Image
Comments
| Blockhead134 #647525 8 months ago |
Its only because the second one is way better. |
| cthulhlu #647530 8 months ago |
how exactly is the top one fat? |
| AshesOfSaturn #647533 8 months ago |
That's fat? |
| sigh #647536 8 months ago |
Also because fat people can't bounce like Pinkie can. |
| Anonymous #647540 8 months ago |
Because slim Pinkie is better than fat Pinkie |
| Glord #647541 8 months ago |
Anon you can find a fatter human Pinkie than that, can't you? |
| Anonymous #647544 8 months ago |
Pinkie as a pony is about the same body type as the rest of the mane 6. If she is fat, then she would look like Mrs. Cake. |
| Mika #647555 8 months ago |
Wouldn't call the top one fat. A little chubby, but adorably so. It's all just personal preference of the art-style. |
| AshesOfSaturn #647556 8 months ago |
Like this, Glord? >>82257
(Did I do that right?) |
| Anonymous #647558 8 months ago |
^ Then I geuss they have to make the mane 6 fat when humanizing. |
| Mushi #647561 8 months ago |
agreed |
| TBTabby #647572 8 months ago |
Western culture has declared that any female who doesn't look like an Auschwitz survivor is to be considered obese. |
| Glord #647586 8 months ago |
@TBTabby
Yeah, we americans suck. I'd actually like the top one if she wasn't dressed like a slut. |
| Fuzzy_Logic #647611 8 months ago |
nobody called her obese
they called her fat im sorry ifyou dont consider wide-ass thighs and a fat waist and big cheeks and cankles to be fat but you guys those things are PRETTY fat, even if she does have a horrifically anatomically incorrect tiny "abdomen" thing going on |
| AshesOfSaturn #647617 8 months ago |
Also, by 647544's logic, humanizations of the mane six should all have completely identical heights and figures, with only hairstyles and skin tones different. |
| Boomerang503 #647625 8 months ago |
My theory is that she has hyperthyroidism, and I can speak from experience. |
| Anonymous #647699 8 months ago |
Yeah the top one isn't really particularly fat.
Still, as many calories as that girl is burning from bouncing around and casually rending the fabric of spacetime asunder, she's probably gonna look more like the bottom one. |
| Anonymous #647944 8 months ago |
Also, cake hat makes EVERYTHING better. EVERYTHING. |
| RiotGearEpsilon #648077 8 months ago |
Top one is hot as hell |
| Posey #648249 8 months ago |
They're both adorable. |
| Anonymous #648304 8 months ago |
I'm surprised no one made a "Bronies are Hypocrite" comment |
| Anonymous #649101 8 months ago |
Not so much the fat as the trampy look of the top one. |
| Anonymous #649105 8 months ago |
The top is wide-hipped, but remarkably flat.
I don't understand why you guys consider her fat. Poem by anon. |
| Anonymous #650257 8 months ago |
top one isn't fat. ): although her clothes are questionable. bottom one is a little too skinny. :/ i don't picture pinkie pie having that much style either. LOL more kooky and weird. |
| MackTheKnife #651770 8 months ago |
But I like chubby Pinkie <(^-^<) |
| Anonymous #653680 8 months ago |
The top pic isn't that bad. Now the absurd morbidly obese/balloon fetishists is what I personally have a problem with. |
| Anonymous #653800 8 months ago |
Pinkie shouldn't be skinny, but she shouldn't be fat. Curvy, or pleasantly round; THAT sounds more like Pinkie to me. I picture her with a curvy body and a slight pudge, more than fat or skinny. |
| Anonymous #1317272 2 months ago |
I'm perfectly accepting of her being fat, or curvy. but my headcanon is she's skinny. not because I think she's cuter at all. I really like chubby Pinkie. she's freaking adorable. but Pinkie also seems like the kind of person who has an Endomorphic metabolism. I can eat and eat and eat and eat and never gain weight. part of that is due to Adderall, but it's also because I burn off those calories very fast. hyperactive people typically are endomorphic. Pinkie is the most hyper thing ever. ergo, skinny. |