edited prose: http://www.fimfiction.net/story/307540/24/fluttershy-wants-in-your-pants/return-to-earth
 
----
>You walk up to Fluttershy's cottage with dread in your heart.
>It had to be done.
>Walking inside, you hear her familiar happy hum as she brushes her animals!
>"O-oh! Anon! I've missed you all day."
>She flies up to you and wraps you in a tight hug.
>You gently push her off of you and sit on her couch.
>God damn it.
>You promised yourself you wouldn't cry.
>"W-what's wrong Anon?"
>She sits next to you, holding your hand gently.
>Fluttershy wipes a tear from your face and her face is filled with concern.
>"Why aren't you saying anything?"
>You take a deep breath to steel yourself for what you have to say.
>"I-is something wrong?"
"We can't do this anymore Fluttershy."
>"..."
>She holds your hand tight.
>"W-what? What do you mean Anon?"
"I can't be your special somepony anymore. I'm sorry."
>Her eyes begin to drown in tears and her voice can't stay calm anymore.
>"B-but Anon... you were the only one who could make me happy..."
"I'm sorry Shy. It's over."
>"I promise I'll do better!"
"It's too late."
>You get up to leave her cottage.
>"Anon... please don't leave me..."
>Don't look back Anon.
>"I'm sorry..."
"I'm sorry too... It's time for me to go home."
>You leave her cottage and she flies to the door.
>"Anon please don't go..."
"I have to."
>"You are all I have left."
>She holds you tightly, believing that if she holds you now and never let go that you will stay.
"I have to go back to earth Fluttershy. I'm sorry."
>"Maybe Celestia will let me go too!"
"I already asked. You have to stay here."
>She lets go of you and falls to the ground in a sobbing mess.
"I'm sorry it had to end this way..."
>You walk away from the cottage, trying to stay strong.