EG CYOA #2 Rape Closet

>The bell rings and everyone leaves class; time for lunch

>When you get to the cafeteria, you see that Fluttershy is alone, as usual

>No one likes hanging out with Klutzershy

>Still, she does seem to need a friend

>Look at her, eating a fruit salad

>As per usual, your boner pops up, satiated only by rape

>"Hey Fluttershy," you say, sitting down across from her

>"...Hi..."

>"I heard an animal howling in pain nearby, I think it's hurt, you should come help"

>Quickly, she jumps up from her seat, "Oh no! I hope they're okay..."

>You take her hand and lead her to the-

>Ah, there it is, the janitor's closet

>When Scruffy's not around, a good 'ol rapin's gotta take place

>"Quick, in here!" you say, pushing Fluttershy into the closet

>She shrieks as she falls inside, and you close the door behind you

>"Not so rough anon..." she says with a whisper

>"I don't see any animals in here..."

>"Oops, guess I was wrong," you say as you slowly walk towards Fluttershy

>"A-Anon..?" she says, a frightened look on her face while she backs into the janitorial supplies

>You put your hands on her hips, grab her skirt, and slowly pull it down

>She whimpers, her eyes clenched tight

>"Please don't..."

>"Anon... Stop" Fluttershy whimpers

>"There are no brakes"

>You flip her over and push her against the wall with one hand, pulling down your pants with the other

>"Anon, stop, please..." she says quietly to herself, too scared to say it any louder

>You press your dick against her anus, but it doesn't go in. A little too tight, it seems

>"Anon, sto-"

>You push yourself against her as hard as you can, sticking it into her pooper

>Fluttershy lets out a loud yelp

>You begin pounding away in her tight butthole

>"A-Anon... Nnggh~"

>Fluttershy grabs onto the shelving in front of her tightly as she lets out soft moans

>You reach around her with on of your hands and begin rubbing her wetted pussy

>Fluttershy gasps and begins moving her hips against you in time

>Fluttershy's moans get louder and louder as you continue

>As you slide in and out of her ass, you feel like you're coming to the end of the ride

>"A-Anon~" Fluttershy shouts between moans

>Her breathing becomes faster and faster, as do your thrusts

>You pull out, turn Fluttershy around, and force her to her knees

>She's panting hard, and you stick your cock into her mouth

>You grab the back of her head and push her onto your dick as you begin to cum

>Your whole body shudders

>Fluttershy slowly draws her lips off your dick, running them over your head as you finish

>She breathes through her nose before swallowing, finishing with a deep sigh

>"Ha, I really am not surprised," you hear behind you

>You turn around to see Sunset Shimmer

>How the fuck did you not her her open the door?

>"The whole school could hear you two going at it, Sluttershy," she said with a smirk

>"I guess I wasn't far off when I told everyone you'd suck guys off for free in the bathroom"

>You turn to look at Fluttershy and see her cowering in the corner, trying to cover herself up

>Oh shit oh shit

>You do the first thing that comes to mind

>"What are you-" she says as you yank her inside, shutting the door behind you once more

>"Asshole, what do you think you're-"

>Fuck, how to shut her up

>You quickly jam your dick into her mouth

>"MMFfPPHHM FMEFPFMP"

>Fluttershy is just huddling in the corner, trying to stay calm, and failing

>"Fluttershy, will you do the honors?"

>Fluttershy looks over to you meekly, and whimpers something to herself

>"You've gotta be more assertive, Fluttershy," you say

>You hold Sunset Shimmer down as she tries to get your dick out of her mouth

>Fluttershy looks at Sunset Shimmer for a while, with no real expression

>She curls her hands into tight fists, and you can see she looks like she's about to cry

>"You're such a bitch!" she screams as she jumps to her feet and pushes you off of Sunset Shimmer

>"Get the fuck off of me Slutter-"

>Fluttershy shoves her against the wall and violently yanks her skirt off her body, ripping it in the process

>"I hate you!" Fluttershy yells as she shoves her whole fist into Sunset Shimmer's vagina

>Your ears are deafened by her shriek

>"Is everyone okay in heee- WHAT'S GOING ON IN HERE?"

>Fuck, not again

>You're gonna run out of space at this rate

>You turn around, and see none other than Twilight Sparkle

>She says something, but you couldn't hear her over Sunset Shimmer's cries and Fluttershy's shrieks of anger

>You stand there awkwardly as Twilight looks on in horror

>"I... I'm not even sure what's going on here," Twilight says

>"Why is she doing that to her. What's going on?!"

>"Anon, you ha-"

>You pull her in and shut the door again, hoping you didn't draw any more attention

>It's getting pretty crowded in here

>"Hey Fluttershy," Twilight says awkwardly

>Fluttershy doesn't respond, still fisting Sunset Shimmer with the strength of the northern star

>You're in too deep, might as well keep going

>You push Twilight's face into the door and lift her skirt up, pushing her panties to the side

>"Anon, what are you do- AH!"

>You stick your dick into her vagina with some resistance

>It's incredibly tight, and you can feel her pussy moisten immediately

>"Ngh~ Anon, w-what are you doing?"

>You begin to mercilessly wail against her ass as you thrust deeper and deeper

>From outside the rape closet, Twilight and Sunset's screams can be heard

>"Twilight you egghead, you've been gone for a while. We're supposed to be havin-"

>Rainbow Dash freezes as she opens the door

>In front of her, she sees Twilight getting her brains fucked out, while Fluttershy is in the corner, calling Sunset Shimmer every name under the sun while shoving her arm as far into her as she can

>"Yeah, m-maybe I'll just"

>You reach for Rainbow Dash and pull her in

>You shut the door

>It's really fucking cramped in here

>"Let go of me asshole!"

>You push her to the ground and hastily stick your dick in her mouth

>"Twilight, why don't you go and, I don't know, finger Fluttershy or something"

>"Whaaaa?"

>She doesn't know what you mean

>"I... I don't know, everyone has to be involved. I don't want to leave you out. Just take your hand, and shove it in that thing between her legs."

>She shrugs and goes off towards Fluttershy

>"And as for you..." you say as you withdraw your dick from Dash's mouth

>"Please no..." RD pleads

>Suddenly Magic Fucking Johnson enters in on the orgy

>"Hold on now guys," he says in a soothing voice

>Everyone stops what they're doing, even Fluttershy, and turns towards him

>"Now, I know you young folk like to have fun, but as a member of the National Commission on AIDS, I have to say, this doesn't look very "safe""

>You all look puzzled, while Dash and Sunset mouth "help"

>"You see, AIDS is a very scary thing. Here are some condoms. Be safe!"

>He closes the door

>He seemed like a nice guy, so you take his advice and put on a condom

>Gotta keep the AIDS away!

>"Now where were we..."

>Dash gulps

>Fluttershy resumes visiting

>Twilight begins timidly fingering Fluttershy, who turns her head slightly and begins kissing her deeply

>You push Rainbow Dash to the floor

>She struggles, but you're stronger than her

>You thrust yourself deep inside her

>"Ah!" Rainbow shouts

>She grimaces as you continue, and grabs onto Twilight's leg

>Meanwhile, Sunset Shimmer can't even fucking feel her vagina anymore. Just pain. You've let that go on for quite a while

>She's just left grabbing onto the bottom shelf of the janitorial supplies

>Fluttershy and Twilight begin moaning as they kiss one another

>Twilight quickens the pace with her finger as Fluttershy writhes against her

>You, on the other hand, begin feeling pressure build up once more within your body

>"I... I'm gonna cum in Rainbow Dash!" you shout

>You ejaculate, forgetting you were wearing a condom

>"Aw..." you say as you realize this

>"C-Can I leave now" Rainbow says

>"Leave? The ride never ends"

>Rainbow Dash's face contorts into a frown

>You take off your condom, and push her ass into the air, leaving only the top of her back on the ground

>You pour your sperm into her vagina as best as you can

>"I know Magic Johnson said otherwise, but fuck it!" you say as you begin pounding again

>Too much stimulation too quickly and in too short a time frame

>You cum again inside her, and Rainbow quivers as you do so

>Her pussy is swathed in cum, as much of it is pushed out by sheer volume

>Fluttershy looks over, and for the first time in a long time, removes her arm from Sunset Shimmer

>She pushes her onto Dash and says, "clean it off"

>Shiiieeeeeet, you think to yourself, Fluttershy really hates this bitch

>Twilight is on her knees, her arms around Fluttershy's legs, panting

>"Okay, uh, wait here guys," you say, pulling up your pants

>You watch as Sunset Shimmer licks your cum off RD, timidly at first, until Fluttershy starts threatening to fist her again

>You leave the rape closet and go for your gun

>Wait

>Fuck

>You open the door, "Any of you guys got a gun on you?"

>"In my locker," Fluttershy replies "Just in case I get pushed over the edge, you know"

>You nod and head off for her locker

>You don't make it very far from the rape closet before

>You stop and have a great idea

>You run off to Fluttershy's locker, grab the gun, and hide it as best you can as you re-enter the rape closet

>As you come back, you find that Fluttershy has Twilight sitting on Rainbow's face, while Sunset is still licking her clean

>"Hey Anon," Fluttershy says

>"Sup. Okay, so, great idea. I have your gun, and now,"

>You get behind Sunset Shimmer

>"What are you doi-" Sunset begins to say, before you ram the barrel of the gun up her asshole

>She shouts in pain

>"I didn't say you could stop," Fluttershy says, taking the chance to being fisting Sunset again

>Sunset begins licking once more, tears rolling down her face

 

*** GAME OVER SCENARIO ***

>Suddenly, there's blood everywhere

>You don't know what happened, but you must've pulled the trigger

>Sunset Shimmer lies died, and Rainbow has a gaping wound in her abdomen

>You try to pull the gun out, and it goes off again

>Twilight falls to the floor

>Shiiiiiiiiit

>"Anon, what the heck!" Fluttershy screams as she takes the gun from you

>She fumbles with it, and it falls, shooting her straight up the chin and into the brain

>"Klutzershy..."

*** GAME OVER SCENARIO ***

 

>"What the FUCK did I say about safe sex, fuckers?!"

>Oh shit

>You all turn to see Magic Fucking Johnson, his magic fucking-johnson erect, in his hands, wielded as a club

>"Y'all motherfuckers 'bout to die. Too late for all of you. AIDS has you. I will put you out of your misery"

 

*** GAME OVER SCENARIO ***

>You look at Johnson

>You look at your gun

>You concoct a plan

>"Get rekd faget!"

>You promptly shoot yourself in the head

>Shows him

*** GAME OVER SCENARIO ***

 

>You scream

>In a defensive action, you ejaculate into his face

>"Fuck!" he yells, falling backwards, dick in hand

>You hear the sound of someone being impaled

>"F-Fuck... F-Falling on m-my own sword..."

>"S-So f-fall, Johnson!" he shouts, and the light leaves his eyes

>You slowly close the door

>"Where were we?"

>Applejack opens the door to the rape closet

>You and Fluttershy are violating Sunset in terrible, painful ways

>Rainbow and Twilight are still going at it

>"Ah... Ah just... Darn, the shit I put up with," Applejack says as she closes the door behind her

>She begins undressing, sighing all the while

>"Y'all know it's gettin' more cramped than pig in a chicken coop in here?"

>As you shove the butt of your gun into Shimmer's anus, Applejack sits herself down next to you and begins sucking you off

>A few seconds of AJ's masterclass blowjob later, you cum

>Her lips leave your cock and she slurps the cum down

>"Ah, sugarcube, can't you last a little longer than that?" she says poutily

>"Hey guys, what's goin' on in here?" Derpy says

>She's confronted by a hedonistic orgy of pain and pleasure

>"Hey! Hi Sunny Shimmy!" she says with a smile

>Fuck it

>You drag Derpy into the room and close the door

>"Anon, y'all gots too many people in this room!"

>"Hey Applejack!" Derpy says happily

>"I... I'm not sure I'm okay with this," you say

>"Anon, what're you guys doing in here! It's so cramped!" Derpy says

>You give her a big bear hug

>"Aw, thanks Anon!"

>Twilight shouts out in ecstasy as she cums, her juices flowing over RD's face

>Sunset Shimmer is still being fisted while Fluttershy shouts "ATATATATATA"

>"Sugarcube, ah really think it's gettin' too cramped in here. It's like we're playin' Twister with six people in a janitor's closet."

>"You guys were having a PARTY without me?!?!"

>"Pinkie!" everyone shouts in unison

>Everyone but Sunset

>"Wee~" she says as she bounces into the room, door closing behind her

>"Soooooooo, what're we doing? Looks fun!"

>"Well, hm..." you say

>"Pinkie, why don't you and Derpy do something together?" you suggest

>"Yay!" they say in unison, as they begin to dance in the cramped rape closet

>"I... Whatever."

>You realize blood is pooling by your feet from Sunset's brutal rape

>The door creaks open

>"R-Rainbow Dash?"

>Scootaloo stares at RD

>RD looks back

>Scootaloo bites her bottom lip

>"Guys, it's too crowded in here, let's head to the pool," you say

>The rest follow you

>Sunset Shimmer takes this time to escape

>Sadly for her, Fluttershy isn't so easily distracted, and flings her to the floor by her hair, and drags her to the swimming pool

>As you all walk the halls, naked, bodily fluids everywhere, people move to the walls and stare, awestruck

>"S-So alpha..." a meek looking boy says as you all pass by

>"Hey, hey, Rarity!" Pinkie shouts as you reach the poolside

>"Pinkie! What... are... all..."

>Rarity stands, scanning your group, and blushes

>"Afraid to get dirty?" Applejack says smugly

>Scootaloo peaks out from behind Rainbow Dash

>"Yeah, c'mon Rarity, don't be s- HEY!" Rainbow Dash shouts

>"Scootaloo!"

>"Aw, c'mon, piggy back ride!"

>"Fine"

>They run a lap around the pool

>"Weeeeeeeeeeeeee~ You're the best Rainbow Dash!"

>Rainbow Dash let's Scootaloo down from her back, and you immediately dive in

>"A-Anon!" she shouts

>You furiously tongue her anus

>Rarity looks towards you with a very puzzled look

>"You. Now"

>Before she can respond, you bend her over and tongue her anus too

>"Anon, that's disgusting" Sunset Shimmer says

>Fluttershy smacks her across the face

>"Shut up, whore."

>"Why don't you do it then, you slut?" Fluttershy says with a snarl

>"W-What?" Sunset Shimmer says "Ah, please Fluttershy, I'm sorry, let me j-"

>Fluttershy pushes her onto her knees

>"Twilight, why don't you let Sunset show you some respect?" Fluttershy says

>Twilight shrugs, walks over, and bends over in front of Sunset

>"Fluttershy, pl-"

>Fluttershy buries SS' face into Twilight's ass

>"Sucarcube, what about all us?"

>"You're right Applejack. Can't leave people out like this! It's just not right."

>You lead everyone into a circle, starting from Twilight, and going around

>Sunset Shimmer is tonguing Twilight under threat of death

>Twilight struggles to tongue Applejack through moans

>Applejack goes to town on Rarity

>Rarity daintily does Dash, though she's clearly not enjoying it

>Scootaloo rushes in in front of Dash with excitement

>Scootaloo tries her best to get to Pinkie's anus through all dat ass

>Pinkie does Derpy, holding in giggles

>Derpy just sits her face on your butt

>You tongue Fluttershy

>And, finally, Fluttershy punches Sunset Shimmer in the asshole with the power of a thousand falcons

>Oh shit, best idea

>You break the circle and rush up to Sunset Shimmer

>You remove her face from Twilight's ass, and bring your cock up to her face

>"Fuck..." you say

>It was such a good idea, but you forgot...

>Nostrils are too little to stick your penis in

>It's like, the first fucking rule of sex, how could you be so stupid?

>"Anon... Anon, p-please let me go- OW!"

>"Shut! UP!" Fluttershy shouts as she shoves her hand deeper into Sunset Shimmer

>You stand there awkwardly, cock against her face, wondering what to do

>You jam your dick all the way down Sunset Shimmer's throat

>All around you, you can hear the moans of the women as they bury their faces into each other's asses

>"MMMGMMGMGMFFF"

>Sunset Shimmer gags on your dick, and tears start running down her face

>You bring your hand to the back of her head and begin to violently facefuck her

>As you climax, you feel your cum shoot into her throat, and you pull out

>Sunset Shimmer falls onto her elbows and begins couching heavily

>After one particularly heavy cough, cum streams down through one of her nostrils

>Fluttershy giggles

>You move from SS to Rarity

>You grab her by the chin, and bring her face up to your waist

>You try to stick your dick in her eye

>"Anon!" she says, pushing your dick aside

>"What are you trying to do?"

>"Idk, more holes or something?"

>"Anon, no one fucks my qt 3.14 gf but ME!" you hear, right before being kicked in the balls

>"Shining?" Twilight says

>"TWILY!"

>"W-What the fuck?" you sputter

>"C'mon Twily, we're leaving"

>"Cya guys!"

>Everyone waves her goodbye

>Sunset Shimmer tries to run to no avail

>"You should've learned by now" Fluttershy says with a smirk

>Sunset pounds at the ground, screaming and crying, hoping for freedom

>"You know what, I will let you go," Fluttershy says to Sunset Shimmer

>Sunset quickly tries to get up to run, but is unable to after the hours of vaginal and anal fisting

>She crawls, slowly but surely, attempting to leave

>"Now, as for you, Anon..." Fluttershy says

>Before you can do anything, you already have your back to the floor, Fluttershy leering over you deviously

>She closes the distance between your faces, getting right in your face

>"We're going to have some fun of our own," Fluttershy says as she gingerly runs her finger down your lips

>"Fuck yes, I am going to enjoy this!" you shout

>Fluttershy digs her fingers into your shoulders

>She gently sets herself on top of your cock

>She bounces up and down at breakneck speed, her tight pussy pressing onto your dick from all directions

>Fluttershy moans, speeding up with every bounce

>You are unable to do anything but sit back, your heart feeling as if it would beat itself out of your chest

>Soon, the rest of the girls come flocking

>Rarity takes a seat on your face, and the rest of the girls fondle one another in a huge pile on top of your body

>All you can hear are moans

>Suddenly, you feel Fluttershy clenching her pussy

>She lets out a loud cry as she cums, spasming on top of your body as pleasure goes over her in waves

>It's too much to take, and you finally cum into her

>Everyone falls back, panting

>"We... We should eat together... More often... Anon..." Fluttershy says

>"I know."