do you think?" you ask.
>She thinks for a moment before speaking up, "I'm happy." she says.
>You both make eye contact. Her shimmering blue eyes make your heart beat even faster.
>"I got excited when you started dropping hints...but I was too shy to ask if it was me."
"I figured."
>Theres a short silence again.
>"But I umm..."
>Please don't shut me down, not after all this.
>"I feel the same..."
>What.
>WHAT?!
>You look back toward her, her face is flushed a deep red.
"You do?"
>She makes eye contact, "Mhm. Yes."
>You can hardly believe it. She feels the same about you? Please don't let this be a dream.
"When...When did you know that you liked me?"
>She gets up from her spot and sits next to you.
>Keep it cool.
>"Well when you first arrived here, I was intrigued since you seemed like a new animal. But as I got to know you...well, I just started feeling this way."
 
>You cant help but feel an overwhelming sense of joy.
>Sometimes you feel really lucky that you came to this world.
>She moves closer, and presses her shoulder against your arm.
>You look down at her, her big blue eyes staring back into yours. She has a smile on her face.
>"I'm glad that I didn't go to the festival, anon."
>You smile and laugh.
"Yeah, me too."
>Your faces start inching closer towards one another
>This is it, Anonymous! You got this!
>thump thump thump thump thump
>What?
>thump thump thump thump thump
>She breaks eye contact with you and looks towards the center of the room.
>"Oh, angel! What are you doing up?!" she asks, upset.
>You blink in disbelief.
>She walks to the center of them room, and you turn your head.
>There was angel, his arms crossed with an angered expression, tapping his foot.
>That. Little. Shit.
>"Angel. Its way past your bedtime. Come on, I'll take you to your bed."
>Angel doesn't even look at Fluttershy, he just stares at you.
>Oh, you little fuck.
>Fluttershy giggles, "Sorry, anon. I guess Angel waited to be trouble until you got here."
>Yeah, you think?
>Right at the perfect moment. How long was he watching?
>You're bummed now. That better not be the end of this.
>You'll have my revenge on that little shit, you swear it.
>After a few moments fluttershy hovers back into the room.
>"I'm really sorry about that, anon...you know Angel."
>You sigh, but smile.
"Its alright, fluttershy."
 
>She floats back onto the couch, right where she had been.
>"Now, where were we?"
>She flashes you bedroom eyes.
>HEART. HURTS.
>Oh fuck. Maybe she's making up for that little hiccup? I'm not complaining.
>Blood rushes to your face again.
"I think we were just about to..."
>You rotate on the couch so that you're facing her directly.
>Nothing is robbing this from you this time.
>You stare into each other's eyes as you inch in closer once again.
>You can feel her breath, sending shivers up your spine.
>You lock lips with her.
>Touchdown.
>She presses her body up against yours, and you wrap your arms around her.
>Locked in a warm embrace with Fluttershy, you continue to lip wrestle with her.
>You break your locked lips every so often so you can breathe and stare into each other's eyes.
>Her mouth feels amazing, especially when she starts using tongue.
>Holy fuck.
>Again, you break your mouth lock. Your lower your head and start kissing her neck.
>She shudders, her breath shakes violently as it comes out.
>"A-Anon..." she giggles, "I didn't think you wanted to do..."
>She pauses.
>You pull back so you face her again
"Fluttershy, I know we just confessed to each other, but...I've been stuck here for a long time and we-"
>"I understand. I'm okay with it." She shoots another grin your way.
>You can't help but smile yourself.
"Fluttershy..."
"Anon..."
>You lock lips again, you knew where this was going. You could scarcely believe it.
 
>You have your right hand on the left side of her face, you're both pressing into each other...she's warm.
>You break, and she breathes hard...
>"Anon..."
>You catch your breath a bit yourself.
"Yeah?"
>"Do you want to umm...lay down?"
>You stare at her for a second.
"Yeah, sure."
>She hops off the couch and you lay down. She climbs up on top of you and looks into your eyes with this...look. A look like she had you right where she wanted you.
>She lines up her face with yours and lays down on top of you.
>You begin kissing again.
>You breath in sharply as she begins to straddle her hips into yours.
>It feels amazing.
>More chills shooting up your spine, you shudder as she pushes herself onto your manhood.
>You stop kissing and look at each other while she does it...
>She moans..."Anon..."
>She's really into this.
>Her face is flushed red, much like yours probably is right now.
>"I want you inside of me, Anon..." she moans.
>You feel you're as hard as one of Rarity's diamonds.
>You take charge, picking her up in your arms as you rise from the couch.
"Wheres your bedroom, Fluttershy?"
>She smiles at you and points to the hall on the left.
>You press your weight against the door, opening it.
>Once inside, you shut it with your feet and make sure its locked. Angels not getting in here.
>You lay fluttershy down on her bed, and take your shirt off.
>"Anon..."
Hmm?
>"This...is my first time, so please be gentle."
>You get to be the man who deflowers fluttershy. Pride wells up inside of you.
 
>You pull off your pants and get on top of fluttershy, who is laying her back.
>"Take my virginity, anon." she whispers.
>You're now halfway convinced your dick could break diamond.
>You climb on top of her, she immediately wraps her back legs around your lower back.
>She pulls you down so that she can grind against you.
>For her first time, she's doing pretty damn good.
>As your cock presses against her mare pussy through your boxers, she shudders again.
>Her voice sent shivers down your spine again.
>You pull out your cock from your underwear, pressing it against the moist outer area of her marehood.
>You don't put it inside just yet, but you slowly grind it against her.
>She's whimpering now, her body trembling.
>Fluttershy continues to moan your name as you do it.
>"Anon...." "Anon...."
>She's wet, her juices getting on your dick. You were going to need it to get through her hymen.
>You begin tongue wrestling with her again as you press against her, slowly increasing speed. Your head and shaft brushing back and forth past her clitoris.
>Its driving her mad, you can tell.
>Her body continues to quiver, and she shudders heavily.
>"Anon, it feels so good...please don't stop..."
>You oblige her request and increase the speed again.
>She's letting out squeeks of pleasure now, becoming more and more wet.
>This was the best foreplay of your life.
>"A-A-Anon...let me taste you..."
>"I want to suck it..." she shudders.
>You nod at her request and flip onto your back.
 
>She gets up from her back and onto her hooves, she shifts over so she's in front of your cock.
>"It...It looks so different than..."
>She stops when she notices a little drop of pre-cum on the very tip.
>With her hoof, she pokes it, the cum sticking onto her.
>She examines it for a moment, before putting the tip of her hoof into her mouth and eating the pre-cum.
>Nice.
>She shifts her attention back to your dick, her blue eyes looking it over.
>Her eyes shift to yours before she lets the head slide into her mouth.
>You grit your teeth and your toes curl up. Her mouth feels amazing on your head.
>She shifts her tongue from side to side along the bottom of the head.
>Popping out of her mouth she says, "Does that feel good, anon?"
>You look at her and nod.
>She goes back down on it, this time getting some of the shaft inside.
>Working up and down your shaft with her mouth, she makes muffled moaning noises as she sucks on it.
>You cant help but moan yourself now.
>She drags her tongue across the head of your cock as she sucks.
"F-Fluttershy..."
>It pops out of her mouth again.
>"Mmm, yes, anon?"
"I want to taste you too."
>Her eyes widen a bit, her face flushing red even more.
>"Alright, anon."
>She pushes herself up and turns around, her mare cunt now directly in your face.
>She teases you by waving it around a bit.
>"You want it, anon?"
>You stare in amazement. This was almost too good.
>She puts it near your face and drags it away again.
>God damn.
 
>You grab the front of her hind legs and pull her marehood down to your face.
>Startled, she squeaks...her squeaking soon turning into moaning as your bury your tongue inside of her.
>In a high pitched voice she says, "Anon, that feels almost too good."
>Yeah, we'll see.
>You pull your tongue out and begin to graze your tongue back and forth across her clitoris.
>Hushed moaning begins to climb as she starts to squeal in pleasure, driving you to fuck her with your mouth even more.
>"Anon...stop..."
>Nah.
>You keep going, despite her protest.
>"It feels too good anon...I'm gonna..."
>She's already close to her first orgasm.
>Nope. Changing your mind, you stop; her first orgasm belongs to your dick.
"Fluttershy, turn around."
>Breathing hard, she listens to you, turning back and facing you again.
>She sits in your lap and lines her face up with yours again.
>This time you showed no hesitation. It was time to deflower her.
"Fluttershy, this is gonna hurt."
>"I know...but I'll try my best for you, anon."
>With all the resolve you needed, you begin to push your cock past her lips and inside of her.
>"Ahhh~" She moans...
>Sliding inside of her slowly, her walls react by closing in on you.
>You reach her hymen...well, here goes nothing.
>You press your head against it, she yelps in pain in response.
"Sorry..."
>"Its okay...I'm okay..." she whispers.
>You press against it again, trying to break through...you could feel the clearing as you put pressure on it.
>Her eyes were squeezed shut, her teeth gritting.
>You break through.
>Both of you take a moment to recuperate and catch your breath.
 
>Now through her hymen, you had free reign of her pussy.
>You begin slowly, the walls of her insides pressing hard against your dick.
>Her pussy lips hug your shaft, retracting and receding as you pump in and out of her
>You stare into each other's eyes while you fuck her
"Fluttershy..."
>"An-" she inhales quickly, "Anon..."
>She is drenched now, your cock making slapping noises as you fucker her.
>"Sl-Slow down, anon..."
>You are getting a bit carried away, but you have a hunch she is close again.
>Her walls are tightening, and she was getting even wetter
>You slow down a bit, but kept a good pace.
>"Anon...I'm going to...I can't hold on anymore."
>This was it.
>She isn't even trying to hold back her voice now, you're glad the cottage was removed from Ponyville.
>She squeals loudly as her walls begin to squeeze around your cock, juices excreting from inside of her.
>It does nothing but make it more slippery, wet and warm.
>"That...was amazing..." she moans.
"Can you still go?"
>She nods, lowers her head to your left ear and moans, "Please give me more."
>The breath brushing past your ear makes you shiver, but you start to pound her harder nonetheless.
>Riding on top of you, she moans loudly as you continue to pass in and out of her.
>"Anon...please, cum inside of me...I want your children..."
>Though children aren't possible, you still feel a wave of hormones rush through your blood.
>You feel you're about to cum...
 
>Her previous comment driving you overboard, you go full force and fuck her as hard as you can.
>The overwhelming feeling of pleasure drowns out everything but you and Fluttershy. Its just you and her.
>"Pl-Please, Anon...Cum inside me..."
>She begins to thrust her hips against your cock, her moaning growing louder, you could tell another orgasm was coming on.
>More shivers as you finally reach orgasm as well.
>A wave of endorphins blasts through your brain, sending you into a blind wave of pleasure.
>You moan loudly, her squealing loudly as you both endure the muscles spasms of orgasm.
>You push against Fluttershy and pull her down onto you, your cock being able to shoot your sperm as far in as possible.
>Fluttershy's orgasm opens her insides up, inviting your semen to be taken in.
>"Please, anon! Give me your cum!"
>You shoot seven blasts of hot semen into her womb, both of you staring into each other's eyes while it happens.
>You slow to a crawl, letting your cock slide out of her.
>She collapses on top of you, breathing heavier than she ever had.
>You wrap your arms around her and pull her close.
>"Y-You don't want to leave?"
"What? No."
>"I figured you'd want to leave when you were do-"
"Do you mind if I sleep over?"
>She lifts her self up and looks at you, a warm grin washing over her face.
>"Not at all. I'd prefer if you did."
>You smile at her and pull her in close again.