"(Shorts) - Anon x Rarity"
By MLP-CYOA-Writer-Dude (https://pastebin.com/u/MLP-CYOA-Writer-Dude)

URL: https://pastebin.com/N6qQrXBJ
Created on: Monday 12th of August 2013 01:45:31 AM CDT
Retrieved on: Sunday 25 of October 2020 10:54:04 AM UTC


>After living in Equestria for a few months, you've found life to be easy and relaxing.
>You've adjusted to everything well, and you've made quite the impression on all the wondrous ponies.
>Of course, the lack of a suitable mate has thrown you off your game.
>You didn't mind all the round, soft pony plots that were in abundance in Ponyville....
>You just didn't really find anyone here to be extremely worthy of your time.
>Well... except for one beautiful mare....

>Your first few weeks in Ponyville were rough.
>Luckily for you, a certain marshmallowy lady was generous enough to give you a place to sleep and food to eat. 
>Eventually, you began to work for her in her boutique.
>Everything from rearranging, to heavy lifting, to even being her own personal mannequin.
>You grew fond of her quickly.
>You were sure she felt the same way.
>But how could you be sure?
>You really wanted to give her subtle signs of your attraction.
>Just to let her know you were interested.
>Maybe a long hug....
>Maybe a gentle nuzzle....
>Maybe a-
>"Anonymous, my dear? Are you ok?"
>Your focus returns, and reality comes back into play.
>Rarity was looking at you, awaiting a response.
"Uh... y-yeah... huh?"
>You stammer on and on, not forming any coherent sentences.
>In the last few weeks of your stay with Rarity, this is how most of your conversations started and ended.
>It was difficult, but Rarity most likely wasn't catching on.

>"Are you sure, darling?"
>Rarity gives you another worried look.
>You rub your face and give her a smile.
"Do you have any more work for me today?"
>She flips her beautiful mane in response.
>"Well... I'm not feeling to well. I've decided to close the Boutique early and go take a nice long shower."
>You nod, showing her that you are -mostly- being attentive.
>"We've made enough business today anyways, so don't we deserve a nice break?"
>Rarity proceeds to lock up the various drawers and containers around you, as was normal for when the Boutique was closing or the night.
>You can't help but keep your eyes locked on her the entire time.
>The way she flows about the room.
>So elegant and carefree, yet completely focused.
>She is so beautiful.
>How is it possible that she hasn't found a suitable mate yet?
>Maybe it's a sign for you to step it up.
>In the meantime, it's enough to satisfy your yearning by watching this gorgeous display.

>Rarity locks up the final few bits of merchandise.
>Clothing levitating through the air thanks to her unicorn magic.
>It really was like watching a magic show.
>But far more lovely.
>The magician, that is.
>You can't help but just want her to keep going.
>Entrancing you more, and more....
>"Anon, did you hear me? What is up with you today, darling?"
>You shake your head quickly, trying to come back into focus.
>Too much daydreaming for one evening.
>Rarity trots over to you, looking more worried than before.
>"Anon, please tell me what's bothering you! You've been acting just so strange lately.... It's not like you! Have you been hanging out with Applejack again?"
>Rarity did tend to get overprotective of you whenever you went out...
>But that had nothing to do with how you feel now.
>All you can think about is Rarity.
>Rarity.
>Rarity.
>Rarity.
"Rarity, I just...."
>You gulp loudly.
>You could just tell her now, and be done with it.
>She will look repulsed by your offer, and forever shun you.
>Then, you can move on.
>You'll just tell her how much you really care for her.
>How beautiful you think she looks.
>How sexy her voice is.
>How she constantly makes you feel like you're not alone in Equestria.
>Just tell her how you feel, Anon.
>Spit it out!
"Rarity, I think that I may be in l-"
>You are interrupted by a knock at the door.
>Your heart almost shoots out of your chest.
>"Oh, darn... Hold on a minute dear!"
>Rarity trots over to answer the door.
>You quickly try to catch your breath as Rarity tells a customer she is closed for the evening.
>After a few seconds, she returns looking frustrated.
>"That old mule tried to tell me that he can get better designs from a flea market! Well! I'd like to see him try! I'll be upstairs taking a shower. Please feel free to spend your evening doing anything else. Hmph!"
>As she angrily heads upstairs to her bedroom, you can only think about how much you want to spend your evening with her.

>Now isn't the time to be scared.
>You need to go tell her how you feel.
>You need to first comfort her, of course.
>But THEN tell her how much you mean to her.
>You leave the room and head up the stairs in her wake.
>You were stomping quite loudly on the stairs.
>Luckily, her parents and her loud (but cute) sister went on a trip to Manehattan for the weekend.
>You make haste, for you want to catch her before she takes her undoubtedly long shower.
>You arrive at her bedroom door, it being slightly ajar.
>You give it a quick tap.
>"Yes, is that you Anon? Please come in! I need a favor!"
>She was clearly yelling from her bathroom.
>Dammit.
>You missed your chance.
>Regardless, you head into her room.
>Large, lush, and fragrant are the three words that you've always described her room.
>Tidy would be a suitable one as well.
>Her cleanliness and attention to detail were just a pair of her traits that you had fallen in love with.
"What do you need, Rarity?"
>You hear the shower running.
>A bit of steam is leaking from underneath the bathroom door.
>It probably feels really nice in there....
>"Clumsy me! I forgot a towel... could you be a dear and bring me one? The purple one, if you could...."
>You agree, and head over to her linen closet.
>After a bit of rummaging, you find her incredibly comfortable purple towel.
>She made this on the day she met you.
>She said that you looked good in purple....
>You grab it and head over to the bathroom door.

>Now what...?
"I... uh, got it right here! Should I just leave it or..."
>You hear Rarity drop something in the tub.
>"Drat! Come in, Anon. I can't hear you too well. And don't forget that towel!"
>You gulp nervously.
>This can't be happening!
>You were glad it was, but damn is this great!
>Don't get ahead of yourself, caballero.
>Take it easy.
>You're just bring your best friend a towel.
>That's it.
>What else could happen?

>You peer into the bathroom before you waltz in.
>The heat refreshes your body, but the steam makes it hard to see.
>You hear Rarity drop something else in the tub.
>"Drat...!"
>You laugh to yourself as you think of a corny prison joke.
>You slowly enter the bathroom.
>You make your way to the counter and gently lay the towel upon it.
>All good, now let's get out.
>Just as you turn around, you hear Rarity drop something yet again.
>"Ugh! Anon! Would you be so kind as to bring me a new bath pouf? This one keeps..."
>Drop.
>You quickly search the bathroom for another pouf before Rarity has a cow.
>Found it.
"I got it Rarity. Should I just...."
>"Well, bring it here!"
>WAT.
"Uh... what was that? I-I couldn't hear-"
>Rarity flings the shower curtain open.
>And here you thought she looked beautiful dry....
>The hot water splashes over her pristine coat, making it shimmer even more beautifully.
>Her mane droops down her face and neck, still retaining that gorgeous purple color you've come to love.
>Her face was slightly rosy, which could be from any number of things.
>Really, all you could think of this was.
"Wow...."

>You were having a hard time fighting the creeping erection in your pants.
>But you knew that wasn't you.
>No, you just want to embrace Rarity.
>Hold her ever so tightly.
>Wash her, massage her, rub her.
>Love every single essence of her being.
>Damn was she making it hard to resist. 
>You stand there, staring stupidly in her direction.
>Rarity waves at you.
>Your attention does not return so quickly.
>"A-anon! Hello!?"
>You just couldn't stand it anymore.
>You shake your head and rub your face.
>"Anon, what is it, darling?"
"Dammit, Rarity. You look absolutely stunning. You always do. You always look so..."
>Before you can finish, Rarity grabs the pouf out of your hand with her magic.
>Your heart drops completely out of your chest.
>You had a feeling this would happen....
>Rarity doesn't feel the same way....
>You just knew it.
"R-rarity, I'm sorry, I..."
>She slowly pulls the pouf towards her.
>She sighs deeply, and places it in the tub.
>The shower seems much hotter all of a sudden.
>Before you can continue to say anything, Rarity's magic engulfs your upper body.
>She slowly and gently pulls your shirt off.
>You look into Rarity's large, blue eyes.
>She gives you a smile, and you see her face get redder.
>"Won't you join me, darling?"

>This obviously must be a dream….
>You pinch yourself a few times.
>Nope, definitely reality.
>Before you can react further, you look down to your pants.
>Rarity was undoing the button.
>You look up at her.
>Her hair now covered her face, but you could tell she was smiling at you.
>You hear a long zip.
>Within an instant your pants fall to the ground.
>Followed soon by your boxers.
>You struggle to form a coherent thought about the current situation.
>But you feel like Rarity is tugging on your mind.
>Pulling you further.
>She knows that you’ve wanted this.
>She’s wanted it too.
>Rarity is completely in control.
>And you’re going to let her be.
>As you stand there naked, Rarity backs up in the shower a bit.
>No need really.
>Her shower is enormous for a pony shower.
>Bigger than you’ve ever seen, in fact.
>You feel Rarity’s magic pull your body gently.
>She really wants you to be in the shower with her.
>Who are you to deny her?
>You slowly step towards the shower.
>Your member gets a bit harder, but you manage to control it.
>You don’t want to scare her off!
>Rarity continues to giggle as her magic persuades you to join her hot shower.
>You step in, letting the water hit you at full blast.
>It feels absolutely amazing.
>Not to mention the fact that there is an amazingly perfect mare standing in front of you.
>You reach over and move her mane from in front of her face.
>Her visage is a deep red now.
>You can’t help but smile at this.
>”Oh, Anon…. Darling…!”
>She stands on her hind legs, positioning her forehooves on your shoulders.
>You instinctively put your own hands on her lower back, holding her close to you.
>Your faces are mere inches from one another.
>”Kiss me, Anon. Please…. Just kiss me….”

>You can’t even process what she said.
>She just presses her lips against yours.
>You stagger slightly, not expecting the kiss.
>You return the sign of affection with equal force.
>You pull her lower body closer into yours, her soft coat brushing against your bare skin.
>The water continues to fall as the two of you embrace.
>Her tongue begs for you to give her more.
>You comply, sliding your tongue into her mouth.
>Rarity’s mouth feels so perfect.
>Her lips, her tongue.
>Her saliva, so warm and inviting.
>You wonder how long she had felt this way.
>But it doesn’t matter.
>This moment is too precious to not focus on.
>You eventually pull away, wanting to lay down all of your feelings for her.
>Rarity looks into your eyes, but quickly gets off of you.
>Her face looks a tad strained.
>She hides behind her mane, clearly in shame.
>”I… I don’t know what’s gotten over me…. It’s so… unladylike… Anon, I’m so sorry, I-“
>You pull Rarity back into your embrace.
“Rarity, don’t apologize. You hear me? Don’t apologize.”
>Her face glows with happiness as she climbs back on your shoulders.
>You decide to get a bit more playful.
>You pick her up by her flank, hoping she’ll comply.
>She doesn’t even hesitate to wrap her legs around your waist.
>You hold her tightly still, kissing her all over her neck and face.
>Rarity moans softly as you continue to give her the utmost affection.

>You feel the warmth of the shower begin to slightly fade.
>You can’t even remember how long you’ve been in there with her.
>Honestly, it’s not long enough.
>You move your hands lower on her back.
>You feel her tail invite you lower.
>You’re scared to go on, so you decide to test the waters more.
>You give her rump a playful squeeze.
>”Oh! Anon!”
>She gives you the most loving eyes, and a smile that says it all.
>”You… you can hold me there. Come now… don’t be so shy!”
>You waste no time sliding your hands right down to her round rear.
>You squeeze both of her cheeks.
>Rarity responds with a loud moan.
>She buries her head into your chest and begins to nibble you.
>You continue to rub her rear and her thighs, eliciting as many responses as you can.
>You’re so overrun with emotion that you are unsure of what to do next.
>Rarity senses your uncertainty, and begins guide your hands.
>She moves your hand right up in between her soft rear.
>You feel her warm and moist nethers.
>You hesitate slightly.
>”It’s ok, darling, I want you to….”
>She forces your hand inside her warm marehood.
>Rarity moans louder than ever.
>You feel your own member get hard in an instant.
>You begin to rub her slowly, milking the pleasure out of her slowly, but surely.
>Her warm juices begin to cover your hand.
>”Ohh…. An-Anon… give me more, please…. Please….”
>You feel her magical grip loosen on your hands, giving you more freedom.
>You continue to rub her soaking marehood.
>Rarity moans louder and louder with each rub of her clit.
>She wraps her tail tightly around your arm.
>You finger her faster and faster….
>”Anon! Oh, Anon!!! Yes!!!”
>She bites down hard on your chest to suppress a scream.
>Her lower body jitters as she squirts her warm juices.
>She moans your name loudly as her orgasm throws her body into a state of nirvana.
>You slowly remove your fingers, returning to holding her plump rump.
>Rarity lies against your body, breathing heavily.
>She eventually lifts her head and gives you a peck on the lips.
>”It’s your turn, I think….”

>You don’t even feel worth of letting her do anything.
>Before you can even decline any attention, she pulls herself off of you.
>Her magic gently tugs at your hard cock.
>It’s like nothing you’ve ever felt before.
>Like the softest and warmest hands were stroking your member up and down.
>You slide back against the wall of the shower.
>You let a large moan escape from your mouth.
>Rarity giggles as she continues to magically pleasure your manhood.
“Rarity… shit… ugh….”
>Rarity shushes you and begins to stroke you harder.
>You just stand back and take it.
>Rarity steps forward, her face lined up right with your throbbing cock.
>She gives it a long lick, from the bottom to the top.
>You twitch from the immense pleasure.
>Her magic stroking you and her tongue licking you was far too much to handle.
>You slide down the wall a bit, but her magic holds you up.
>Rarity is taking complete control right now.
>You look down at Rarity.
>Her eyes meet yours for an instant, before she closes them.
>She wraps her mouth around the tip of your member.
>You let out a load moan as she begins to orally pleasure you.
>You struggle to stand in the shower, but Rarity’s magic keeps you up.
>She begins to suckle you, her tongue wrapping around all of your length.
>Your insides beg for her to keep going.
>Rarity refuses to let up as she bobs her head up and down, slowly gaining speed.
>Her warm mouth pleasures you better than you’ve ever had before.
>Your body begins to shake.
>You feel the cum rise up your shaft.
>You let out a load moan as you spray your seed into Rarity’s mouth.
>She takes every drop, continuing to suckle on your head.
>After a few seconds you pull her away.
>You feel like your dick is about to fall off.
>After catching your breath, you hear the shower knobs turn.
>Slowly, the water recedes back into the showerhead.
>”Shall I meet you in the bedroom, darling?”

>You don’t respond immediately, but you nod in approval.
>Rarity giggles and walks slowly out of the shower.
>You lift you head up to see her leave.
>Her perky rear jiggles as she walks towards the counter.
>It’s almost inviting you to smack it.
>Her tail was barely covering her marehood.
>You were certain that she was teasing you.
>You get out and walk over to the counter.
>Rarity hands you the purple towel that you brought for her.
“This is your towel, Rarity. I can go get my own.”
>Rarity laughs as she grabs a towel from behind the door.
>She had a towel all along.
>”I knew you would follow me up here. Why would I simply walk away from you when we were talking, dear?”
>You feel stupid at this point.
>This sly mare knew all along.
>She knew you had feelings for her.
“How long have you known?”
>Rarity wraps her towel around her mane.
>She grabs the towel out of your hands and begins to dry you off.
>”I’ve always had a hunch, darling. You made it so painfully obvious.”
>Point taken.
“Well when did you feel the same about me?”
>Rarity gently wraps the towel around your hair.
>She walks out of the bathroom, turning the light off on her way out.
>Her rump was shaking more seductively know than ever.
“So… you’re not gonna tell me, Rarity?”
>She giggles playfully before plopping on her bed.
>You leave the bathroom, closing the door behind you.
>Rarity gives you a loving look.
>”Why should I tell you? I don’t want to ruin the secret!”
>She pats the bed, insisting that you join her.
>You comply, sitting right next to her.
>She immediately lays her head on your chest.
>You wrap an arm around her, rubbing her back gently.
>Rarity sighs deeply as she nuzzles your chest.
>”You’re more friendly, good looking, and caring than any other creature I’ve met.”
>You put another arm on her stomach, and rub it gently.
>She moans softly in approval.
>”You’ve always treated me well, and I strove to do the same. But I could never top you.”
>She kisses your chest a few times.
>Damn she feels good.
>”I’d be lying if I didn’t say that I liked you from the beginning, Anon.”
>You pull Rarity on top of you.
>You gently rub her back.
>Rarity unravels the towels from her mane and your head.
>Her hair droops down in front of her face.
>You take a hand and move it, to reveal her stunning blue eyes.
“That’s better.”
>Rarity presses her lips against yours.
>She pulls ways, her face beet red.
>”Anon… what do you really think of me?”
>You waste no time in responding.
“I think you’re perfect, Rarity.”
>She immediately kisses you again before putting you in a tight hug.
>After sometime passes, she sighs deeply.
>She lowers her head next to yours.
>Rarity whispers softly in your ears:
>”I love you, Anon. Don’t ever leave me.”
~