Berrys on Butter

Bubble Berry bounced though town, a birthday cake somehow not falling off his back despite being thrown around. All the ponies waved to him as they passed, most if not all of them knowing why the pink stallion was so happy. Well, happier than usual. It had been a few months since the day Berry and Butterscotch had announced themselves to the town as a couple, most ponies remembering the amazing party they had thrown. But all that was quickly forgotten after Berry remembered Butters birthday. For weeks he had been on about it, to the point that now every pony in town knew the yellow stallions date of birth. And now the date had finally arrived. Berry knocked on Butters door loudly and waited, vibrating with pure excitement.

 

The shy stallion gave a start as the door was knocked and stood up, having just finished feeding his latest animal friends. He had been dreading this day for weeks. Berry had been on and on about how great it was going to be, all the while Butters had been trying to hide himself in the background. He didnt like being the center of attention. Unfortunately for him, the center of attention seemed to be the only place Berry ever was. The looks from other ponies as they walked the street together, the pink one bouncing high into the air, drawing attention to them both making Butter feel uncomfortable. He sighed, trying not to cry. He knew he couldnt go on like this. He loved Berry, but if the relationship was going to work, the party pony would have to tone himself down a bit. Butter looked at the door and forced himself towards it. He couldnt afford to be scared, he had to tell Berry how he felt.

 

As Butter opened the door, he was hit with a stream of confetti and noise. Berry shouted happy birthday, bouncing into the house and around the confused and slightly scared Butterscotch. He dropped the cake onto the table and started singing a birthday song, grabbing Butterscotch and throwing him into the air and catching him again. As the song ended, Butter found himself on the floor, his house covered in brightly colored paper ,all his animals hiding and staring into the large grin of his coltfriend. He forced himself to smile, trying to ignore the slight feeling of sickness from the sudden excitement, and stood up.

 

Berrys grin only got wider and pulled Butter into a hug.

"Well?! What do you think huh? Wasnt that the best birthday surprise song ever?!"

Butter tried to clear his head. How did the song go again? It came and went so fast, hes not ever sure he heard it in all the noise. He just smiled and nodded.

"I-it was great Berry..."

Berry let out a noise of pure joy and plonked Butters into a chair, right in front of the giant cake.

"I made you a cake! Would you like to cut it?"

Butter looked at Berry with a confused face

"Berry, its 8am. Dont you think its a bit early for cake?"

"Its never to early for cake!" Berry yelled, nearly stuffing a slice of cake into Butters mouth. Butter forced himself to swallow it, putting on a brave face. He knew that after the large party Berry had no doubt planed, the two could snuggle on the sofa all night, hopefully without any loud noises.

 

Butter smiled up at Berry after swallowing the cake and nodded slightly.

"Its a wonderful cake Berry." He tilted his head slightly "I would have though you would have served it at my party though."

Berry looked kind of nervous "I... I havent planned you one..."

Butters heart skipped at beat as he held in a sigh of relief. "O-oh?"

Berry shifted from hoof to hoof "I didnt think you would want to be the center of attention..."

Butters suddenly hugged Berry tightly. He actally did know what he wanted! Butters plants a kiss on Berrys lips, Berry being quick to return it. They stand there for a few minutes, locked in a loving embrace.

 

Butters was the one to break the kiss as he looks lovingly into Berrys eyes. He softly nips the party ponys neck, extracting a small gasp from Berry. Today was the day, he decided, that he wanted to give Berry everything he had to offer.

"Berry..." He said, nuzzling softly into Bubbles neck "I love you."

Berrys eyes went wide. Even after being together for a few months he had yet to hear those words leave Butters lips. He knew this was big. A thought burst though the party obsessed mind of the pink stallion: Dont fuck this up.

"Butters..." He held the shy one in his hooves, looking down into his eyes "I love you too."

Their lips met again in another passion filled embrace, but this time it felt like something more. Like something had changed between them. Before they were just together, now they were lovers and as such, had to celebrate. They were both thinking it. As they kissed, their bodies lead them towards the door into the bedroom.

 

Butters body landed on the mattress, smiling up at the pink hunk of stallion that had thrown him onto it. Butter had always been the submissive one and he liked it that way. Being held in Berrys arms felt so good, so right. He wouldnt dare tell Berry about the dress in his wardrobe yet though, he wasnt ready to be outed as the sissy he was quite yet. His attention was drawn back to Berry as he felt a hoof brush against his face. Berry was standing above him, his four hooves caging the small stallion in. Butter smiled and knew what was needed. He sat up slightly, kissing Berrys underbelly, and locked eyes on Berrys flaccid member. It was slightly spilling out of its sheath, not because of Berry getting hard, but because of the shear size. Butters had noticed this before, Berrys member had never quite fit inside where as Butters barely seemed to make it out of his sheath before stopping, just another reason he believed he was meant to be born a mare. He softly licked Berrys member, starting to bring the rest of it out. He heard Berry moan softly and licked faster, the soft moans being music to his ears.

 

 

Soon enough Berrys entire member was free of his sheath. The size both excited and terrified Butters and he was sure he would be torn apart. He took the head onto is mouth and began sucking softly, much to Berrys pleasure. Butters knew where this dick was going and he wanted to make sure it was lubed up enough. He ran his tongue up and down the thick log of meat until every inch was covered in his saliva. He leant his head back, smiling slightly as he heard Berrys quickening heartbeat next to his ears. Butters knew it was time. He slipped out from under Berry and presented himself, his flank high in the air. No words were needed as Berry mounted him. Butters squeaked slightly as he felt the tip press against his virgin plothole and tried to relax his muscles. Berry started to slip his member inside, softly nibbling Butters ear as he does. The shy pony moaned loudly as his hole stretched and gave way to the massive ponyshaft now invading it.

 

Berry was in heaven as he slowly entered Butter. Berry had gotten laid before with both Stallion and Mare, but nothing quite compared with this. This was more than a one night stand after some drunken party, this was the stallion he loved and his hole was so fucking tight! Berry shook his head slightly as he tried to keep focus. This was Butterscotch and he needed to make sure he didnt hurt him. He moaned loudly as his hips make contact with Butters flank, his entire cock snuggly inside of the yellow stallion. He looks down at his lover and kisses the top of his head.

"Are you ok Butters?"

Butterscotchs tongue was hanging out of his mouth. He couldnt believe how good this felt. It was as if a log of pure ecstasy had been inserted into him. The kiss on the head brought him back from the brink of losing his mind to the pleasure as he nods

"I-im great Berry~"

Berry smiled and started thrusting slowly, in and out of Butters tight plot. By this time Butters plot had stretched to fit the massive member of the party pony and it was easier to thrust inwards than it had been to get it in in the first place. Soon Berry had built up a rhythm and was softly panting and he rutted the stallion below him. Butters was in a state of pure bliss, every thrust pleasuring him in ways he could have never dreamed. He found his hips bucking backwards as Berry pulled outwards, not wanting the shaft to leave him, but always feeling great whenever it was thrust back inside. Soon both the stallions were nearing the end of their ropes, both cocks throbbing dangerously. It was with a final large thrust that Berry finally emptied his load into Butters. Butters came as pleasure overtook him, the feeling of Berrys hot seed filling his plot driving him over the edge. Both fell over sideways, Berrys cock still deep within Butters. The yellow pony felt pink hooves wrap around him and the two soon fell asleep in the most interment way possible.