The Grand Game of Give and Take 2 (CYOA)

>You get up from the bed

>Stretch

Aaaaaaah

>Get out of bed

>Shit, shower, shave

>You’re feeling pumped

>It’s time to get rid of the yellow menace!

>Go to your desk and sit down

>Open the drawer

>Open up the Big Book of Turn Offs

>Flip through it

>Something catches your eye

>Stop at that section

>Read it

>Details the things you shouldn’t do

>Mentions bad breath

>Smile

>That should be easy enough

>Bookmark that page

>Go check through your pantry

>Milk, fish from Fluttershy, and a block of cheese, and cider

>Chug the cider

>Cook the fish and eat it

>Cheese smells awful

>Wonder why you bought it

>Shrug

>Slowly eat it

>Nearly gag

>Your breath should be unbearable

>With your morning breath it should keep Fluttershy away

>You step outside

>Surprised Fluttershy hasn’t knocked on your door

>Frown

>Probably scheming something

>She always is….

>You sigh

>Take comfort that she won’t be bothering you for long

>Look around

>She has to be somewhere

>Oh well you’ll encounter her eventually

>You just have to go about your typical day

>You actually feel bad for other ponies having to deal with your rancid breath

>Ugh

>Maybe you should hang out with someone today

>Other than Fluttershy of course

>You begin to walk away from your house

>Hear a rustle in nearby bushes

>Turn around

>Nothing

>Roll your eyes

Gee, I wonder why I have a boner all of a sudden…..

>Look at the bush

>A pair of yellow and erect wings pop out of it

>At first nothing

>Probably hoping she is still hidden

>Keep staring

>”*squeak*”

>Stare harder

>”Um….”

Come on out. I know you’re there.

>Fluttershy slowly walks out of the bush

>Head hanging low

>Not even going to ask why she was hiding

>Now is the time for action

>Kneel down to her eye level

>Fluttershy is curious

>Approaches you

>She smiles a bit

>”Um Anon I-“

>Lean your head closer to hers

>Her eyes widen

>Fluttershy thinks you’re going to kiss her

>Puckers her lips

>Leans her head closer

>Open your mouth

>Breathe on her

>Make sure all your breath is going to her muzzle

>She winces for a second

>Here we go

>The moment of truth

>Fluttershy opens her mouth

>Breathes back on you

>Her breath isn’t bad

>But it shocks you

>What the hell is she doing?!

>It’s rather intense too as if she wanted you to smell it

>Confused as hell

>Breathe again

>She breathes at the same time

>Exchanging breaths with each other

>Glare for a second

>Inhale deeply

>Unleash your full breath

>Fluttershy inhales even deeper

>And you’re both breathing into each other’s mouths and nostrils

>Intensely as you two possibly can

>Maybe this is revenge?

>Notice Fluttershy looks very pleased

>She nuzzles your face

Okay! What are you doing?!

>Fluttershy cocks her head

>She blushes and hides behind her mane slightly

>”Um we’re having an intimate moment by exchanging breaths…”

That’s really weird!

>”B-but why did you do it then?”

>Fluttershy looks extremely confused now

I was hoping you hated the smell of my breath.

>You breathe on her

Isn’t that shitty?

>She gasps

>Ahah!

>”Watch your language mister.”

>Damn it

>Fluttershy thinks for a moment

>”When two ponies want to meet each other or like each other…”

>She rubs her hoof along the ground shyly

>”It’s an old tradition to breathe on one another.”

>Fluttershy beams at you

>”I’m so happy you decided to do this with me.”

>She breathes on you again

>…..

>Seriously?!

>Of course ponies would have a weird thing like that

>Freaking alien horses

>You sigh and Fluttershy takes this as an invitation to keep breathing on you

>You don’t breathe back

>Stand up

>Groan

Okay. My breath is still bad

>”Well you should brush your teeth...”

Doesn’t that turn you off?

>She shakes her head

>”But it’s your breath.”

>Now you’re even more annoyed than before

Why were you even hiding from me?

>Cross your arms

You obviously had something planned

>”Um well *mumblemumblemumble*”

>She backs away and hides behind her mane

>You roll your eyes

Cmon, you know I didn’t hear that. Try raising your voice

>She backs into the bush

That’s not an answer

>Tap your foot

>Fluttershy bursts out of the bushes and flies up to your face

>Her mouth is full of some plucked feathers

>She rubs them on your face and you can’t help but laugh

Hahahahaha! What the-

>You put your hands up to block the feathers

>She doesn’t relent and tickles your hands

>Unfortunately you’re reduced to a laughing mess and fall to the ground

>Banana Hush then uses her wings and tail

>You laugh in a very high pitched manner

>Much to your shame

>After some time she begins to tug at your shirt

>That gave you enough motivation to push her away and stand up

No! Tickling is not my fetish!

>”Oh…”

>She whimpers and flies off

>Fucking Fluttershy

>It’s shit like this that’s driving you to find her turn off

>You’re going to need to try harder

>Fluttershy tries really hard after all

>If there’s any chance of winning you’re going to need some outside help

>The yellow menace can get help so why can’t you?

>You walk back inside your house

>Go to your bedroom

>Sit down at your desk

>Write up a list:

>Potential Allies

>1.Twilight Sparkle

>Pros: Magic, Smart, (Usually) Reasonable

>Cons: Tries to please both sides, partially supports Fluttershy’s crush, she makes everything a big deal

>2.Pinkie Pie

>Pros: Wild Card, Plenty of resources, wants happiness for everyone

>Cons: Aspects of her plans are kept to herself, Wild Card

>Potential Enemies (Needs more convincing)

>3.Rarity

>Pros: Can make and supply necessary resources, good communicator, willing to help

>Cons: Uptight, Best friends with Fluttershy, tries to pair me with the enemy

>4.Applejack

>Pros: Strong, honest about intentions, owns and maintains property that can be used

>Cons: Honest about intentions, inspires Fluttershy to get more physical, stubborn

>5.Rainbow Dash

>Pros: Flight, charismatic and can get help from other ponies, loyal if converted

>Cons: Loyal to Fluttershy, dislikes when your reject her friend, volatile

>You stare at the list

>Alright, time to write a few plans

>It takes a couple hours to finish

>But now it’s time to go ahead with your plan…or back-up plans

>Satisfied, you walk outside of your house to the Golden Oaks Library

>After a few minutes of walking you’ve arrived

>Twilight is reading about…

>Well who cares what she’s reading about?

>You approach her

>”Hey Anon! Are you enjoying that book you checked out?”

>You nod

Yeah, it’s okay.

>You clear you throat

The thing is, I need some help

>”I’m a bit busy, but if it’s not too much I can help a friend in need.”

>You get a hopeful smile

I want Fluttershy to leave me alone. If we find her turn off, she’ll find someone else to bother.

>”No. Sorry Anon, but that’s too mean.”

>Ugh

Why?

>”I’ve been encouraging Fluttershy to pursue her feelings for you.”

>You try to hide your frown

>But you’re already rustled

Yeah, thanks a lot “Lavender Magic”

>Twilight blushes

>”There’s nothing wrong about writing a book like that.”

“Human and Pegasi: Natural Partners” sounds like a biased book to me.”

>”It’s something Fluttershy and I have fun doing.”

That’s fine……hell write a whole series. I won’t read it

>Twilight sighs

I just can’t stand her fetish attempts

>Twilight is a bit skeptical

>She doesn’t know why you’d make it up

>But she has never seen Fluttershy’s fetish guessing in action

>She also mentioned she found it funny, cute, and nice

>It was funny at first, you’ll admit

>Maybe cute

>But it’s not nice

>Especially some of her attempts that involve you in helpless positions

>Or come out of nowhere

>Without asking you should add

>”I don’t see the big deal, Anon.”

>”Is she really going that far?”

She checked out the Big Book of Fetishes

>Twilight blinks

>”Okay you’re right.”

>”I still believe it is fine. Besides, I’d like to know about human sexuality.”

Well I’ll tell you this about my sexuality. No ponies.

>Twilight looks offended

>”Why?”

Because you all aren’t human!

>Twilight doesn’t look convinced

>”But we’re just like you! What’s wrong with inter species relationships?”

Nothing! Well, as long as I’m not in one!

>”Ugh! What do you even need from me?”

Okay, we go to Fluttershy’s cottage….

>”Uh huh”

And you use your magic to assist me in finding the yellow menace’s turn off.

>”Yellow wh-“

Fluttershy

>Twilight shakes her head

>”No Anon. I’m not going to use magic like that on you or my friends.”

>”I don’t want to help in a conflict in that way.”

Oh come on! If I had magic I’d put it to great use!

>It’s true

>The things you could accomplish with magic…

>”Not with that attitude you wouldn’t.”

>Throw up your arms

Fine! I’ll just find someone else to help me!

>Twilight goes back to reading her book

>”Sure.”

>Still ranting

I bet if Fluttershy asked you to go to my house, and use your magic to find my fetish, you would say yes!

>”Just go Anon…”

>You leave

>Okay that didn’t work out, but you still have the others to try out

>Surely they’ll see reason

 

>You’re now at Sugarcube Corner

>Pinkie Pie is at the counter

>Realize it’s a bad time to talk to her

>Line is full of ponies

>You’re going to have to make this quick

>Line moves

>You start walking

>Feel something rubbing your backside

>Assume it’s a pony just being careless

>Move up the line again

>This time the rubbing is slower

>Feels like a tail

>Then it smacks your backside

>But not too hard

>Still enough to make you jump

>Turn around sharply

>Glare

>Fluttershy cowers

>You’re embarrassed as hell that she would do this with many ponies around

>Some are staring

>Whisper to her

What are you doing?

>”W-well you uh h-have a soft flank and I thought maybe a little spanking would excite you.”

>You turn around

>She sighs in relief

>”Oh, you do like it.”

>Her tail smacks your backside again

>Grit your teeth

>And fart

>Silent but deadly

>Right on her face

>”Eep! That’s very rude.”

Did it turn you off?

>”No, it may not smell nice, but I’m used to unusual smells when I work with animals.”

>Fluttershy gasps

>”Not that you’re an animal Anon-“

I get it

>Although she probably does identify you as one to some extent

I’m going to fart on you from now on then.

>Victory

>”I can bear it, because I love you. When you love me you won’t do that.”

Yeah, like I’d love you…

>Roll your eyes

>”Next!”

>You’ve been holding up the line

>Oops

>Walk up to Pinkie Pie

Hey Pinkie I need help in stopping…

>Point to Fluttershy

Her

>Pinkie Pie blinks

Because she’s annoying and can’t take no for an answer

>Pinkie Pie purses her lips

>”Hmmmmmmmmmmm.”

>Looks to Fluttershy

>Looks to you

>Fluttershy heard all of this

>She looks sad

>What is she going to do?

>Stutter?

>Ask Pinkie to refuse in an overly polite manner?

>Fluttershy approaches the counter

>”Um…Pinkie, I really love Anon, and I don’t want to give up on him.”

>”If you wouldn’t mind, could you uh maybe not interfere?”

>Fluttershy shies away

>”If that’s okay with you.”

>Pinkie is still thinking

>”Mmmmmmmmmmmmm, sorry Anon!”

>What?!

Why?

>”I don’t want to hurt my friendship with either of you.”

>She smiles and leans her head close to you

>”Besides, I think you’d make a great Mr.Fluttershy~”

>Pinkie bats her eyelashes

>Fluttershy smiles

Ugh, so much for my “surprise” party scheme

>Next time

>Pinkie Pie is still staring at you expectantly

>Raise an eyebrow

>”Silly! Aren’t you going to order something?”

>Your stomach growls

>Nod

>Reach into your pocket

>Nothing

>You didn’t originally plan to do this

Sorry Pinkie …I was just here to chat

>”That’s okay Anon. Just remember to bring bits next time.”

>You’re about to leave when Fluttershy spreads a wing

>Places bits on the counter with it

>”Um could I have one banana nut muffin and a cinnamon bun for my sweetheart, please?”

I’m not your sweetheart

>How did she know you liked cinnamon buns?

>Fluttershy smiles a bit

>”I sometimes watch you and you order them a lot.”

>Oh

>Wait…

That’s really creepy. Stop watching me!

>”I like watching you though…”

I don’t care if-

>”Here you go!”

>Pinkie balances the pastries on her hooves

>You take the cinnamon bun

>Fluttershy takes the muffin

>You sit down at a table and begin to munch away

>Banana Hush joins you at the table

>Eyeing you

>It’s annoying

>You look at your pastry

>May as well try for a turn off

>You take huge bites

>Make a lot of noise

>Take the cinnamon paste and rub it on your cheeks

>You stare at Fluttershy

>She seems surprised

>Fluttershy leans forward and wipes it away

>You do the same thing

>This time she smirks

>Fluttershy leans forward and licks it off

>Then she rubs some muffin crumbs on your face

>What the hell?!

>Then she licks it off again

>Her saliva is all over your cheeks

>Fluttershy nuzzles you and attempts to more crumbs on your face

Stop that!

>You get up

So, bad table manners aren’t your turn off?

>”Food isn’t your fetish?”

No

>You leave

>Okay, may as well try your other back-up plan…

>You are now at Sweet Apple Acres

>Applejack and Rainbow Dash are playing horseshoes

>Look around

>No Fluttershy? Good.

>You wave at them and then approach the pair

>They seem surprised to see you

>Well you can try convincing both

>Or not

>They’re both in favor of Fluttershy

Hey you two, how’s it going?

>Rainbow Dash shrugs her withers

>”Good.”

>Applejack greets you

>”Hey Anon, I thought you weren’t going to work here this week.”

Well, I’ve been hoping to work out a deal with you.

>”Really?”

>You nod

I’ll work the next week for free.

>”That sounds mighty enticing, but you want something in return. Don’t ya?”

Pretty much, I was hoping to use your barn this weekend

>Applejack nods

>”You’ve got yourself a deal, sugarcube.”

>”…If you tell me what you’re using it for.”

>Fair enough

>You look at Rainbow Dash

>She’s listening intently

>You’re going to have to whisper it

>Lean over to Applejack’s ear

>”Anon, it don’t have to be a secret.”

>Sigh

I need it in a convoluted plan to get Fluttershy to leave me alone

>Rainbow Dash facehooves

>”Applejack, don’t listen to him! Fluttershy doesn’t deserve something like that!”

>”She’s so nice to you!”

She’s annoying!

>Applejack chuckles

>”Well, she should be more forward to ya.”

>Rainbow Dash nods

Your definition of forward is to tie me up and have me molested!

>Dash scoffs

>”Maybe Fluttershy should do that! She’s been trying everything!”

She’s not entitled to have me! I can’t believe I had plans for either of you to help me!

>”I bet your plans are all dumb anyway.”

Probably not as dumb as stealing a book from a hospital

>Applejack starts laughing

>It takes a moment for what you said to sink in for Dash

>You’ve already walked away so you can’t hear what she’s shouting at you

>Well time for your final back-up plan

>Let’s just hope she says….

 

>You are now in Carousel Boutique

>”Yes!”

>Rarity has a huge grin on her face

>She really said yes?

>”I am so flattered you would ask me for help.”

>Probably shouldn’t mention she was your last resort

>”Oh think of all of the dresses I could make for you! Oh my how exciting!”

>Woah, woah, woah

>Did she just go plural with the word dress?

>Rarity seems a little too eager

>The silly marshmallow

Not that I’m complaining about your enthusiasm to help me……

>You rub the back of your head

But aren’t you a bit confused about my request for a dress?

>”Isn’t it some human custom of yours?”

>Should you mention it isn’t?

No…

>Rarity giggles

>”Oh well, you will look quiet cute in a dress.”

>You know you’re the one asking for a dress

>But you’re still getting annoyed

>This is rustling you on many levels

How much is this going to cost?

>”Free of charge.”

Come on, it may be interesting to make clothes for me-

>”You need help, I will help you.”

>She’s too generous for her own good

>But you’ll admit

>Rarity can be cool sometimes...

>”Darling I need to measure you again just to be sure.”

Okay

>You step up on the stand with the mirrors

>Spread your arms

>Rarity rolls her eyes

>”Anon, those clothes are going to be in the way.”

>This area is so close to the door

>You blush

>Strip down to your boxers

>Rarity gives you a disapproving look

>”Fold your clothes Anon! You do not simply throw them onto the ground!”

>”I would assume somep0ny that valued their clothes so much would treat them better!”

>You quickly fold them and set them aside neatly

>Anything to prevent a rant

>”The boxers must go as well.”

Come on, Rarity you know how I don’t like being naked.

>”I do understand the need for privacy, but I don’t see the problem of going naked when it is necessary.”

>Rarity adds

>”You could go naked more often Anon. It would make your clothes more special.”

>You let out an exasperated groan

>”I know you find it unpleasant, but it will be over before you know it.”

>You take off your boxers

>Fold them

>Cross dressing better be Fluttershy’s turn off

>Rarity measures you for a few minutes

>Sometimes she uses magic

>Sometimes her hooves

>She stops for a moment

>”I need to compare this to my previous measurements.”

>”I’ll be right back Anon.”

>She goes upstairs

>You’re just left in the same position

>Standing awkwardly

>You’re spacing out when you hear a bell ringing

>Someone has entered the boutique

>You slightly turn your head

>It’s Fluttershy

>Of course

>Yeah, out of all the ponies it had to be

>Perfect

>Just fucking excellent

>Fluttershy looks overjoyed

>She’s not even trying to hide her excitement

>”Hi Anon! I’m so surprised to see you here!”

>Is she really?

>Did she follow you here?

>”You’re looking so handsome today.”

I’m here for something, leave me alone

>She either ignores that or didn’t hear you

>The mesmerized mare flaps her wings a little

>”It’s so wonderful I don’t even know what to say.”

>She slowly walks up to you

>There’s still a few measuring tapes on you

>Shouldn’t move

>Not unless you want to unleash the whining marshmallow

>Scratch that

>Complaining marshmallow…

>Shudder

Keep your distance

>Fluttershy isn’t paying attention

>She is drooling a bit

>She’s uncomfortably close

What are you doing?

>Yellow pone gives your manhood a sloppy kiss

>There’s drool on it now

Fluttershy, stop!

>Her hoof rubs your thighs

>She nuzzles your leg and then kisses your manhood again

>Gives you a boner

>Okay that’s it

>Turn your head upstairs

Rarity!

>No response

>Fluttershy grips your dick with a wing

>Feels weird

>Time to shout

FLUTTERSHY!

>Fluttershy jumps back and hides behind her mane

>She cowers

What are you even doing here?

>”Um.”

Stalking me?

>”*mumblemumblemumblemumble*”

I can’t hear you

>”I don’t w-want to say yet.”

I’m assuming you’re stalking me then

>”No, I’m here to request something …..special.”

>Don’t like the ambiguous term

>It’s probably for a fetish

>Huh, this is awkward

>That means Rarity is helping the both of your schemes

>You already know Fluttershy is going to fail

>A wing brushes your manhood again

>”But I f-f-found another special thing as well.”

>She blushes

>Fluttershy sneaked her way back over to you while you were thinking

>You glare at her

>”Fluttershy what a pleasant surprise!”

>Rarity comes down stairs and joins you and Fluttershy

>”Anon, I am sorry! I forgot to tell you that I finished your measurements.”

>So you got felt up for nothing?

>Purse your lips

>Deep breaths

>You take a few

>Rarity scrunches her nose

>”Anon your breath is… rather foul.”

>Fluttershy flies up to you and breathes on your face

>You stop breathing

>Fucking Fluttershy

>You put your clothes on

>”Come back in three days Anon.”

Thanks

>”No, thank you.”

>Fluttershy and Rarity go upstairs to discuss something

>You’re about to leave, but realize you can gain some information about Fluttershy’s plans

>You sneak up to the upstairs door

>Press your ear against it

>You can hear their voices

>”Fluttershy dear, you should be more considerate to Anon.”

>”I was just showing my affection, and I think he looks very nice without his clothes.”

>”But he does not think so, if you hope to be in a relationship with him you are going to have to understand what he finds comfortable. You also need to be aware of what makes him uncomfortable. It isn’t just about…um fetishes.”

>Thank you Rarity

>Banana Hush should be considerate anyway, relationship or not

>”I-I know….”

>”That aside, I am sad to inform you that your special order is not finished yet.”

>”That’s okay, I’ll come back when you need me.”

>”I promise it will be done soon, don’t worry your precious little head about it.”

>”Um Rarity, if it’s not too much of a bother could you um n-not treat me like an um….little f-filly?”

>”Sorry dear, I know how you dislike that.”

>Sigh loudly

>You aren’t getting any information out of this

>Other than the object Fluttershy needs will be ready soon

>”Did you hear that?”

>!

>Time to go

>You sprint out of the boutique

 

>Then you arrive at your house

>It’s going to be a while before you can execute your plan

>You should try a few turn off attempts while you wait

>You sit down on the living room couch

>Book on your lap

>You read some ideas for a couple of hours

>Some aren’t going to work out

>Or would need to be elaborate

>You need to use a dislike of hers

>Wait…

>Fluttershy mentioned her dislike of being treated like a filly

>Probably because many see her as helpless

>You look through your book on something like that

>On the common turn offs section there is an entry above bad breath

>Baby talk

>The book states that baby talking from the opposite gender is a huge turn off to many

>You grin

>This seems easy enough

>You put the book down and walk outside

>You don’t usually see Fluttershy at this time

>She’s not always in town at this point unless her plans require her to

>Fluttershy had saddlebags with her

>She most likely came to shop and to pick up this mysterious thing Rarity is working on

>Hopefully Rarity won’t tell Fluttershy what she’s making for you

>You check out the marketplace

>No Fluttershy

>Town Hall

>She’s not there either

>You’ll just call it day and try tomorrow

>You decide to drink some coffee at the nearby café

>You arrive and are about to take a seat

>”It’s like fate wants us to be together.”

>Fluttershy says sweetly

>Groan

>Of course

>It’s more like fate has her show up when you don’t want her to

>Why is she never there when you actually look for her?

>Fluttershy is drinking coffee

>You sit down at her table

>May as well try the baby talk

>She orders another cup of coffee

>You put too much cream and sugar

>Just the way you like it

>Fluttershy’s coffee is black

>Well shit

Thank you my little Flutterbooboo

>She blushes

>”It’s no problem at all, Anon.”

Aaaaw I really mean it you sweet little baby~

>”Oh my…”

>She closes her eyes and smiles with content

>Soaking in the praise

>You can tell she is a bit confused by the tone of her voice

>You pat her head

>She smiles

I’m surprised such a cutesy-wutesy horsey like you is so interested in me~

>Fluttershy shakes her head

>”I love you, Anon of course I do.”

>She loses her smile a bit

>”And um I like that you’re being affection but ummmm…”

What’s w’ong Flutter-cutie?

>”It’s nothing it’s just maybe you’re overdoing it an um teeny-tiny bit.”

>Perfect

>You cradle her head in your hands

>Rub her face

>She coos happily

>Then you do it more roughly

Awwww~! You think I’m overdoing it, but you’re so cute! Yes you are! Who’s so cute? Who’s so cute?

>You tousle her soft mane

>Fluttershy isn’t sure if she likes it or not

>She’s conflicted

>She lets out a slight horse snort

>Ugh

>It’s freaky that they can sound like people and horses

>That turns you off

>”Thank you Anon, am I c-cute enough to be your fetish?”

No

>Yellow pony looks very disappointed

>Oh well, too bad for her

>You gulp down your coffee

>”Would you like to come to my cottage?”

>”We can have fun playing with the animals, and afterwards we could um y-you know…”

>She blushes deeply

>”I’m uh t-t-talking about s-“

I’d love to go to your wittle cottage you sweetie-poo!

>She winces a bit

>You’ll keep up the baby talk and then she’ll be sick of you

>”yay!”

No sex though, you’re too much of a fuzzy fluffy pony baby~

>”Oh…okay.”

>You follow her to the cottage

>She stares at your crotch the entire time but you just laugh it off

>Enjoy it while you can Fluttershy

>Her patience will run out eventually

>When you finally arrive she unpacks her groceries

Aaaaaaaaaaaaaaw~! You have such a cozy little cottage with all these cute critters!

>”Oh it’s not much to look at, but it’s a very nice home.”

>”You can always live with me if you’d like.”

Oh no no no, this place is for little adorable things, like you.

>You ruffle up her wings

>She blushes, but purses her lips

>You can see her getting a little chagrin

>Fluttershy actually looks annoyed

>”But you’re cute…..”

>Really?

>She probably finds some weird things cute

>So you aren’t surprised at this point

Well you’re super cute

>”N-no you.”

Are you suuuuuuure Flutterbooboo?

>”Yes, momma’s sure~”

>She nuzzles your legs

>Huh

>She’s asserting herself as someone with authority

>While babytalking back

>Let’s make her regret that

Hmmmm? Momma? You’re a cute wittle momma!

>She beams at you

>Fluttershy seemed to really like that

>She flutters up to your eye level and nuzzles your face

>”You’re momma’s little angel! You’re cuter, mister.”

>Sigh

>This going nowhere

>Better change the subject

Gootchie goo! Is there anything you want to do?

>She nods

>”Let’s go play with the bunnies, my honey bunny.”

>This is getting painful

>Hopefully it’ll all pay off

>You follow her out the door

>She actually hovers around you

>This must be an exciting activity to do

>You’ve never really been around these parts before

>Maybe once when you first arrived, but briefly

>It’s actually very serene and quiet

>Everything is picture perfect

>Especially the further you go into the meadow area

>Only Ponyville Tower can be seen now

>Many rabbits of all shapes and sizes begin to follow Fluttershy and you

>She stops at a secluded tree

>You sit down and lean on the trunk

>One by one, bunnies go on your lap or hop around the two of you

>It’s actually a relaxing experience

>She checks on each of them to make sure they aren’t sick

>Tells you their name and what they like

>After all the introductions are aside you watch them all play

>A few approach you and nibble on your finger

>Fluttershy is beside you and you don’t push her away when she rests her head on you

>You just baby talk more

Oooooh! These bunny-wunnies are being taken good care of by a little silly filly!

>Smirk

I’m surprised you’re able to take care of anything at all~

>She hugs your arm tightly with her forehooves

>”I do my best, I can show you how well Momma’s going to take care of you…”

>Wait what?!

>She tackles you

>The bunnies hop away

>Fluttershy kneads on your chest and keeps nuzzling your face

>It gets a laugh out of you

>But you push her away lightly

>She grips on you and puts a hoof under your shirt

>Then she plants kisses up your neck while feeling you all over

>”Mmmm~”

>Keep calm

Aaaaaaw? Are you playing a cute little game?

>”Yes, momma’s going to teach you.”

>She nibbles on your chin

>Then she begins to take off your shirt

>You tug back

>Pet her

What kind of game babykins?

>She kisses your cheek

>”A very fun one….um…my sweetie.”

>You tousle her mane a bit

>She just bites her lip in an attempted seductive manner

>For a few minutes you attempt this dance of avoiding her advances

>While using baby talk wordplay, of course

>She attempts are your shirt more forcefully this time

>”Come on, little sweetheart, please be cooperative.”

>”Momma just wants to make you happy.”

>Okay this isn’t working

Don’t you hate when I babytalk you?

>”Well I do like the compliments…”

>”And I get to say nice things to you..”

>She gives you a warm smile

>”It must be your fetish as well.”

It’s not

>She pouts

You don’t like being patronized. How could you stand that?

>”There are some benefits, and I love you.”

Stop “loving” me, it’s annoying

>”No.”

Yes

>She shakes her head and hugs your chest tightly

Leave me alone

>”No I want to be with you, if you wouldn’t mind.”

I do mind

>Fluttershy looks frustrated

>”I’m going to have to show you…”

>She tugs on your shirt

Don’t do that…

>She pulls on it and uses her wing to gain leverage

>"I n-n-need to do this..."

>She tugs harder

>"To make you see."

>You tug harder

>"So you'll know how much I care!"

Go away!

>”No!”

>You were about to get more physical, but then you both are distracted by a peculiar sight

>Above the both of you is a swarm of butterflies

>They are every color of the rainbow

>A notable amount even resemble Fluttershy’s cutie mark

>Fluttershy lands on your chest

>You both look upwards at the large amount of butterflies

>They pass above the trees and the sun illuminates their wings

>The colors rain down on you like some sort of rainbow

>For some reason it makes you melancholy

>Sad even

>You’re not sure why

>It relaxes the both of you

>Probably because it’s such a spontaneous sight

>You even pet Fluttershy’s mane without realizing it

>”They’re beautiful creatures aren’t they?”

>You nod

>She smiles at you

>”I was saved by something like that.”

Really?

>She nods

>Fluttershy tells you about her early life

>How she fell from the sky

>Only to be saved by a swarm of butterflies

>It amazed you what was possible in this world

>You even felt a little jealous

>Then she saw many animals and plants that she had never seen before

>It resulted in Fluttershy earning her cutie mark

>To live a new life

>Taking care of the animals

>Watching them grow, feeding them, and befriending them

>The whole story warmed your heart

That’s quite a tale

>It honestly felt like something out of a children’s fairy tale

>You really seem to be living in one

>Neither of you talk much after that

>You just enjoy the warmth you bring to each other

>You drift off to sleep looking out at the meadow

>When you awaken its night

>You feel warmth on your chest

>She’s still sleeping on you

>How sweet

>Fluttershy’s head is under your shirt

>Part of her head is poking out of your neckline

>You chuckle a little

>Sometimes she really is cute

>Your pants feel a little wet and warm

>Her marehood is soaking onto your crotch

>Looks like she was messing with your zipper as well

>You grumble lowly

>Oh right, creepy obsessed with you

>You move her out of your shirt

>Push her off gently

>Dust yourself off

>Well, baby talk isn’t her turn off

>You may as well commence the rest of your plan

>Rarity will provide the dress

>To….cross dress in

>But that’s only part of the picture

>You’re going to need to do this a particular way

>You grin

>Oh yes

>If it isn’t already her turn off….

>It will be

>Heh

>You walk away

>With the intent to gather and prepare for the rest of your plan

>Fluttershy is sure to leave you alone after this...

 

>You are now Fluttershy

>You wake up slowly

>It’s dark outside and you’re still in the meadow

>Oh goodness!

>Poor Angel Bunny must be so worried

>You didn’t mean to go to sleep

>Anon just looked so peaceful and innocent

>You like watching him sleep

>He doesn’t frown when he sleeps

>You don’t like to see him frown

>You just want him to smile

>To be at peace

>It fills you with happiness to see him happy

>Under that grumpy attitude he hides behind

>But you hope to give him that happiness

>Anon is nowhere to be seen

>He must have gone back to his home

>You feel your marehood is very wet

>You gasp a little

>How embarrassing!

>You shake your head

>Be positive Fluttershy!

>Hopefully your scent got on his clothes

>Maybe he’ll like it

>You smile a little to boost your confidence

>Then you walk home

>Humming to distract you from the dark

>Night can be a little scary

>But the meadow is very safe

>You let out a deep breath

>If mr.owl and ms.bat can play in the dark so can you

>Today was very strange

>Anon is trying to get you to not love him

>He’s so silly sometimes

>You know he’s doing it on purpose

>And those tiny little things won’t stop you

>He didn’t like any of your fetishes today…

>But that’s okay

>As long as you find something he loves

>He’ll like you

>No

>He’ll love you

>Just like you love him

>You suppress the urge to squee

>You’re sure he’ll love you soon

>You enter the cottage and apologize to Angel

>He just rolls his eyes

>Sometimes he can have a bit of an attitude

>You giggle

>He’s a bit like Anon in a way

>You go upstairs and open the Big Book of Fetishes

>You may not need it anymore

>Not with what’s planned soon

>Rarity will have the special order finished soon

>But it can’t hurt to try and guess his fetish

>You read through the book….

End of Part 2

 

(Suggestion box closed)