Image
Comments
| PhilSrobeighn #1380863 2 months ago |
Okay, this time it's right. This is the complete second version of my small set. It's been updated to include the rest of season 2. I've asked the mods delete the first version and my derped upload of this version.
Thank you to everyone who commented on the first version. I read every comment and considered your input. It's been fun doing practically any pony search on Google and seeing the old image come up, but I don't want to take up the servers with three big images. Like the earlier version, this is less of a MTG-flavored pony image as it is a pony-flavored MTG image, so a lot of the humor comes from a knowledge of Magic, its rules, and its history. If you don't get my choice on a card, I might be referencing shared name/flavor/creature with older Magic cards (Big Mac is a prime example - how many previous cards started with "Big?") |
| Anonymous #1380992 2 months ago |
Is this well balanced and playable? Like, could I take some of my massive collection of Innistrad proxy cards, put print-outs of these in front of them, and play a full deck of motherbucking Pony cards against my friends' normal decks? |
| Anonymous #1381021 2 months ago |
Damn it, you Derpy'd up Apple Bloom's name. It's Apple Bloom, not Applebloom! |
| Anonymous #1381133 2 months ago |
I would've thought Chrysalis would have Changeling, but with all that text already there, it probably wouldn't fit. (Maybe a Changeling creature?)
I love transforming Lyra, Coward Pansy, and Spike being a Spike. Good call there. Lords still don't exist, though. And this is just me, but Windigoes sounds fitting as a Snow creature (they do create blizzards) But, um... whatever you do is fine. (I wish I knew how to make my own cards) |
| Anonymous #1381322 2 months ago |
Ok, there are some weird, unintentional combos here: Angel + Mountain Dragon attacking each turn to keep opponents lands tapped while you can still do stuff. Lyra + Princess Luna for an easy way to transform all your creatures at once at the end of your turn. Filthy Rich + Photo Finish to screw with your opponents ability to cast spells while simultaneously playing your own instant-speed spells.
And by far the weirdest is Applejack + Flim Flam Brothers (YES, the freaking FLIM FLAM BROTHERS) for increased protection for yourself and other creatures. |
| Anonymous #1381360 2 months ago |
"Strength to move a house"
And buckle under a cake. BM's stats are crazy. |
| Anonymous #1381368 2 months ago |
Wait- Celestia is a Planeswalker and Discord is not? |
| ponybrohoof #1381981 2 months ago |
wtf Celestia is a Planeswalker (and stupidly op broken btw) but Luna/NMM and Discord not? |
| SeaBiscuit #1382458 2 months ago |
I going to print out those basic lands. |
| Anonymous #1382753 2 months ago |
I can see why Luna is a double sided card...but why isn't Discord a Planeswalker? |
| Anonymous #1382799 2 months ago |
All sense of logic and balance out the window I see. |
| BlueYoshi #1383479 2 months ago |
I love the pic you put for each land art. |
| Anonymous #1383753 2 months ago |
Oh, I'll "tap" the great and powerful Trixie all right... |
| PhilSrobeighn #1384757 2 months ago |
For those of you asking, it's a small set. I get one 'Walker to work with if I keep to WotC's apparent formula.
Discord works better as a creature than Celestia so that he can have a static ability can muck with all turns without having to charge up an emblem. Plus, on a personal level, I want Discord as a Commander. |
| Anonymous #1385903 2 months ago |
@OP So? You can make {"Discord, Planeswaker" planeswaker} and {"Discord, Storm of Chaos" legendary creature}, just like Nicol Bolas.
Also, according to current rules, you can have Princess Luna and Nightmare Moon on the battlefield at the same time, because they are Legendary permanents with different names. That's why there are no legendary werewolf in Innistrad block. |
| PhilSrobeighn #1390862 2 months ago |
^Erata NMM to have "Double-faced cards you play enter the battlefield with their back face up."
Also, haters, feel free to substitute card 74 with:  |
| Anonymous #1391088 2 months ago |
Man, shittiest Planeswalker ever. Made for a game type nopony plays and no way to raise his Loyalty Points. |
| Anonymous #1400560 2 months ago |
^Well, duh, Discord always plays his own game.
Also, do even one of you, younglings, remember that thing:  |
| Anonymous #1472467 2 weeks ago |
http://boards.4chan.org/mlp/res/2428676 |