- >It’s Nightmare Night in Ponyville, and you are one little scaredy-Pegasus at the moment.
- >Anonymous has been trying to convince you to go outside for the past hour and a half,
- >but you’ve never gone out to Nightmare Night in your life, much less in… costume.
- >A remote-controlled plug is humming away deep inside you,
- >a black, slender cat tail protruding from it and swishing around.
- >Your normal tail is bound up against your side,
- >hidden underneath a skirt that reveals the plug’s tail while hiding its source;
- >a matching black blouse covers the rest of your body,
- >and your thigh-high stockings are capped with fabric paws.
- >A pair of black cat ears complete the ensemble.
- >Master is adorned in a faded brown duster going down to his ankles;
- >a simple shirt, pants, and heavy, faux-leather boots has transformed him into something he calls a ‘bounty hunter’,
- >the coat and shoes courtesy of Rarity, though your own costume was tailor-made in Canterlot for the occasion.
- “…oh, but what if somepony were to play a prank on us, Master?”
- >”I’ve already told Rainbow Dash to leave you alone.
- >Frankly, she was shocked to hear you’re coming in the first place.”
- “But I don’t wanna…”
- >Anon smacks his forehead. “It’s fun! It’s just ponies having a fun time, a costume party.
- >Yeah, there are pranks, and Princess Luna shows up to spook everyone,
- >but that’s all just part of the fun, Fluttershy.”
- >If this was a normal day, you’d follow his command without question,
- >and he would impose his will like any good Master.
- >…but Nightmare Night is different,
- >stressful enough to you that neither of you even pretended to invoke your Master and slave situation.
- “Fun? Yeah, maybe for Applejack or Pinkie Pie, but I’m a scaredy-pony, I can’t – “
- >Three solid raps on the door interrupt your freak-out.
- “GAH!”
- >You hide behind Anonymous, quaking in fear as he shakes his head and walks to the door.
- >You see three young ponies at the door, who chant something you can’t quite hear.
- >Master looks back at you.
- “Fluttershy, come on! It’s the, uh… Crusaders.”
- >You peek out from behind a couch, and sure enough, three fillies are standing on your doorstep,
- >decked out in white tunics and tin chainmail, and holding out pails for candy.
- >Anon tosses a few candies into each of the buckets,
- >and Scootaloo sees you from in front of him.
- >”Hey, Fluttershy!” They all step inside, and Anon closes the door.
- “Oh, um, nice costumes, girls.”
- >”Thanks! Now we’re really the Cutie Mark Crusaders!”
- >Their enthusiasm is adorable, and your apprehension melts away for a moment,
- >as you examine the cutely amateurish armor tailor-made for each of them.
- >”Are you gonna go trick-or-treating, Fluttershy?”
- “Uh… well…”
- >Anon gives you a glance as the three knights stare at you eagerly.
- “Sure.”
- >”You’re coming with us??”
- >”Uh, girls, give us a few minutes to get ready.”
- >The Cutie Mark Crusaders depart, and you steel yourself for what you’re about to do.
- ***
- >Just because you’re both outside doesn’t mean she isn’t panicking.
- >As you walk along the empty trail to Ponyville behind the Crusaders,
- >Fluttershy clings to your back, forelegs wrapped around your neck.
- >If those paws were real, you’d have scratches all over yourself by now,
- >and you imagine you look pretty foolish.
- >Ponyville proper is done up fabulously; cobwebs and jack o’ lanterns on every doorstep,
- >and the Nightmare Night Festival in the center of town is bustling with activity.
- >”D-do we really have to go into town, Anonymous?”
- “Of course, Fluttershy. And get down, you’ll attract even more attention if you’re stuck to my back.”
- >She reluctantly floats to the ground, a quite convincing scaredy-cat in her paws, ears, and tail.
- >Hmm… speaking of which, you know a good way to distract her.
- >Reaching into your coat, you turn up the dial on a remote to its medium setting.
- >”Ah! A-Anon… please… not right now…”
- >She’s grimacing in a rather provocative fashion, so you relent, switching her vibrator to its lowest setting.
- >”Thanks… Um, so what – AAAAAH!”
- >”Heya, Fluttershy! Never seen you out for Nightmare Night before!”
- >A very convincing zombie Pinkie has bounded up in front of you,
- >and your Fluttercat, after a short spook, is quickly working to calm herself.
- >”Um… Anonymous brought me. So, Pinkie, what do you usually do on Nightmare Night?”
- >”Well, I like to go trick-or-treating with the kids, but most people just enjoy the festival.”
- >Pinkie’s hair is a sickly, frazzled yellow, and her entire coat has been painted green for the occasion.
- >The best part, at least to you, is the fake cute mark of a brain on her flank, the only pink left on her body.
- >”Oh, oh, oh! And at the end, everyone visits the Nightmare Moon statue,
- >where we offer some of our candy so Nightmare Moon doesn’t EAT US!”
- >A loud, booming crackle of thunder roars through the street, Fluttershy and Pinkie alike scurrying off in fear.
- “Rainbow Dash, god damn it, I told you not to scare Fluttershy tonight!”
- >”Heh hah hah… oh wait, that cat was Fluttershy? You really dragged her out here?”
- >The Pegasus bitch has recycled her Shadowbolt costume,
- >and is continuing the dubious tradition of scaring the crap out of people.
- “Yes, and you probably just ruined all of that with your stupid cloud.”
- >”Eh, she really needs to lighten up sometimes. See ya, cowboy.”
- “I’m a bounty – oh, never mind.”
- >You stomp off in the direction you saw Fluttershy fleeing;
- >between two well-decorated haunted houses, she’s curled up on the ground, all her fears come true.
- “Shy, are you okay?”
- >She’s trembling just slightly; you kneel down and hug her.
- >”I-I’m okay…” She turns up at you, tears in her eyes. “Why did Dash do that…”
- >You pull her extra-close, your coat trailing for a few feet along the trash-strewn alley.
- “She was just being a jerk. It won’t happen again.”
- >”You promise?”
- “I promise, Fluttershy.”
- >…
- >This is quite a secluded alley. Perhaps Fluttershy could use something to calm her nerves.
- >You pull her into a kiss, before slipping your hand down her skirt.
- >”Mmm!?”
- >You’ve gotten quite good at this over past few months;
- >your fingers brush over her thin, virginal slit,
- >and Fluttershy’s cries of alarm melt into a moan as you begin to tease her button,
- >jilling off your cute little black cat in the cool evening air of Nightmare Night.
- >Oh, that reminds you.
- >You find the knob on her vibrator remote and turn it up, the tail plug buzzing along in her ass quite powerfully,
- >and in no time, your insistent, practiced handjob brings Fluttershy to an ecstatic peak.
- >You did have the good sense to cover her mouth first; she can be quite… expressive, when you’re pleasuring her.
- >”…thanks, Master.” Shy steals another quick kiss.
- “You feeling better?”
- >”Yeah. We can go.”
- ***
- >It was with some trepidation that you stepped out into Ponyville’s main boulevard,
- >trotting alongside Anonymous to see the attractions on display.
- >Though some of the costumes still put you on edge, you must admit it’s nowhere near as bad as you’d worried –
- >if anything, the low, constant hum of the plug in your butt is a bigger cause for concern.
- “Ooh, what’s that?”
- >A booth catches your eye – “Hit The Bottles And Win A Prize! (No Magic)”
- >On a shelf above the Pegasus operator lie a row of ghoulish teddy bears and plush, skeletal donkeys.
- “Anon, can we play that, please?”
- >”Sure thing.”
- >The sign says three bits for three balls, and as Anon gives the pony his fee,
- >a bucket of average baseballs is dropped in front of you.
- >”You wanna try it?”
- “Um…”
- >You look down at your ‘paws’.
- “These cat paws could make it hard…”
- >”Well, try just one.”
- >You nod, taking one of the balls and aiming it as best you can at the milk bottles lined up in a pyramid.
- >Just as you make your pitch, a frantic vibration in your ass sends the ball careening off course.
- “Anonymous!”
- >Your mischievous Master is snickering with his hands in his pockets.
- “You better win me something, mister.”
- >He rubs your head. “Okay, sweetie. What do you want?”
- “Hmmm…”
- >You scan the stuffed animals – Nightmare Night-themed creatures of every shape and size,
- >and eventually you come upon a strange and cute hybrid:
- >a small black cat with fangs, bat wings, and blood-red eyes.
- >You point it out to him.
- “Could you win me that vampire kitten thing?”
- >”Sure.” Anon grabs a baseball, focusing on the triangle of bottles,
- >and sends it rocketing through the booth, smashing the pyramid apart in less than a second.
- >”Uhh… congratulations, sir. What would ya like?”
- >”I’ll have that vampire cat up there.”
- >The Pegasus floats up and retrieves it, handing it to you as a reward for Anon’s victory.
- >”I’ve never seen a stuffed animal like that. It’s cute.”
- “Yeah… people must make them special for Nightmare Night.”
- >The festival is in full swing, and as you amble through it, recognizing all your friends at attractions and booths,
- >Anon takes a special interest in a curious attraction manned by none other than…
- >Applejack?
- >”Hey, y’all! You make a mighty fine cowboy, ‘Nonymous.”
- >She waves you over, the brambles and leaves of her intricately-crafted full-body costume
- >resembling some strange botanic abomination.
- >”I’m actually a bounty hunter, but I guess I should just accept a complement, huh?”
- “AJ… what are you supposed to be?”
- >”Ah’m a timber wolf, ‘a course. Say, ain’t seen you around Nightmare Night before, Shy.”
- “It’s my first time… Anon brought me out.”
- >”Well, good to have ya, kitty cat.”
- >”Say, is this a strength test game?”
- >”Yep. Uh… wait a minute, it’s built for ponies…”
- >Anon brushes off her concerns, dropping five bits into a payment jar and grabbing a rubber-headed mallet.
- >”Don’t hit it too –“
- >Your Master slams the target, sending the weight rocketing up to the bell so fast it cracks the thing.
- >”– hard. Gosh darn it, I knew that would happen.”
- >”I’ll pay for any damages later, Applejack. Fluttershy, you wanna check out…”
- >”Woo! Nightmare Moon time! Let’s go, kids!”
- >Your master is interrupted by Zombie Pie ushering a group of kids toward the edge of town.
- >”I guess it’s time for everyone to head to the statue.”
- >Oh, no. Please don’t ask.
- >”You wanna go check it out?”
- >You feel a bit light-headed at the moment.
- “Um… do we have to…?”
- >”It’s a Nightmare Night tradition. We don’t have any candy,
- >but we can still go see Luna’s transformation with everyone else.”
- >That’s what you were worried about.
- “I… I don’t think that’s… well, if you really want to, sure.”
- >You press close to your Master as you head down the trail to the Everfree Forest,
- >frightening in its own right, and you can’t tell if your quaking is from fear,
- >the pleasurable vibration of your ‘tail’, or both.
- >You never much liked Luna…
- >You ESPECIALLY didn’t like Nightmare Moon…
- >Oh god, why are you doing this!? Why do these ponies WANT to be scared!?
- “Aahhh! Anon, please, please please please can we go home…”
- >You’re making a bit of a scene, though anyone who knows you can’t really be surprised if they think about it.
- >”Shy… I just want to make your first Nightmare Night special.”
- “Yeah, okay, it’s been special, it’s been great, just… please not Nightmare Moon!”
- >If you weren’t quaking in fear at your Master’s feet, you’d see him frowning in a wistful sort of sympathy.
- >”I think I know another way to give you a special night.”
- >Almost before you can process it, you’re swept up into his arms,
- >cradled like a baby as you clutch your stuffed vampire kitten.
- “Oh thank you, I just wanna –“
- >Anon waits until you’re out of sight of the procession, and strides into the thick brush of the Everfree Forest.
- “Gah! What are –“
- >A firm hand clasps over your mouth.
- >”You know, you can be quite a talkative pony sometimes.”
- >Diving deeper into the forest, Anon comes across a small clearing,
- >and lays you down on your butt against a tree. The tail presses uncomfortably into you.
- >”Now, Fluttershy, please trust me to take care of you. I want you to not say a word. Do you understand?”
- >You nod your head, and his hand is removed from your mouth…
- >…to reach into his pocket and turn up your butt plug to its maximum setting.
- >”I’ve always wanted to do this in the woods.”
- >Anonymous spreads open your hind legs and lifts up your skirt,
- >diving in headfirst and latching his mouth onto your slit.
- >You nearly strangle your stuffed cat in an effort to keep from squealing,
- >the wonderful pleasure on your ass and pussy is nearly too much to bear.
- >Anon doesn’t waste time, either, latching onto your clit and fondling it with care and attention;
- >your constant, low-level arousal through the night hits its second peak,
- >and you convulse in ecstasy against the hard bark of an Everfree oak.
- >The buzzing in your butt subsides, and Anon climbs up from the ground.
- >”It’s a good thing your costume is black.”
- “Y-you’re the one who did this twice.”
- >”I can’t help myself, sometimes.”
- >You rise to your hooves, happily walking back to the trail and the short distance to your cottage.
- ***
- “So, Fluttershy, how was your first Nightmare Night?”
- >”Kinda scary, Master. Sorry about Nightmare Moon…”
- “I understand.”
- >You slip out of your coat, throwing it over the back of the couch.
- >”I just can’t wait to get out of this costume –“ Shy motions to slip off a stocking,
- >but you place a hand on her shoulder.
- >”Huh?”
- “Leave it on for the night.”
- Fin