Casey Hartley never knew what he ever wanted to do with his life. He was indecisive, aimless, directionless and hopeless. He was pretty much a loser in many people's eyes. Just some random punkass wannabe who couldn't make good decisions.
Possum Springs was pretty much a boring town, with little to nothing to do. There were rumors here and there about some cult doing something. He didn't know the details, nor did they care. They were just a bunch of nutjobs.
Oh, how he wished he was more careful. The cultists have found him, rambling on about nonsense such as making the town prosperous, happy and pure. But in actuality, would cause more suffering. Casey was the perfect target. He was a nobody, a fuckup, nobody would get any second glances if nobody knew him.
For the first time, he was scared shitless. Two cult members, holding his arms, edging him closer to the end of a pit. He couldn't see with their robes and hoods. But their voices sounded vaguely familiar, they sounded like older people. But he was too scared to even remember.
"No, no, no! Please! Lemme go! Wh-what do you fucks want?!" He cried out, tears streaming down the orange feline's face.
"O Black Goat, accept our humble sacrifice for a prosperous harvest! For the glory and survival of Possum Springs!" One cultist shouted out, and Casey started to panic even more. He was eventually tossed down, screaming bloody murder as his life flashed before his eyes.
His childhood, his parents, all the people in the neighborhood he thought he could trust, and of course, his friends.
'Mae... Bea... Gregg... Angus... I guess I'm fated to die after all.' He thought, closing his eyes and accepting his fate. However, instead of colliding with the ground, he was instead... caught by something.
"Oomph! Are you... are you okay?" Casey heard a male's voice, and his eyes snapped open. He saw a white goat, wearing a purple robe with some black markings. Was this the Black Goat? No. He was white, and he was definitely a monster, but... he seemed genuinely concerned.
Casey was silent, not knowing what to say. He was alive. He was alive and he was saved.
"That was some fall there! Are you okay? You're not hurt are you?" The goat asked, and Casey then shook his head, tears still falling down his cheeks, both of relief and still with fear. What if those old guys come back?
"I-I-I'm fi-fine... I... I was tossed down here." Casey stuttered out, as the white goat's eyes widened in horror as he set the feline down. Now that he looks at him, this robed monster was taller than him.
"B-but why?! Who would do something so... Oh, my apologies. My name is Asriel Dreemurr. I'm the Prince of Monsters. Who are you?" Asriel introduced himself.
"Casey. Casey Hartley. I'm from Possum Springs. A bunch of old cultist guys sacrificed me to some... Black Goat or something." The cat explains, and Asriel didn't seem pleased at that.
"Well, I don't know what Black Goat they're talking about, but I'm not one of them. Oh. Maybe this form is, uh... a little intimidating." Asriel says and with magic, he managed to alter his body, being the same age and height as Casey, who just stares wide eyed. "Is this better?"
Even his voice changed. If this Asriel could do something like this so easily, he might've been older than he thought.
"I wanna go home..." Casey whimpers, he suddenly felt like he was some scared little kid again. Never in his life did he ever think to experience this. Wherever this is. It seemed to be underneath the town somehow, hidden for a long time.
"I'll help you, Casey." Asriel says, holding a hand out to the frightened feline.
Casey hesitated a bit. Could he even trust this Asriel? Either way, he nervously took the monster's hand.
"Th-Thank you." He sniffled. Drying his tears. Asriel smiled warmly before the two looked up at where Casey had fallen from.
"It's a long way back up." The prince pointed out. "I suppose you could climb back up."
Casey's eyes widened. "Huh?? What if I get caught again!?" He panicked.
Asriel placed a hand to his chin. "Oh, right. Didn't think of that…" He said. Asriel appeared to be deep in thought before it clicked. "We could wait a while before you can climb. That way, they won't suspect a thing."
"Oh! Okay, let's try that." Said Casey. "What should we do while we wait?"
"Hmm. That's a good question. We rarely get visitor or go anywhere. But..." Asriel says before he eyes the feline. He was actually quite the looker. And it has been a long time since he was with someone from outside. But he doesn't wanna push into things. "Say, this might seem weird, but... do you have... y'know... someone waiting for you out there?"
"Huh? Oh. I mean, my friends maybe. Or you mean..." It clicked with Casey as he shook his head slowly. "N-nah. Not really. I've looked at some girls and dudes but... it just seems awkward that we kinda... grew together and shit."
Wait, did he say girls AND guys? So he must be bisexual then. That was interesting to know.
"Casey... Do you trust me? You know I'll never hurt you. But... well, it can get kinda lonely at times and..." Asriel explains, as the feline listens to what the prince has to say. "I feel so selfish and I barely know you, but... would you... you and me...?"
They stared at each other in silence, both males blushing. Asriel seemed so ashamed and covered his face with his hands. He must've come off as a creep.
As for Casey, this guy just saved his life. If Asriel wasn't around, or anyone for that matter... He shudders from the thought. And looking closer, he was pretty cute. In this form and his other one. Despite his appearance, he seemed so kind and innocent.
Casey walks over and lowers Asriel's hands.
"I might as well get this outta the way. Maybe this is God's or the Universe's way of saying I have a second chance. So... what the hell." Before Asriel could say anything, Casey cupped the goat's face and kisses him on the lips.
Asriel was surprised that Casey was so open about this despite what just happened, but he kissed back, nonetheless. The two males moaned slightly during the kiss as they even started embracing each other. The kiss got to the point where Asriel groped Casey's ass. He didn't seem to mind, though, as he shuddered and moaned louder.
They eventually broke away. "Hah… Not bad~" Asriel breathed. "Have you done this before?"
Casey blushed. "Not really; I just did what felt natural." He sheepishly explained.
"Ah, I see." Asriel replied. "So, should we…? Y'know…"
Casey put two and two together. "Oh! Right, I guess that's a given. Heheh!" He chuckled.
Casey and Asriel began stripping down. Adrenaline rushing through their veins. When they were fully nude, they couldn't help but notice that they both had such feminine frames. "Lookin' good, Casey~" Asriel complimented.
Casey blushed and smiled. "Thanks~" He replied. "So, uh… Can I go first? If you don't mind, that is."
"I don't mind one bit." Said Asriel as Casey got down on his knees. "Go on; there's no rush."
Casey then started fondling Asriel's balls with his hands as he opened his mouth, taking the head of the goat's cock inside. He bobs his head slowly, staring up at the other male. Asriel lets out a couple of cute moans, feeling the warmth around his erection.
"Mmmh... Oohh, this feels good... You sure you haven't done this before?" Asriel teases, and Casey blushes, shaking his head. "Well, you're a natural~"
Casey's heart flutters from the compliment. He didn't think he was that good. But if Asriel said so...
The orange feline male tried taking more of Asriel's cock, but he was having a bit of trouble. He broke for air a couple of times.
"S-sorry..." He muttered, before trying again, however, Asriel didn't seem annoyed or angry. He was very patient.
"It's all good; just keep going~" Asriel breathed before letting out another moan. "Mmn! That's it, baby~"
He didn't know where that came from, but hey! Casey didn't seem to mind. He just continued bobbing his head. Asriel rested a hand on the back of the feline's head as he made his announcement. "I-I think I'm close~" He groaned.
Casey looked up at the prince with a lusty gaze as if to say 'Go for it!'. And with one loud moan, Asriel came down Casey's throat. The cat's eyes widened, but when he tasted it, he closed them again in content. It wasn't all that bad, truth be told~ Asriel let go of Casey's head as he pulled away and swallowed the rest of his cum.
"Phaa… Hah… So yummy~" He breathed.
Asriel chuckled a bit. "Heheh! Glad you liked that, Casey. I know I sure did~" He said before helping him up. "Anyway, I guess it's my turn, huh?"
Casey watched as Asriel got onto his knees and immediately took the feline's length into his mouth. Casey groaned loudly as his legs almost buckled from the pleasure. "A-Aaah! Whoa~" He breathed. Damn, Asriel was a natural right out the gate!
Casey watched as Asriel sucked like a pro. There was no doubt he's done this many times before. He could feel the goat wrapping his arms around Casey's waist, groping his ass, he continues bobbing and sucking the feline's shaft.
"A-aahh... Ooohhh, holy fuck, dude...~ Th-this is amazing...!~" Casey breathed out, panting as the male goat swirled his tongue. He then felt one hand cupping and groping his balls, and the other poking and rubbing against his entrance, earning a cute squeak. "H-nhn!~ O-oh fuck me...!"
'Oh, I will cutie~' Asriel thought lewdly, he smiles, taking more of the length inside, while also adding more pleasure to Casey. It was even a struggle not to collapse right then and there, he was shaking like a leaf. His cheeks flushed a deep red and breathing heavily.
It was becoming more and more clear that Casey hadn't experienced this before. If that was the case, Asriel would make sure that this would be the experience of his life!
This went on for a bit before Casey felt I’m self reaching climax. "I'm gonna cum!!" He moaned before grabbing the sides of Asriel's head and thrusting down his throat.
Asriel's eyes widened at Casey's sudden forcefulness, but it was a welcome surprise~ Casey practically screamed in ecstasy as he came down the monster's throat. "Aaagh! Take my cum!!" Casey groaned.
 When he was finished, Asriel pulled away and slowly stood back up. "Haaah~" He sighed. "So good!~"
"Say, uh… Asriel?" Casey began.
"Yeees?" Asriel replied teasingly. Secretly knowing what Casey was about to ask.
"Can… Can you… Stick it in me?" He asked. Blushing hard.
Asriel smirked lewdly. "Of course~" He breathed. He watched as Casey leaned up against the wall and show off his glorious bubble butt to the prince. Asriel grabbed hold of the feline's waist and began hotdogging his cock in-between his asscheeks.
"Please…" Casey begged softly. Moving his hips to try and get Asriel's dick in his needy ass.
"Please, what?" Asriel teased. Making sure to milk this for what it's worth.
Casey whimpered, feeling the cock just slowly inching inside, before going back out.
"P-please... f-fuck me...! I-I want it... I need it...!" Casey begged a little louder, and Asriel couldn't help but find him so adorable when he's submissive. He slowly shoves his penis inside, making both males moan. "Hhnh!~ F-fuck... y-yeah...~"
Asriel hugged him close, their bodies touching as he bucked his hips, thrusting inside the orange feline.
"Mmm... so tight~ Relax baby..." Asriel cooed, he then bit down on Casey's shoulder, giving him a hickey. He squeaked from that, before relaxing.
"Hhah... A-Asriel... O-oh God... P-please... d-do whatever... t-to me... p-p-please..." Casey panted out, letting the goat do the work, as he felt each thrust in his ass, the sound of skin slapping and cheeks jiggling could be heard.
Asriel pulled away and whispered into Casey's ear. "You're such a cutie, right Casey?~"
Casey shuddered from the lewd praise. "Mmng… Fuck yeah~" He breathed before Asriel started going harder and faster. "A-Aah! Yes! Fuck me hard, Asriel!!"
Asriel responded by giving Casey's as a nice slap. Causing his cheeks to jiggle some more. "AH!" Casey yelped girlishly at the spank. "Yeees~ Right there!"
"You mean… Here?!" Asked Asriel before thrusting harder and deeper into Casey. His cock hitting his prostate a couple of times. If anything, though, this added to the immense pleasure the two newfound lovers were feeling.
Casey's eyes rolled back as hearts were slowly forming in them. "Yes! Right there! Keep fucking me, Asriel!" He begged and pleaded. Sounding like he'd die without being fucked.
Asriel reached down with one hand, and began stroking Casey's cock, his other hand still holding him tightly.
"Let it all out, Casey~ You're gonna feel great, amazing, a winner~" He whispers to him, before kissing his hickey.
'W-winner...? Y-yeah.' Casey thought as he accepted what was happening.
"M-more, more, more!~ Oh God!~ Asriel!~ ASRIEL!!!~ I'M GONNA FUCKING CUM!!!~" Casey screamed out, leaking out pre as he moved his hips, his prostate getting more and more pleasure.
"Go ahead and cum, cutie~ I'm gonna fill you up like a good kitty~" Asriel says and thrusts faster and harder, Casey couldn't even respond. He has a dumb smile on his face, moaning and panting like he's running through marathon.
"Fuck, fuck, fuck, fuck, fuck!!~ I'M CUMMIIIIINNNGGG!!!~" The orange male cat lets out a gilrish moan, staining the ground as he felt Asriel filling him up.
"Mmgh! Take it, Casey!~" Asriel groaned out, both males groaning in pleasure.
Words couldn't describe how good this felt for both Casey and Asriel. The feline's stomach was even bulging from the sheer amount of cum that was poured into him. When it was all over, Asriel pulled out and stained Casey's bubbly rear with the remainder of his cum.
"Hah… Hah… That was so good~" Casey panted before flopping down. Ass in the air.
Asriel couldn't help but laugh at the state Casey was "Haha! I agree, Casey." He replied. "Well, I guess you can climb back up out of here now."
"B-But… What about you? This feels too good…" Casey asked. Looking at him with despair.
"Oh! Hmm…" Asriel hummed before the revolutionary idea came to him. "You can stay here, if you'd like. Just a thought."
Casey couldn’t hide his big dumb smile. "Yes! I would love that, Asriel~!" he replied before yawning. "Just… Just let me take a quick nap first."
Asriel chuckled before laying down next to Casey and cuddling him close. "Night, Casey~" He breathed before the two of them nodded off in each other's arms.
[…]
Casey had no idea how long he was here for, time had no meaning down below. All he cared about was spending the rest of it with his cute goat lover, Asriel.
Right now, they were in Asriel's room, who the goat shared with Casey. They were on the bed as the cat was rimming the goat's plump ass.
"Mmmm... go ahead and give it to me, cutie~ You know you wanna~" Asriel teased once Casey pulled away, seeing him shake his fat ass in his direction with a cute giggle.
"I'm gonna enjoy this~" Casey replied and shoves his cock inside, both males moan as the cat thrusted inside.
"Ooohh!~ That's it... f-fuck me there!~ Mmhhf...! Y-yeah...~" Asriel didn't keep his slutty moans down, which only added further sexual appeal in Casey's eyes. He spanks his ass, watching his cheeks jiggle upon contact. "Ooh!~ Oh, fuck Casey...~ U-use me... p-pound this slutty prince!~"
Casey happily obliged, leaned forward and pinning him on the bed, returning the favor as he bit down on Asriel's shoulder, a hickey of his own.
"Mmmhh... I-I fucking love you, Asriel. Never, ever leave me...~" Casey whispered, Asriel blushes at the confession, whether Casey was aware or not.
"Promise." Asriel reassured, and all you could heard inside the room was the intense lovemaking and the slapping of flesh.
Casey felt like he was supposed to do something important and go somewhere. But why would he? His new life is spending with Asriel forever~ His new lover and fellow fuckbuddy. As Casey came inside Asriel for what seemed like hours into their session, they sloppily made out as cum leaked out of the goat's used ass.
Right now, Casey felt like the luckiest bastard in the world.
THE END